General characterisation of Hamiltonians generating velocity-independent forces

Fredy Yip,A. C. H. Cheung
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1751-8121/ad5124
2024-06-27
Abstract:Dynamics generated from Hamiltonians enjoy potential pathways to quantisation, but standard Hamiltonians are only capable of generating conservative forces. Classes of Hamiltonians have been proposed in Berry et al. capable of generating non-conservative velocity-independent forces. Such Hamiltonians have been classified in the past, under the strict assumption that they are polynomial in momentum. This assumption is relaxed here to analyticity. In doing so, broader classes of Hamiltonians are discovered. By considering the Hamiltonian as a function of state space without introducing the Lagrangian and constructing a metric-like tensor, we develop strong general constraints on Hamiltonians generating velocity-independent forces and exhibit a surprising dichotomy between classes of such Hamiltonians. These results are applicable to any spatial domain of any dimension admitting well-defined Hamiltonian dynamics. As an example application, we apply these constraints to classify all Hamiltonian velocity-independent forces in two spatial dimensions, as well as all such Hamiltonians which do not generate an isotropic simple harmonic motion. The case of one spatial dimension is also discussed for the sake of completeness.
Mathematical Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to determine which Hamiltonians can generate velocity - independent forces. Specifically, the standard Hamiltonian form \(H=\frac{1}{2}p^{T}p + U(x)\) can only generate conservative forces, while the author hopes to find a broader class of Hamiltonians that can generate non - conservative and velocity - independent forces (referred to as "curl forces"). To achieve this goal, the author relaxes the restrictions on the momentum polynomial hypothesis in previous studies and instead considers analytic functions, and by introducing the method of metric tensors, derives the general constraint conditions for Hamiltonians that generate velocity - independent forces. ### Main Research Contents 1. **Background and Motivation**: - Standard Hamiltonians can only generate conservative forces. - Non - conservative "curl forces" appear in certain physical systems, such as dipole dynamics in optical electromagnetic fields, rotating flexible shafts, and pendulums with rotational dissipation. - Hamiltonian dynamics provides partial integrability and a natural quantization path, so it is of great significance to study Hamiltonians that generate velocity - independent forces. 2. **Methods**: - Relax the momentum polynomial hypothesis of Hamiltonians and consider analytic functions. - Introduce the metric tensor \(g_{ij}=\partial_{ij}H\), and use its properties to derive the general constraint conditions for Hamiltonians that generate velocity - independent forces. - Simplify the problem through canonical transformations to ensure the universality and independence of the results. 3. **Main Results**: - Derive the general constraint conditions for Hamiltonians that generate velocity - independent forces. - Classify Hamiltonians in one - dimensional and two - dimensional spaces and discover new possibilities. - Prove that in two - dimensional space, Hamiltonians that generate velocity - independent forces can be divided into three forms: anisotropic quadratic type, separable type, and "seesaw" type. 4. **Applications and Discussions**: - Apply the results to specific examples in one - dimensional and two - dimensional spaces, showing different types of Hamiltonians and the forces they generate. - Discuss the relationship between velocity - independent Hamiltonian forces and conservative forces, and introduce the concepts of pseudo - conservative forces and pseudo - irrotational forces. ### Conclusion Through in - depth analysis of the analytic properties of Hamiltonians, this paper successfully expands the class of Hamiltonians that generate velocity - independent forces, providing a new perspective for understanding the generation mechanism of non - conservative forces. These results are not only applicable to specific spatial dimensions but also provide a theoretical basis for future research.