Universal low-temperature fluctuation of unconventional superconductors revealed: 'Smoking gun' leaves proper bosonic superfluidity the last theory standing

Anthony Hegg,Ruoshi Jiang,Jie Wang,Jinning Hou,Tao Zeng,Yucel Yildirim,Wei Ku

2024-06-26

Abstract:Low-temperature thermal fluctuations offer an essential window in characterizing the true nature of a quantum state of matter, a quintessential example being Fermi liquid theory. Here, we examine the leading thermal fluctuation of the superfluid density across numerous families ranging from relatively conventional to highly unconventional superconductors (MgB$_2$, bismuthates, doped buckyballs, heavy fermions, UTe$_2$, doped SrTiO$_3$, Chevrel clusters, intermetallics, organic superconductors, transition metal dichalcogenides, ruthenates, iron-pnictides, cuprates, and kagome metals). Amazingly, in all of them an unprecedented universal $T^3$ depletion materializes in the low-temperature superfluid density, even in the believed-to-be-conventional MgB$_2$. This reveals a new quantum superfluid state of matter and requires a necessary change of paradigm in describing modern superconductors. We demonstrate that such unorthodox yet generic behavior can be described by a strictly Galilean consistent theory of bosonic superfluidity hosting a long-lived 'true condensate'.

Superconductivity,Strongly Correlated Electrons

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve

This paper attempts to reveal the thermal fluctuation characteristics of unconventional superconductors at low temperatures and explore the new quantum superfluid states behind these characteristics. Specifically, the paper focuses on the thermal fluctuations of superfluid density at low temperatures in a range of superconducting materials from relatively conventional to highly unconventional (such as MgB₂, bismuthates, doped fullerenes, heavy fermions, UTe₂, doped SrTiO₃, Chevrel clusters, intermetallic compounds, organic superconductors, transition metal dichalcogenides, ruthenates, iron-based superconductors, copper-based superconductors, and kagome metals).

### Main Findings

1. **Universal T³ Depletion Phenomenon**:
- In all studied superconducting materials, regardless of their superconducting gap structure (whether fully gapped or nodal), the low-temperature superfluid density exhibits an unprecedented universal T³ depletion phenomenon.
- This phenomenon appears not only in relatively conventional MgB₂ but also in highly unconventional superconductors.

2. **New Quantum Superfluid State**:
- This universal T³ depletion phenomenon reveals a new quantum superfluid state that cannot be explained by existing theories, requiring a paradigm shift in the description of modern superconductors.
- The authors propose a rigorous Galilean-invariant bosonic superfluid theory that can describe the characteristics of this new quantum state.

### Theoretical Framework

1. **Rigorous Galilean Invariance**:
- By introducing long-lived fully dressed eigenparticles, the authors develop a rigorous quantum theory that strictly maintains particle number conservation and includes the necessary inertial mass velocity term.
- This theory equates the superfluid density strictly with the "true condensate" density, naturally resulting in the identified universal T³ thermal fluctuation.

2. **Microscopic Definition of Superfluid Density**:
- The authors define a rigorous microscopic superfluid current excitation through the irrotational nature of the superfluid current.
- This definition ensures that only the fluctuations of eigenparticles in the true condensate contribute to the superfluid current fluctuations.

### Experimental Verification

1. **Numerical Verification**:
- Through standard quantum Monte Carlo calculations, the authors verify the T³ thermal depletion phenomenon in the 3D Bose-Hubbard model, consistent with experimental results.
- This numerical verification further supports the theoretical framework proposed by the authors.

### Conclusion

By analyzing published experimental data, the paper reveals that almost all modern superconducting materials exhibit a universal T³ thermal depletion phenomenon at low temperatures. This phenomenon cannot be explained by existing standard theories, necessitating a new theoretical framework. The authors propose a rigorous Galilean-invariant bosonic superfluid theory that can naturally explain this phenomenon and reveal that the unconventional superconductivity in these materials is described by the charged superfluid state of emergent bosons.