Abstract:A mapping is made between fermion exchange and excluded volume in the quantum-classical isomorphism using polymer self-consistent field theory. Apart from exchange, quantum particles are known to be exactly representable in classical statistical mechanics as ring polymers, with contours that are parametrized by the inverse thermal energy, often called the imaginary time. Evidence in support of a previously used approximation for fermion exchange in ring polymer self-consistent field theory is given, specifically, that the use of all-contour interactions in the mean field picture instead of equal imaginary time interactions is justified based on the symmetry of ring polymers. It is also shown that the removal of forbidden thermal trajectories, both those that violate excluded volume directly and those that represent topologically inaccessible microstates, is equivalent to antisymmetric exchange. The electron density of the beryllium atom is calculated with ring polymer self-consistent field theory ignoring classical correlations, and very good agreement is found with Hartree-Fock theory which also neglects Coulomb correlations. The total binding energies agree to within less than 6%, which while still far from chemical accuracy, is remarkable given that the field theory equations are derived from first principles with zero free parameters. The discrepancy between self-consistent field theory and Hartree-Fock theory is attributed to classical Coulomb self-interactions which are included in Hartree-Fock theory but not in self-consistent field theory. A potential method to improve the agreement by more accurately representing electron-electron self-interactions in self-consistent field theory is discussed, as are the implications for quantum foundations of the quantum-classical mapping between fermion exchange and thermal trajectory excluded volume.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to address the problem of how to handle fermion exchange in quantum-classical equivalent mapping. Specifically, the authors aim to relate fermion exchange to thermal trajectory excluded volume through ring polymer self-consistent field theory (RP-SCFT), thereby describing the quantum behavior of fermion systems within the framework of classical statistical mechanics. ### Main Issues: 1. **Classical Explanation of Fermion Exchange**: Existing quantum-classical equivalent mapping methods are mainly applicable to boson systems because boson exchange can naturally be explained by the merging and splitting of ring polymers. However, for fermion systems, there is no similar classical explanation. The authors attempt to fill this gap by proposing a method to relate fermion exchange to thermal trajectory excluded volume. 2. **Theoretical Validation**: The authors need to verify whether this new mapping method can accurately describe the properties of fermion systems, particularly electron density and binding energy. This includes validating the method's effectiveness and accuracy in practical applications through numerical calculations. ### Specific Goals: - **Establish Mathematical Foundation**: Through mathematical derivation, prove that fermion exchange can be described by thermal trajectory excluded volume and provide the corresponding formulas. - **Numerical Validation**: Use the beryllium atom as a test case, calculate its electron density and binding energy through RP-SCFT, and compare it with Hartree-Fock theory to verify the new method's effectiveness. - **Discuss Improvement Methods**: Explore how to further improve the method, especially in handling electron-electron interactions, to more accurately represent electron self-interaction. ### Methods and Results: - **Theoretical Part**: The authors derive formulas describing fermion exchange through ring polymer self-consistent field theory, particularly equations (10) and (11), which consider the excluded volume of particle trajectories and topologically inaccessible conformations. - **Numerical Calculations**: Using numerical methods to calculate the electron density and binding energy of the beryllium atom, the results show very good agreement with Hartree-Fock theory, with a total binding energy error of less than 6%. - **Discussion**: Although the results are satisfactory, the authors point out that the remaining discrepancies are mainly due to the approximate treatment of electron-electron self-interaction in SCFT. They propose improvement methods, such as combining energy methods and entropy methods, to further enhance calculation accuracy. ### Conclusion: The authors successfully relate fermion exchange to thermal trajectory excluded volume and validate the method's effectiveness through numerical calculations. This achievement not only provides a new theoretical foundation for quantum-classical equivalent mapping of fermion systems but also offers a potential pathway for further research into complex quantum many-body systems.

Fermion exchange in ring polymer self-consistent field theory

Fermions with long and finite range interactions on a quantum ring

A multi-species exchange model for fully fluctuating polymer field theory simulations

Connecting polymers to the quantum Hall plateau transition

Convergence of direct space exchange lattice sums in polymer band structure calculations

Precision Thermodynamics of the Fermi polaron at strong coupling

Self-dual solutions of a field theory model of two linked rings

Polymer-Mode-Coupling Theory of Finite-Size-Fluctuation Effects in Entangled Solutions, Melts and Gels. II. Comparison with Experiment

Electronic Force Density Fields: Insights into Partial Bonds, Transition States, and Chemical Structure Evolution

Exploring thermal equilibria of the Fermi-Hubbard model with variational quantum algorithms

Self–dual solutions of a field theory model of two linked rings

Density Functional Theory for Inhomogeneous Mixtures of Polymeric Fluids

Symmetry breaking and restoration on a fermionic quantum ring

Dynamical exchange-correlation potential formalism for spin-$\frac{1}{2}$ Heisenberg and Hubbard chains: the antiferromagnetic/half-filled case

Field-theoretical approach to a dense polymer with an ideal binary mixture of clustering centers

Nonadiabatic dynamics with quantum nuclei: simulating charge transfer with ring polymer surface hopping

'Return to equilibrium' for weakly coupled quantum systems: a simple polymer expansion

Self-Consistent Field Theory of Mixtures of Flexible Polymers and Small Liquid Crystalline Molecules

Directed-polymer systems explored via their quantum analogs: General polymer interactions and their consequences

The Polymer representation for the scalar field: A Wigner functional approach

Spin liquid phase in the semiclassical theory of the Heisenberg model on an anisotropic triangular lattice with ring exchange