Continuum of spin excitations in an ordered magnet

Jieming Sheng,Le Wang,Wenrui Jiang,Han Ge,Nan Zhao,Tiantian Li,Maiko Kofu,Dehong Yu,Wei Zhu,Jia-Wei Mei,Zhentao Wang,Liusuo Wu

2024-02-12

Abstract:Continuum of spin excitations observed in inelastic neutron scattering experiments are often considered as a strong evidence of quantum spin liquid formation. When quantum spin liquid is indeed the ground state of a disorder-free magnetic compound, the elementary excitation is no longer the conventional spin waves (magnons). Instead, the magnons fractionalize into spinons, leaving only a two-spinon continuum detectable in inelastic neutron scattering experiments. For a clean ordered antiferromagnet, it was unclear if we can observe a continuous spectrum similar to the ones in a quantum spin liquid state. Here we show that the magnetically ordered state in Na$_2$BaCo(PO$_4$)$_2$ is able to host a spin excitation continuum induced by strong quantum fluctuations. Thus, a second thought is necessary when concluding such continuum as signature of quantum spin liquid in new material explorations.

Strongly Correlated Electrons

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the question of whether a continuous spin excitation spectrum, similar to that in Quantum Spin Liquids (QSL), can be observed in a magnetically ordered material. Specifically, the researchers explored whether a spin excitation continuum induced by strong quantum fluctuations exists in the magnetically ordered compound Na₂BaCo(PO₄)₂.

### Background and Motivation
1. **Quantum Spin Liquid**: Quantum Spin Liquid is a special quantum state where spins do not exhibit long-range order but form a highly entangled state. This state is usually associated with geometric frustration and quantum fluctuations and is considered an important platform for realizing fault-tolerant quantum computing and understanding unconventional superconductivity mechanisms.
2. **Continuous Spin Excitation Spectrum**: In Quantum Spin Liquids, traditional spin waves (i.e., magnons) split into spinons, forming a continuous spin excitation spectrum. This feature can be observed in inelastic neutron scattering experiments.
3. **Magnetically Ordered Materials**: In magnetically ordered materials, clear spin waves are typically expected rather than a continuous spin excitation spectrum. However, researchers have found that in some magnetically ordered materials, a similar continuum can also be observed, prompting an in-depth exploration of the underlying physical mechanisms.

### Research Questions
- **Primary Question**: Can a spin excitation continuum induced by strong quantum fluctuations be observed in the magnetically ordered material Na₂BaCo(PO₄)₂?
- **Secondary Questions**:
- Can this continuum be considered a unique signature of Quantum Spin Liquids?
- Does this continuum also exist in other magnetically ordered materials?

### Methods and Results
1. **Experimental Methods**: The researchers used inelastic neutron scattering (INS) techniques to measure the spin excitation spectrum of Na₂BaCo(PO₄)₂ under different magnetic fields in detail.
2. **Theoretical Analysis**: Using linear spin wave theory (LSW) and density matrix renormalization group (DMRG) calculations, the researchers provided a theoretical interpretation of the experimental results.
3. **Main Findings**:
- At zero magnetic field, Na₂BaCo(PO₄)₂ exhibits long-range magnetic order, but its spin excitation spectrum is a continuum rather than the expected clear spin waves.
- This continuum is induced by strong quantum fluctuations rather than disorder effects.
- Theoretical calculations indicate that this continuum is an intrinsic property of the triangular lattice XXZ model, observable even in a long-range magnetically ordered state.

### Conclusion
- **Main Conclusion**: In the magnetically ordered material Na₂BaCo(PO₄)₂, strong quantum fluctuations can lead to the formation of a spin excitation continuum, challenging the traditional view of directly associating a continuum with Quantum Spin Liquids.
- **Significance**: This finding reminds researchers to more cautiously evaluate the origin of the continuum when exploring new Quantum Spin Liquid candidate materials, rather than simply attributing it to Quantum Spin Liquids.

Through this study, the authors provide a new perspective on understanding the role of quantum fluctuations in magnetically ordered materials and offer important references for future research.