On reduced modeling of the modulational dynamics in magnetohydrodynamics

S. Jin,I. Y. Dodin

2024-02-20

Abstract:This paper explores structure formation in two-dimensional magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) turbulence as a modulational instability (MI) of turbulent fluctuations. We focus on the early stages of structure formation and consider simple backgrounds that allow for a tractable model of the MI while retaining the full chain of modulational harmonics. This approach allows us to systematically examine the validity of popular closures such as the quasilinear approximation and other low-order truncations. We find that, although such simple closures can provide quantitatively accurate approximations of the MI growth rates in some regimes, they can fail to capture the modulational dynamics in adjacent regimes even qualitatively, falsely predicting MI when the system is actually stable. We find that this discrepancy is due to the excitation of propagating spectral waves (PSWs) which can ballistically transport energy along the modulational spectrum, unimpeded until dissipative scales, thereby breaking the feedback loops that would otherwise sustain MIs. PSWs can be self-maintained as global modes with real frequencies and drain energy from the primary structure at a constant rate until the primary structure is depleted. To describe these waves within a reduced model, we propose an approximate spectral closure that captures them and MIs on the same footing. We also find that introducing corrections to ideal MHD, conservative or dissipative, can suppress PSWs and reinstate the accuracy of the quasilinear approximation. In this sense, ideal MHD is a `singular' system that is particularly sensitive to the accuracy of the closure within mean-field models.

Plasma Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper discusses a problem in magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) concerning the formation of turbulent structures, namely the Modulational Instability (MI). The researchers analyzed the early stage of structure formation using a simplified model, particularly when the background turbulence consisted of a simplified monochromatic main structure. They found that although some popular approximate closure theories, such as quasi-linear approximation, could accurately predict the growth rate of MI under certain conditions, these theories might not qualitatively capture the modulational dynamics and even incorrectly predict the system to be in an unstable state in neighboring parameter regions.

The paper pointed out that this mismatch was due to the presence of Propagating Spectral Waves (PSWs), which self-sustain at a real frequency and continuously absorb energy from the main structure until it is exhausted. To describe these waves in the simplified model, the authors proposed an approximate spectral closure theory that can simultaneously capture modulational behavior and PSWs.

Furthermore, the paper also discovered that introducing conservative or dissipative corrections to ideal MHD can suppress PSWs and restore the accuracy of the quasi-linear approximation. This indicates that ideal inviscid MHD is a "singular" system that is particularly sensitive to the accuracy of closure theories. However, even small deviations from the ideal state and adjustments in turbulent parameters can lead to qualitative inaccuracies in the simplified model.

In conclusion, this paper reveals the limitations of low-order closure theories and proposes new theoretical tools to more accurately understand and simulate the structural evolution in MHD turbulence by analyzing the early stage of structure formation.