A Strong Form of the Quantitative Wulff Inequality for Crystalline Norms

Kenneth DeMason

2024-02-10

Abstract:Quantitative stability for crystalline anisotropic perimeters, with control on the oscillation of the boundary with respect to the corresponding Wulff shape, is proven for $n\geq 3$. This extends a result of [Neu16] in $n=2$.

Analysis of PDEs,Metric Geometry

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

A strong form of the quantitative Wulff inequality for crystalline norms

Kenneth DeMason

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00526-024-02796-4

2024-07-14

Calculus of Variations and Partial Differential Equations

Abstract:Quantitative stability for crystalline anisotropic perimeters, with control on the oscillation of the boundary with respect to the corresponding Wulff shape, is proven for . This extends a result of Neumayer (SIAM J Math Anal 48:172–1772, 2016) in .

mathematics, applied
Strong Stability for the Wulff Inequality with a Crystalline Norm

Alessio Figalli,Yi Ru‐Ya Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/cpa.21928

2020-07-10

Communications on Pure and Applied Mathematics

Abstract:Let K be a convex polyhedron and ℱ its Wulff energy, and let denote the set of convex polyhedra close to K whose faces are parallel to those of K . We show that, for sufficiently small ε , all ε ‐minimizers belong to As a consequence of this result we obtain the following sharp stability inequality for crystalline norms: There exist γ = γ (K , n ) > 0 and σ = σ (K , n ) > 0 such that, whenever ∣E ∣ = ∣ K ∣ and ∣E ΔK ∣ ≤ σ , then In other words, the Wulff energy ℱ grows very fast (with power 1) away from The set appearing in the formula above can be informally thought as a sort of "projection" of E onto Another corollary of our result is a very strong rigidity result for crystals: For crystalline surface tensions, minimizers of ℱ(E ) + ∫E g with small mass are polyhedra with sides parallel to the those of K . In other words, for small mass, the potential energy cannot destroy the crystalline structure of minimizers. This extends to arbitrary dimensions a two‐dimensional result obtained in [9]. © 2020 Wiley Periodicals LLC

mathematics, applied
On crystallization in the plane for pair potentials with an arbitrary norm

Laurent Bétermin,Camille Furlanetto

2024-07-30

Abstract:We investigate two-dimensional crystallization phenomena, i.e. minimality of a lattice's patch for interaction energies, with pair potentials of type $(x,y)\mapsto V(\|x-y\|)$ where $\|\cdot\|$ is an arbitrary norm on $\mathbb{R}^2$ and $V:\mathbb{R}_+^*\to \mathbb{R}$ is a function. For the Heitmann-Radin sticky disk potential $V=V_{\text{HR}}$, we prove, using Brass' key result from [Computational Geometry, 6:195--214, 1996], that crystallization occurs for any fixed norm, with a classification of minimizers and minimal energies according to the kissing number associated to $\|\cdot\|$. The minimizer is proved to be, up to affine transform, a patch of the triangular or the square lattice, which shows how to easily get anisotropy in a crystallization phenomenon. We apply this result to the $p$-norms $\|\cdot\|_p$, $p\geq 1$, which allows us to construct an explicit family of norms for which crystallization holds on any given lattice. We also solve part of a crystallization problem studied in [Arch. Ration. Mech. Anal., 240:987--1053] where points are constrained to be on $\mathbb{Z}^2$. Moreover, we numerically investigate the minimization problem for the energy per point among lattices for the Lennard-Jones potential $V=V_{\text{LJ}}:r\mapsto r^{-12}-2r^{-6}$ as well as the Epstein zeta function associated to a $p$-norm $\|\cdot\|_p$, i.e. when $V=V_s:r\mapsto r^{-s}$, $s>2$. Our simulations show a new and unexpected phase transition for the minimizers with respect to $p$.

Mathematical Physics
Stability of the Wulff shape with respect to anisotropic curvature functionals

Julian Scheuer,Xuwen Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2308.15999

2023-08-30

Analysis of PDEs

Abstract:For a function $f$ which foliates a one-sided neighbourhood of a closed hypersurface $M$, we give an estimate of the distance of $M$ to a Wulff shape in terms of the $L^{p}$-norm of the traceless $F$-Hessian of $f$, where $F$ is the support function of the Wulff shape. This theorem is applied to prove quantitative stability results for the anisotropic Heintze-Karcher inequality, the anisotropic Alexandrov problem, as well as for the anisotropic overdetermined boundary value problem of Serrin-type.
On the stability of the Wulff shape

Julien Roth

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1511.04718

2015-11-15

Differential Geometry

Abstract:Given a positive function F on S n satisfying an appropriate con-vexity assumption, we consider hypersurfaces for which a linear combination of some higher order anisotropic curvatures is constant. We define the varia-tional problem for which these hypersurfaces are critical points and we prove that, up to translations and homotheties, the Wulff shape is the only stable closed hypersurface of the Euclidean space for this problem.
Convex geometric reasoning for crystalline energies

Thaicia Stona de Almeida

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2102.12683

2021-02-25

Analysis of PDEs

Abstract:The present work revisits the classical Wulff problem restricted to crystalline integrands, a class of surface energies that gives rise to finitely faceted crystals. The general proof of the Wulff theorem was given by J.E. Taylor (1978) by methods of Geometric Measure Theory. This work follows a simpler and direct way through Minkowski Theory by taking advantage of the convex properties of the considered Wulff shapes.
Symmetry enforced fractonicity and $2d$ quantum crystal melting

Ajesh Kumar,Andrew C. Potter

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.100.045119

2019-07-17

Abstract:Fractons are particles that cannot move in one or more directions without paying energy proportional to their displacement. Here, we introduce the concept of symmetry enforced fractonicity, in which particles are fractons in the presence of a global symmetry, but are free to move in its absence. A simple example is dislocation defects in a two-dimensional crystal, which are restricted to move only along their Burgers vector due to particle number conservation. Utilizing a recently developed dual rank-2 tensor gauge description of elasticity, we show that accounting for their symmetry enforced one-dimensional nature of dislocation motion dramatically alters the structure of quantum crystal melting phase transitions. We show that, at zero temperature, sufficiently strong quantum fluctuations of the crystal lattice favor the formation of a super-solid phase that spontaneously breaks the symmetry enforcing fractonicity of defects. The defects can then condense to drive the crystal into a super-nematic phase via a phase transition in the $2+1d$ XY universality class to drive a melting phase transition of the crystal to a nematic phase. This scenario contrasts the standard Halperin-Nelson scenario for thermal melting of $2d$ solids in which dislocations can proliferate via a single continuous thermal phase transition. We comment on the application of these results to other scenarios such as vortex lattice melting at a magnetic field induced superconductor-insulator transition, and quantum melting of charge density waves of stripes in a metal.

Strongly Correlated Electrons,Statistical Mechanics
Finite Crystallization and Wulff shape emergence for ionic compounds in the square lattice

Manuel Friedrich,Leonard Kreutz

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1361-6544/ab591f

2020-02-07

Nonlinearity

Abstract:We present two-dimensional crystallization results in the square lattice for finite particle systems consisting of two different atomic types. We identify energy minimizers of configurational energies featuring two-body short-ranged particle interactions which favor some reference distance between different atomic types and contain repulsive contributions for atoms of the same type. We first prove that ground states are connected subsets of the square lattice with alternating arrangement of the two atomic types in the crystal lattice, and address the emergence of a square macroscopic Wulff shape for an increasing number of particles. We then analyze the signed difference of the number of the two atomic types, the so-called net charge, for which we prove the sharp scaling in terms of the particle number n. Afterwards, we investigate the model under prescribed net charge. We provide a characterization for the minimal energy and identify a critical net charge beyond which crystallization in the square lattice fails. Finally, for this specific net charge we prove a crystallization result and identify a diamond-like Wulff-shape of energy minimizers which illustrates the sensitivity of the macroscopic geometry on the net charge.

mathematics, applied,physics, mathematical
Strong existence for free discontinuity problems in linear elasticity

Manuel Friedrich,Camille Labourie,Kerrek Stinson

2024-02-15

Abstract:In this note we show Ahlfors-regularity for a large class of quasiminimizers of the Griffith functional. This allows us to prove that, for a range of free discontinuity problems in linear elasticity with anisotropic, cohesive, or heterogeneous behavior, minimizers have an essentially closed jump set and are thus strong minimizers. Our notion of quasiminimality is inspired by and generalizes previous notions in the literature for the Mumford-Shah functional, and comprises functions which locally close to the crack have at most a fixed percentage of excess crack relative to minimizers. As for the case of minimizers of the Griffith functional, our proof of Ahlfors-regularity relies on contradiction-compactness and an approximation result for GSBD functions, showing the robustness of this approach with respect to generalization of bulk and surface densities.

Analysis of PDEs
Weak crystallization theory of metallic alloys

Ivar Martin,Sarang Gopalakrishnan,Eugene A. Demler

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.93.235140

2015-06-10

Abstract:We extend the Weak Crystallization theory to the case of metallic alloys. The additional ingredient -- itinerant electrons -- generates nontrivial dependence of free energy on the angles between ordering wave vectors of ionic density. That leads to stabilization of FCC, Rhombohedral, and icosahedral quasicrystalline (iQC) phases, which are absent in the generic theory with only local interactions. The condition for stability of iQC that we find, is consistent with the Hume-Rothery rules known empirically for majority of stable iQC; namely, the length of the primary Bragg peak wavevector is approximately equal to the diameter of the Fermi surface.

Materials Science,Soft Condensed Matter,Strongly Correlated Electrons
Maximal Fluctuations on Periodic Lattices: An Approach via Quantitative Wulff Inequalities

Marco Cicalese,Gian Paolo Leonardi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00220-019-03612-3

IF: 2.361

2019-11-06

Communications in Mathematical Physics

Abstract:We consider the Wulff problem arising from the study of the Heitmann–Radin energy of N atoms sitting on a periodic lattice. Combining the sharp quantitative Wulff inequality in the continuum setting with a notion of quantitative closeness between discrete and continuum energies, we provide very short proofs of fluctuation estimates of Voronoi-type sets associated with almost minimizers of the discrete problem about the continuum limit Wulff shape. In the particular case of exact energy minimizers, we recover the well-known, sharp $N^{3/4}$ scaling law for all considered planar lattices, as well as a sub-optimal scaling law for the cubic lattice in dimension $d\ge 3$.

physics, mathematical
Quantization of fractional corner charge in $C_n$-symmetric higher-order topological crystalline insulators

Wladimir A. Benalcazar,Tianhe Li,Taylor L. Hughes

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevB.99.245151

2019-04-21

Abstract:In the presence of crystalline symmetries, certain topological insulators present a filling anomaly: a mismatch between the number of electrons in an energy band and the number of electrons required for charge neutrality. In this paper, we show that a filling anomaly can arise when corners are introduced in $C_n$-symmetric crystalline insulators with vanishing polarization, having as consequence the existence of corner-localized charges quantized in multiples of $\frac{e}{n}$. We characterize the existence of this charge systematically and build topological indices that relate the symmetry representations of the occupied energy bands of a crystal to the quanta of fractional charge robustly localized at its corners. When an additional chiral symmetry is present, $\frac{e}{2}$ corner charges are accompanied by zero-energy corner-localized states. We show the application of our indices in a number of atomic and fragile topological insulators and discuss the role of fractional charges bound to disclinations as bulk probes for these crystalline phases.

Strongly Correlated Electrons
Crystalline invariants of fractional Chern insulators

Ryohei Kobayashi,Yuxuan Zhang,Naren Manjunath,Maissam Barkeshli

2024-07-23

Abstract:In the presence of crystalline symmetry, topologically ordered states can acquire a host of symmetry-protected invariants. These determine the patterns of crystalline symmetry fractionalization of the anyons in addition to fractionally quantized responses to lattice defects. Here we show how ground state expectation values of partial rotations centered at high symmetry points can be used to extract crystalline invariants. Using methods from conformal field theory and G-crossed braided tensor categories, we develop a theory of invariants obtained from partial rotations, which apply to both Abelian and non-Abelian topological orders. We then perform numerical Monte Carlo calculations for projected parton wave functions of fractional Chern insulators, demonstrating remarkable agreement between theory and numerics. For the topological orders we consider, we show that the Hall conductivity, filling fraction, and partial rotation invariants fully characterize the crystalline invariants of the system. Our results also yield invariants of continuum fractional quantum Hall states protected by spatial rotational symmetry.

Strongly Correlated Electrons,Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,High Energy Physics - Theory,Quantum Physics
Thin Film Liquid Crystals with Oblique Anchoring and Boojums

Stan Alama,Lia Bronsard,Dmitry Golovaty

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1907.04757

2020-01-15

Abstract:We study a two-dimensional variational problem which arises as a thin-film limit of the Landau-de Gennes energy of nematic liquid crystals. We impose an oblique angle condition for the nematic director on the boundary, via boundary penalization (weak anchoring.) We show that for strong anchoring strength (relative to the usual Ginzburg-Landau length scale parameter,) defects will occur in the interior, as in the case of strong (Dirichlet) anchoring, but for weaker anchoring strength all defects will occur on the boundary. These defects will each carry a fractional winding number; such boundary defects are known as "boojums". The boojums will occur in ordered pairs along the boundary; for nematic director with angle oblique to the normal vector, they serve to reduce the winding of the phase in two steps, in order to avoid the formation of interior defects. We determine the number and location of the defects via a Renormalized Energy and numerical simulations.

Analysis of PDEs
Origin and stability of generalized Wigner crystallinity in triangular moiré systems

Aman Kumar,Cyprian Lewandowski,Hitesh J. Changlani

2024-09-21

Abstract:Generalized Wigner crystals (GWC) on triangular moiré superlattices, formed from stacking two layers of transition metal chalcogenides, have been recently observed at multiple fractional fillings of the moiré unit cell [Nature 587, 214 - 218 (2020), Nat. Phys. 17, 715 - 719 (2021), Nature 597, 650 - 654 (2021)]. Motivated by these experiments, tied with the need for an accurate microscopic description of these materials, we explore the theoretical origins of GWC at $n=1/3$ and $2/3$ filling. We demonstrate the limitations of theoretical descriptions of these moiré GWCs relying on truncated (finite-range) electron-electron interactions instead of a long-range Coulomb interaction. We validate our findings by studying both classical and quantum mechanical effects at zero and finite temperatures. More generally, we discuss the role of charge frustration in the theoretical extended Hubbard-model phase diagram, identifying a "pinball" phase, a partially quantum melted generalized Wigner crystal with coexisting solid and liquid-like features, with no classical analog. Quantum effects also explain the small, but experimentally detectable, asymmetry in the transition temperatures of the $n=1/3$ and $2/3$ crystals. Our calculations reveal that the charge ordering temperature and the magnetic crossover temperature predicted using the long-range Coulomb interaction are correctly captured with appropriately renormalized nearest-neighbor interactions. The effective nearest-neighbor interaction strength is significantly weaker than previously reported, placing it close to a metal-insulator phase boundary. This observation has implications for future experiments that we discuss. We conclude by studying the dependence of melting temperatures on gate-to-sample separation and we also predict temperature scales at which magnetic crossovers should be observed.

Strongly Correlated Electrons,Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Materials Science
Continuous Crystallization in Hexagonally-Ordered Materials

Gregory M. Grason

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.101.105702

2009-01-08

Abstract:We demonstrate that the phase transition from columnar-hexagonal liquid crystal to hexagonal-crystalline solid falls into an unusual universality class, which in three-dimensional allows for both discontinuous transitions as well as continuous transitions, characterized by a single set of exponents. We show by a renormalization group calculation (to first order in $\epsilon = 4-d$) that the critical exponents of the continuous transition are precisely those of the XY model, which gives rise to a continuous evolution of elastic moduli. Although the fixed points of the present model are found to be identical to the XY model, the elastic compliance to deformations in the plane of hexagonal order, $\mu$, is nonetheless shown to critically influence the crystallization transition, with the continuous transition being driven to first order by fluctuations as the in plane response grows weaker, $\mu \to 0$.

Soft Condensed Matter,Statistical Mechanics
Volume inequalities for asymmetric Wulff shapes

Franz E. Schuster,Manuel Weberndorfer

DOI: https://doi.org/10.4310/jdg/1352297808

2012-10-01

Journal of Differential Geometry

Abstract:Sharp reverse affine isoperimetric inequalities for asymmetric Wulff shapes and their polars are established, along with the characterization of all extremals. These new inequalities have as special cases previously obtained simplex inequalities by Ball, Barthe and Lutwak, Yang, and Zhang. In particular, they provide the solution to a problem by Zhang.

mathematics
Maximal fluctuations around the Wulff shape for edge-isoperimetric sets in ${\mathbb Z^d}$: a sharp scaling law

Edoardo Mainini,Bernd Schmidt

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2003.01679

2020-03-03

Mathematical Physics

Abstract:We derive a sharp scaling law for deviations of edge-isoperimetric sets in the lattice $\mathbb Z^d$ from the limiting Wulff shape in arbitrary dimensions. As the number $n$ of elements diverges, we prove that the symmetric difference to the corresponding Wulff set consists of at most $O(n^{(d-1+2^{1-d})/d})$ lattice points and that the exponent $(d-1+2^{1-d})/d$ is optimal. This extends the previously found `$n^{3/4}$ laws' for $d=2,3$ to general dimensions. As a consequence we obtain optimal estimates on the rate of convergence to the limiting Wulff shape as $n$ diverges.
Limit of the Wulff crystal when approaching criticality for isoperimetry in 2D percolation

Chang-Long Yao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1214/23-EJP1061

2023-11-22

Abstract:We consider isoperimetric sets, i.e., sets with minimal vertex boundary for a prescribed volume, of the infinite cluster of supercritical site percolation on the triangular lattice. Let $p$ be the percolation parameter and let $p_c$ be the critical point. By adapting the proof of Biskup, Louidor, Procaccia and Rosenthal [6] for isoperimetry in bond percolation on the square lattice, we show that the isoperimetric sets, when suitably rescaled, converge almost surely to a translation of the normalized Wulff crystal $\widehat{W}_p$. More importantly, we prove that $\widehat{W}_p$ tends to a Euclidean disk as $p\downarrow p_c$. This settles the site version of a conjecture proposed in [6]. A key input to the proof is the convergence of the limit shapes for near-critical Bernoulli first-passage percolation proved by the author recently.

Probability
Alignment Destabilizes Crystal Orders in Active Systems

Chen Huang,Leiming Chen,Xiangjun Xing

2021-01-01

Abstract:We combine numerical and analytical methods to study two dimensional active crystals formed by permanently linked swimmers and with two distinct alignment interactions. The system admits a stationary phase with quasi long range translational order, as well as a moving phase with quasi-long range velocity order. The translational order in the moving phase is significantly influenced by alignment interaction. For Vicsek-like alignment, the translational order is short-ranged, whereas the bond-orientational order is quasi-long ranged, implying a moving hexatic phase. For elasticity-based alignment, the translational order is quasi-long ranged parallel to the motion and short-ranged in perpendicular direction, whereas the bond orientational order is long-ranged. We also generalize these results to higher dimensions.

A Strong Form of the Quantitative Wulff Inequality for Crystalline Norms

A strong form of the quantitative Wulff inequality for crystalline norms

Strong Stability for the Wulff Inequality with a Crystalline Norm

On crystallization in the plane for pair potentials with an arbitrary norm

Stability of the Wulff shape with respect to anisotropic curvature functionals

On the stability of the Wulff shape

Convex geometric reasoning for crystalline energies

Symmetry enforced fractonicity and $2d$ quantum crystal melting

Finite Crystallization and Wulff shape emergence for ionic compounds in the square lattice

Strong existence for free discontinuity problems in linear elasticity

Weak crystallization theory of metallic alloys

Maximal Fluctuations on Periodic Lattices: An Approach via Quantitative Wulff Inequalities

Quantization of fractional corner charge in $C_n$-symmetric higher-order topological crystalline insulators

Crystalline invariants of fractional Chern insulators

Thin Film Liquid Crystals with Oblique Anchoring and Boojums

Origin and stability of generalized Wigner crystallinity in triangular moiré systems

Continuous Crystallization in Hexagonally-Ordered Materials

Volume inequalities for asymmetric Wulff shapes

Maximal fluctuations around the Wulff shape for edge-isoperimetric sets in ${\mathbb Z^d}$: a sharp scaling law

Limit of the Wulff crystal when approaching criticality for isoperimetry in 2D percolation

Alignment Destabilizes Crystal Orders in Active Systems