Social Norms in Cinema: A Cross-Cultural Analysis of Shame, Pride and Prejudice

Sunny Rai,Khushang Jilesh Zaveri,Shreya Havaldar,Soumna Nema,Lyle Ungar,Sharath Chandra Guntuku

2024-10-16

Abstract:Shame and pride are social emotions expressed across cultures to motivate and regulate people's thoughts, feelings, and behaviors. In this paper, we introduce the first cross-cultural dataset of over 10k shame/pride-related expressions, with underlying social expectations from ~5.4K Bollywood and Hollywood movies. We examine how and why shame and pride are expressed across cultures using a blend of psychology-informed language analysis combined with large language models. We find significant cross-cultural differences in shame and pride expression aligning with known cultural tendencies of the USA and India -- e.g., in Hollywood, shame-expressions predominantly discuss self whereas Bollywood discusses shame toward others. Pride in Hollywood is individualistic with more self-referential singular pronouns such as I and my whereas in Bollywood, pride is collective with higher use of self-referential plural pronouns such as we and our. Lastly, women are more sanctioned across cultures and for violating similar social expectations e.g. promiscuity.

Computers and Society

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### The Problem the Paper Attempts to Address

This paper attempts to explore and analyze the expressions of shame and pride across different cultures and the social expectations behind them. Specifically, the authors have constructed a dataset containing over 10,000 expressions related to shame and pride, sourced from more than 5,400 Bollywood and Hollywood movies. By combining psychology-guided language analysis and large language models (LLM), the researchers aim to uncover the following points:

1. **Cross-Cultural Differences**: How do expressions of shame and pride differ across cultural backgrounds? For example, in Hollywood movies, expressions of shame are more focused on the individual, whereas in Bollywood movies, shame is more directed towards others.
2. **Social Expectations**: How do social expectations in different cultures influence the expressions of shame and pride? For instance, women face more social sanctions when violating similar social expectations (such as promiscuous behavior).
3. **Gender Differences**: How do men and women differ in expressing shame and pride? The study finds that women express shame more frequently, while men express pride more often.

Through these analyses, the researchers hope to provide new perspectives for understanding social and self-regulation and to support the development of computational models capable of understanding and handling these emotions. This will help in building more culturally sensitive human-computer interaction systems, especially in AI-driven psychotherapy and related fields.