Bounds on Growth and Impossibility of Collapse for Point Vortex Systems

Samuel Zbarsky

2024-02-12

Abstract:We consider 2D point vortex systems and, under certain conditions on the masses of the point vortices, prove that collapse is impossible and provide bounds on the growth of the system. The bounds are typically of the form $O(t^a)$ for some $a<1/2$, but we obtain various results for various assumptions on the masses.

Classical Analysis and ODEs

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

On the Dynamics of Point Vortices with Positive Intensities collapsing with the boundary

Martin Donati,Ludovic Godard-Cadillac,Dragos Iftimie

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physd.2024.134402

2024-10-17

Abstract:In this paper, we study the point-vortex dynamics with positive intensities. We show that in the half-plane and in a disk, collapses of point vortices with the boundary in finite time are impossible, hence the solution of the dynamics is global in time. We also give some necessary conditions for the existence of collapses with the boundary in general smooth bounded domains, in particular, that the trajectory of at least one point vortex has no limit. Some minor results are obtained with unsigned intensities.

Analysis of PDEs
The strength of a pair of point vortices in an incompressible inviscid fluid in 3d can blow up in finite time

Matthew Radley Brown

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1507.01897

2015-07-04

Abstract:The evolution of a pair of point vortices in whole space, subject to the inviscid Euler equations for incompressible fluid flow, is solved exactly for rotationally symmetric initial conditions. This exact solution shows that the vortex strength for a pair of point vortices can either remain stable or blow up in finite time, depending on the initial data.

Fluid Dynamics
Burst of Point Vortices and Non-uniqueness of 2D Euler Equations

Francesco Grotto,Umberto Pappalettera

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00205-022-01784-2

2022-05-10

Archive for Rational Mechanics and Analysis

Abstract:We give a rigorous construction of solutions to the Euler point vortices system in which three vortices burst out of a single one in a configuration of many vortices; equivalently we show that there exist configurations of arbitrarily many vortices in which three of them collapse in finite time. As an intermediate step, we show that well-known self-similar bursts and collapses of three isolated vortices in the plane persist under a sufficiently regular external perturbation. We also discuss how our results produce examples of non-unique weak solutions to 2-dimensional Euler's equations—in the sense introduced by Schochet—in which energy is dissipated.

mathematics, applied,mechanics
Decay of time correlations in point vortex systems

Francesco Grotto,Silvia Morlacchi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physd.2024.134169

IF: 3.751

2024-04-27

Physica D Nonlinear Phenomena

Abstract:The dynamics of a large point vortex system whose initial configuration consists in uniformly distributed independent positions is investigated. Time correlations of local observables of the vortex configuration are shown to be compatible with power law decay 1/t , providing additional insight on ergodicity and mixing properties of equilibrium dynamics in point vortex models.

mathematics, applied,physics, mathematical, multidisciplinary, fluids & plasmas
Collapse of generalized Euler and surface quasigeostrophic point vortices

Gualtiero Badin,Anna M Barry

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevE.98.023110

Abstract:Point-vortex models are presented for the generalized Euler equations, which are characterized by a fractional Laplacian relation between the active scalar and the stream function. Special focus is given to the case of the surface quasigeostrophic (SQG) equations, for which the existence of finite-time singularities is still a matter of debate. Point-vortex trajectories are expressed using Nambu dynamics. The formulation is based on a noncanonical bracket and allows for a geometrical interpretation of trajectories as intersections of level sets of the Hamiltonian and Casimir. Within this setting, we focus on the collapse of solutions for the three-point-vortex model. In particular, we show that for SQG the collapse can be either self-similar or non-self-similar. Self-similarity occurs only when the Hamiltonian is zero, while non-self-similarity appears for nonzero values of the same. For both cases, collapse is allowed for any choice of circulations within a permitted interval. These results differ strikingly from the classical point-vortex model, where collapse is self-similar for any value of the Hamiltonian, but the vortex circulations must satisfy a strict relationship. Results may also shed a light on the formation of singularities in the SQG partial differential equations, where the singularity is thought to be reached only in a self-similar way.
Zero-Noise Selection for Point Vortex Dynamics after Collapse

Francesco Grotto,Marco Romito,Milo Viviani

2023-07-11

Abstract:The continuation of point vortex dynamics after a vortex collapse is investigated by means of a regularization procedure consisting in introducing a small stochastic diffusive term, that corresponds to a vanishing viscosity. In contrast with deterministic regularization, in which a cutoff interaction selects in the limit a single trajectory of the system after collapse, the zero-noise method produces a probability distribution supported by trajectories satisfying relevant conservation laws of the point vortex system.

Fluid Dynamics,Probability
Asymptotic estimates for concentrated vortex pairs

Guodong Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2203.11800

2022-03-22

Analysis of PDEs

Abstract:In [Comm. Math. Phys. 324 (2013), 445--463], Burton-Lopes Filho-Nussenzveig Lopes studied the existence and stability of slowly traveling vortex pairs as maximizers of the kinetic energy penalized by the impulse relative to a prescribed rearrangement class. In this paper, we prove that after a suitable scaling transformation the maximization problem studied by Burton-Lopes Filho-Nussenzveig Lopes in fact gives rise to a family of concentrated vortex pairs approaching a pair of point vortices with equal magnitude and opposite signs. The key ingredient of the proof is to deduce a uniform bound for the size of the supports of the scaled maximizers.
Bounds on field range for slowly varying positive potentials

Damian van de Heisteeg,Cumrun Vafa,Max Wiesner,David H. Wu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/jhep02(2024)175

IF: 6.379

2024-02-24

Journal of High Energy Physics

Abstract:In the context of quantum gravitational systems, we place bounds on regions in field space with slowly varying positive potentials. Using the fact that , where Λ s ( φ ) is the species scale, and the emergent string conjecture, we show this places a bound on the maximum diameter of such regions in field space: ∆ φ ≤ a log(1/ V ) + b in Planck units, where a ≤ , and b is an O(1) number and expected to be negative. The coefficient of the logarithmic term has previously been derived using TCC, providing further confirmation. For type II string flux compactifications on Calabi-Yau threefolds, using the recent results on the moduli dependence of the species scale, we can check the above relation and determine the constant b , which we verify is O(1) and negative in all the examples we studied.

physics, particles & fields
Euler Configurations and Quasi-Polynomial Systems

A. Albouy,Y. Fu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1134/s1560354707010042

2007-01-01

Regular and Chaotic Dynamics

Abstract:Consider the problem of three point vortices (also called Helmholtz’ vortices) on a plane, with arbitrarily given vorticities. The interaction between vortices is proportional to 1/r, where r is the distance between two vortices. The problem has 2 equilateral and at most 3 collinear normalized relative equilibria. This 3 is the optimal upper bound. Our main result is that the above standard statements remain unchanged if we consider an interaction proportional to r b, for any b < 0. For 0 < b < 1, the optimal upper bound becomes 5. For positive vorticities and any b < 1, there are exactly 3 collinear normalized relative equilibria. The case b = −2 of this last statement is the well-known theorem due to Euler: in the Newtonian 3-body problem, for any choice of the 3 masses, there are 3 Euler configurations (also known as the 3 Euler points). These small upper bounds strengthen the belief of Kushnirenko and Khovanskii [18]: real varieties defined by simple systems should have a simple topology. We indicate some hard conjectures about the configurations of relative equilibrium and suggest they could be attacked within the quasi-polynomial framework.
Analytic characterization of stability islands on two point vortex systems

Gil M. Marques,Sílvio Gama,Fernando L. Pereira

2023-07-25

Abstract:In a system of point vortices, there exist regions of stability around each vortex, even if the system is chaotic. These regions are usually called stability islands and they have a morphology that is hard to characterise. We study and characterise them in two point vortex systems in the infinite two-dimensional plane -- the simplest scenario -- by studying the dynamics of passive particles in these environments. We present computations for the perimeter and area of these islands and highlight the analytical expressions that define their boundary.

Chaotic Dynamics,Mathematical Physics
On the optimal rate of vortex stretching for axisymmetric Euler flows without swirl

Deokwoo Lim,In-Jee Jeong

2024-09-29

Abstract:For axisymmetric flows without swirl, we prove the upper bound of $t^{4/3}$ for the growth of the vorticity maximum, which was conjectured by Childress [Phys. D, 2008] and supported by numerical computations from Childress--Gilbert--Valiant [J. Fluid Mech. 2016]. The key is to estimate the velocity maximum by the kinetic energy together with conserved quantities involving the vorticity.

Analysis of PDEs,Mathematical Physics
A transformation between stationary point vortex equilibria

Vikas S Krishnamurthy,Miles H Wheeler,Darren G Crowdy,Adrian Constantin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1098/rspa.2020.0310

Abstract:A new transformation between stationary point vortex equilibria in the unbounded plane is presented. Given a point vortex equilibrium involving only vortices with negative circulation normalized to -1 and vortices with positive circulations that are either integers or half-integers, the transformation produces a new equilibrium with a free complex parameter that appears as an integration constant. When iterated the transformation can produce infinite hierarchies of equilibria, or finite sequences that terminate after a finite number of iterations, each iteration generating equilibria with increasing numbers of point vortices and free parameters. In particular, starting from an isolated point vortex as a seed equilibrium, we recover two known infinite hierarchies of equilibria corresponding to the Adler-Moser polynomials and a class of polynomials found, using very different methods, by Loutsenko (Loutsenko 2004 J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 37, 1309-1321 (doi:10.1088/0305-4470/37/4/017)). For the latter polynomials, the existence of such a transformation appears to be new. The new transformation, therefore, unifies a wide range of disparate results in the literature on point vortex equilibria.
Gibbs Equilibrium Fluctuations of Point Vortex Dynamics

Francesco Grotto,Eliseo Luongo,Marco Romito

2023-08-01

Abstract:We consider a system of N point vortices in a bounded domain with null total circulation, whose statistics are given by the Canonical Gibbs Ensemble at inverse temperature $\beta\geq 0$. We prove that the space-time fluctuation field around the (constant) Mean Field limit satisfies when $N\to\infty$ a generalized version of 2-dimensional Euler dynamics preserving the Gaussian Energy-Enstrophy ensemble.

Probability,Mathematical Physics,Analysis of PDEs
Enstrophy variations in the collapsing process of point vortices

Takeshi Gotoda

2024-10-19

Abstract:We investigate enstrophy variations by collapse of point vortices in an inviscid flow and, in particular, focus on the enstrophy dissipation that is a significant property characterizing 2D turbulent flows. Point vortex is an ideal vortex whose vorticity is concentrated on a point and the dynamics of point vortices on an inviscid flow is described by the point-vortex system. The point-vortex system has self-similar collapsing solutions, which are expected to cause the anomalous enstrophy dissipation, but this collapsing process of point vortices cannot be described by the 2D Euler equations. In this study, we consider point-vortex solutions of the 2D filtered Euler equations, which are a regularized model of the 2D Euler equations, and the filtered-point-vortex system describing the dynamics of them. The preceding studies have proven that there exist solutions to the three filtered-point-vortex system such that they converge to self-similar collapsing orbits of the point-vortex system and dissipate the enstrophy at the event of collapse in the zero limit of a filter scale. In this study, we numerically show that the enstrophy dissipation by the collapse of point vortices could occur for the four and five vortex problems.

Fluid Dynamics
Vortex-carrying solitary gravity waves of large amplitude

Robin Ming Chen,Kristoffer Varholm,Samuel Walsh,Miles H. Wheeler

2024-04-12

Abstract:In this paper, we study two-dimensional traveling waves in finite-depth water that are acted upon solely by gravity. We prove that, for any supercritical Froude number (non-dimensionalized wave speed), there exists a continuous one-parameter family $\mathcal{C}$ of solitary waves in equilibrium with a submerged point vortex. This family bifurcates from an irrotational uniform flow, and, at least for large Froude numbers, extends up to the development of a surface singularity. These are the first rigorously constructed gravity wave-borne point vortices without surface tension, and notably our formulation allows the free surface to be overhanging. We also provide a numerical bifurcation study of traveling periodic gravity waves with submerged point vortices, which strongly suggests that some of these waves indeed overturn. Finally, we prove that at generic solutions on $\mathcal{C}$ $\unicode{x2013}$ including those that are large amplitude or even overhanging $\unicode{x2013}$ the point vortex can be desingularized to obtain solitary waves with a submerged hollow vortex. Physically, these can be thought of as traveling waves carrying spinning bubbles of air.

Analysis of PDEs
Existence and Uniqueness for the SQG Vortex-Wave System when the Vorticity is Constant near the Point-Vortex

Dimitri Cobb,Martin Donati,Ludovic Godard-Cadillac

2024-01-05

Abstract:This article studies the vortex-wave system for the Surface Quasi-Geostrophic equation with parameter 0 < s < 1. We obtained local existence of classical solutions in H^4 under the standard "plateau hypothesis", H^2-stability of the solutions, and a blow-up criterion. In the sub-critical case s > 1/2 we established global existence of weak solutions. For the critical case s = 1/2, we introduced a weaker notion of solution (V-weak solutions) to give a meaning to the equation and prove global existence.

Analysis of PDEs
Stability of two-dimensional steady Euler flows with concentrated vorticity

Guodong Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00208-023-02641-7

2023-05-26

Mathematische Annalen

Abstract:In this paper, we study the stability of two-dimensional steady Euler flows with sharply concentrated vorticity in a bounded domain. These flows are obtained as maximizers of the kinetic energy on some isovortical surface, under the constraint that the vorticity is compactly supported in a finite number of disjoint regions of small diameter. We prove the nonlinear stability of these flows when the vorticity is sufficiently concentrated in one small region, or in two small regions with opposite signs. The proof is achieved by showing that these flows constitute a compact and isolated set of local maximizers of the kinetic energy on the isovortical surface. The separation property of the stream function plays a crucial role in validating isolatedness.

mathematics
The geometry of the space of vortices on a two-sphere in the Bradlow limit

R.I. Garcia Lara,J.M. Speight

2023-09-15

Abstract:It is proved that the normalized $L^2$ metric on the moduli space of $n$-vortices on a two-sphere, endowed with any Riemannian metric, converges uniformly in the Bradlow limit to the Fubini-Study metric. This establishes, in a rigorous setting, a longstanding informal conjecture of Baptista and Manton.

Differential Geometry

Bounds on Growth and Impossibility of Collapse for Point Vortex Systems

On the Dynamics of Point Vortices with Positive Intensities collapsing with the boundary

The strength of a pair of point vortices in an incompressible inviscid fluid in 3d can blow up in finite time

Burst of Point Vortices and Non-uniqueness of 2D Euler Equations

Decay of time correlations in point vortex systems

Collapse of generalized Euler and surface quasigeostrophic point vortices

Zero-Noise Selection for Point Vortex Dynamics after Collapse

Asymptotic estimates for concentrated vortex pairs

Bounds on field range for slowly varying positive potentials

Euler Configurations and Quasi-Polynomial Systems

Analytic characterization of stability islands on two point vortex systems

On the optimal rate of vortex stretching for axisymmetric Euler flows without swirl

A transformation between stationary point vortex equilibria

Gibbs Equilibrium Fluctuations of Point Vortex Dynamics

Enstrophy variations in the collapsing process of point vortices

Vortex-carrying solitary gravity waves of large amplitude

Existence and Uniqueness for the SQG Vortex-Wave System when the Vorticity is Constant near the Point-Vortex

Stability of two-dimensional steady Euler flows with concentrated vorticity

The geometry of the space of vortices on a two-sphere in the Bradlow limit