Towards Faithful and Robust LLM Specialists for Evidence-Based Question-Answering

Tobias Schimanski,Jingwei Ni,Mathias Kraus,Elliott Ash,Markus Leippold
2024-06-04
Abstract:Advances towards more faithful and traceable answers of Large Language Models (LLMs) are crucial for various research and practical endeavors. One avenue in reaching this goal is basing the answers on reliable sources. However, this Evidence-Based QA has proven to work insufficiently with LLMs in terms of citing the correct sources (source quality) and truthfully representing the information within sources (answer attributability). In this work, we systematically investigate how to robustly fine-tune LLMs for better source quality and answer attributability. Specifically, we introduce a data generation pipeline with automated data quality filters, which can synthesize diversified high-quality training and testing data at scale. We further introduce four test sets to benchmark the robustness of fine-tuned specialist models. Extensive evaluation shows that fine-tuning on synthetic data improves performance on both in- and out-of-distribution. Furthermore, we show that data quality, which can be drastically improved by proposed quality filters, matters more than quantity in improving Evidence-Based QA.
Computation and Language,Machine Learning
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to improve the reliability and traceability of large - language models (LLMs) in evidence - based question answering (Evidence - Based QA). Specifically, the paper focuses on two main challenges: 1. **Data Scalability (Fine - Tuning Data Scalability)**: Manually annotating data for instruction tuning is costly, and data synthesized using LLMs may be of low quality, resulting in sub - optimal fine - tuning performance. 2. **Generalizability after Fine - tuning**: Previous research has shown that diverse instruction tuning can improve the generalizability of LLMs. Therefore, an intuitive concern is that fine - tuning LLMs on evidence - based question - answering data may turn the model into an expert model lacking generalizability, making it difficult to handle out - of - distribution (OOD) problems and evidence. To address these issues, the paper proposes a data - generation pipeline to synthesize high - quality training and test data and evaluates the performance of the fine - tuned model through four test sets. The experimental results show that data quality is more important than quantity, and fine - tuning on synthetic data can significantly improve the evidence - based question - answering performance of the model in the target application.