On the importance of parallel magnetic-field fluctuations for electromagnetic instabilities in STEP

D. Kennedy,C. M. Roach,M. Giacomin,P. Ivanov,T. Adkins,F. Sheffield,T. G örler,A. Bokshi,D. Dickinson,H. G. Dudding,B. S. Patel

2024-05-20

Abstract:[ABRIDGED] This paper discusses the importance of parallel perturbations of the magnetic-field in gyrokinetic simulations of electromagnetic instabilities and turbulence at mid-radius in the burning plasma phase of the conceptual high-$\beta$, reactor-scale, tight-aspect-ratio tokamak STEP. Previous studies have revealed the presence of unstable hybrid kinetic ballooning modes (hKBMs) at binormal scales approaching the ion Larmor radius. In this STEP plasma it was found that the hKBM requires the inclusion of parallel magnetic-field perturbations to be linearly unstable. Here, the extent to which the inclusion of fluctuations in the parallel magnetic-field can be relaxed is explored through gyrokinetic simulations. In particular, the frequently used MHD approximation (dropping $\delta \! B_{\parallel}$ and setting the $\nabla B$ drift frequency equal to the curvature drift frequency) is discussed and simulations explore whether this approximation is useful for modelling STEP plasmas. It is shown that the MHD approximation can reproduce some of the linear properties of the full STEP gyrokinetic system, but is too stable at low $k_y$ and nonlinear simulations using the MHD approximation result in very different transport states. It is demonstrated that the MHD approximation is challenged by the high $\beta^{\prime}$ values in STEP, and that the approximation improves considerably at lower $\beta^{\prime}$. Furthermore, it is shown that the sensitivity of STEP to $\delta \! B_{\parallel}$ fluctuations is primarily because the plasma sits close to marginality and it is shown that in slightly more strongly driven conditions the hKBM is unstable without $\delta \! B_{\parallel}.$ Crucially, it is demonstrated that the state of large transport typically predicted by local electromagnetic gyrokinetic simulations of STEP plasmas is not solely due to $\delta \! B_{\parallel}$ physics.

Plasma Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to address the linear and nonlinear characteristics of electromagnetic instabilities, especially the hybrid kinetic ballooning mode (hKBM), in the high - β, compact fusion reactor design of STEP (Spherical Tokamak for Energy Production). Specifically, the focus of the study is on the influence of perturbations in the parallel magnetic field (δB∥) on these instabilities and whether the MHD approximation can be used to simulate these phenomena.

### Background and Objectives of the Paper
- **Background**: In magnetically - confined fusion devices, such as spherical tokamaks (STs), turbulent fluctuations usually dominate the transport losses of heat, particles, and momentum. Therefore, understanding and predicting turbulent transport in next - generation STs is crucial for optimizing their performance. The STEP project aims to achieve fusion power generation with a net electrical output exceeding 100 MW by developing a compact prototype power plant based on the ST concept.
- **Objectives**: This paper mainly explores the importance of parallel magnetic field perturbations (δB∥) in electromagnetic instabilities and turbulence in STEP burning plasma phases. In particular, it investigates whether ignoring δB∥ will affect the linear instability of hKBM under high - β conditions and evaluates the applicability of the MHD approximation in STEP plasma modeling.

### Main Findings
- **Linear Stability of hKBM**: Research shows that in STEP plasma, hKBM needs to include parallel magnetic field perturbations to be linearly unstable. If δB∥ is ignored, hKBM becomes stable, and the sub - dominant micro - tearing mode (MTM) becomes the most unstable mode in the system.
- **Applicability of the MHD Approximation**: The MHD approximation (i.e., ignoring δB∥ and making the ∇B drift frequency equal to the curvature drift frequency) can partially reproduce the linear characteristics of the complete STEP gyrokinetic system in some cases, but it is overly stable at low ky values, and the nonlinear simulation results are significantly different from the full - physics model.
- **Challenges under High - β′ Conditions**: The MHD approximation faces challenges in STEP plasma with high - β′ values, but performs better at lower β′ values. In addition, it is found that the sensitivity to δB∥ is particularly evident when the plasma is close to the marginally stable state. Under slightly stronger driving conditions, hKBM can be unstable even without δB∥.

### Conclusions
- **Importance of δB∥**: In STEP plasma, δB∥ is crucial for the instability of hKBM, especially when the plasma is close to the marginally stable state.
- **Limitations of the MHD Approximation**: Although the MHD approximation can partially reproduce linear characteristics under certain conditions, it has significant deficiencies in describing nonlinear transport states. In particular, the MHD approximation performs poorly under high - β′ conditions.
- **Future Research Directions**: To more accurately describe hKBM - driven turbulence, δB∥ needs to be introduced in global simulations, and its sensitive dependence on hybrid modes needs to be further studied.

Through these studies, the authors provide important theoretical and experimental bases for understanding electromagnetic instabilities in STEP plasma, and provide valuable references for future fusion reactor design and optimization.