Copyleft for Alleviating AIGC Copyright Dilemma: What-if Analysis, Public Perception and Implications

Xinwei Guo,Yujun Li,Yafeng Peng,Xuetao Wei
2024-02-19
Abstract:As AIGC has impacted our society profoundly in the past years, ethical issues have received tremendous attention. The most urgent one is the AIGC copyright dilemma, which can immensely stifle the development of AIGC and greatly cost the entire society. Given the complexity of AIGC copyright governance and the fact that no perfect solution currently exists, previous work advocated copyleft on AI governance but without substantive analysis. In this paper, we take a step further to explore the feasibility of copyleft to alleviate the AIGC copyright dilemma. We conduct a mixed-methods study from two aspects: qualitatively, we use a formal what-if analysis to clarify the dilemma and provide case studies to show the feasibility of copyleft; quantitatively, we perform a carefully designed survey to find out how the public feels about copylefting AIGC. The key findings include: a) people generally perceive the dilemma, b) they prefer to use authorized AIGC under loose restriction, and c) they are positive to copyleft in AIGC and willing to use it in the future.
Computers and Society,Artificial Intelligence
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper attempts to address the copyright dilemma of Artificial Intelligence Generated Content (AIGC). Specifically, due to the significant social impact brought by the development of AIGC technology, related ethical issues have also garnered widespread attention, among which one of the most pressing problems is the copyright dilemma of AIGC. This dilemma could greatly hinder the development of AIGC and impose substantial costs on society as a whole. The paper explores this issue through the following aspects: 1. **Specific manifestations of the copyright dilemma**: The author uses case studies to illustrate the three main stakeholders involved in AIGC copyright disputes—data owners, model owners, and model users—and discusses the complexity of copyright ownership for each role. 2. **Public perception survey**: By designing a questionnaire survey to understand the public's perception of the AIGC copyright dilemma and their attitude towards adopting "copyleft." 3. **Feasibility analysis**: Through formal hypothesis analysis methods, the paper explores in detail the potential benefits, challenges, and risks that may arise under different scenarios (if a particular stakeholder claims copyright), thereby revealing the complexity of the copyright dilemma. Ultimately, the paper concludes that copyleft is a feasible solution that can alleviate conflicts among stakeholders and promote the development of AIGC. Although copyleft has some limitations, its potential advantage lies in balancing the interests of all parties, thereby advancing social productivity.