Abstract:A key challenge currently encountered in the development of tokamak fusion energy is the large-amplitude ‘edge-localized modes’ (ELMs). Demonstration of an intrinsic small or no ELM regime with good energy confinement, suitable for low rotation and steady-state operation in a metal wall environment, is one of the urgent tasks for the next step fusion development. After a very brief review of recent worldwide progress in developing small/no ELM H-mode regimes for stationary high-performance operations in future tokamak fusion reactors and advances in physical understandings, this talk will focus on the small/no ELM H-mode regimes discovered in the EAST superconducting tokamak, which is capable of long-pulse H-mode operations with metal wall and low plasma rotation as projected for a fusion reactor. A reproducible high-performance stationary H-mode regime with high-frequency grassy ELMs, fELM = 0.5-3 kHz, has been achieved in the EAST tokamak [1] in the parameter range q95 ≥ 5.2 and p ≥ 1.1 with a confinement improvement factor H98y2 up to 1.4 and N up to 2, limited by the total heating power currently available. This regime exhibits good compatibility with high bootstrap current fraction (fBS up to 70% has been achieved) and fully non-inductive operation, accessible in a broad density range, nel/nGW = 0.4-1.1, with the central-line-averaged electron density, nel, up to 6.410m. Particle transport carried by the grassy ELMs provides strong impurity exhaust and good density control, which is important to achieve long-pulse operation with sustained high performance in a metal wall environment. We have uncovered that this small ELM regime is enabled by a wide edge transport barrier (pedestal) with a low density gradient and a high density ratio between the pedestal foot and top. Nonlinear simulations reveal, for the first time, that the underlying mechanism for the observed small ELM crashes is the upper movement of the peeling boundary induced by an initial radially localized collapse in the pedestal, which stops the growth of instabilities and further collapse of pedestal, thus providing a physics basis for mitigating ELMs in future steady-state fusion reactors. This regime is achieved with high poloidal beta p which facilitates the achievement of high bootstrap current fraction fBS, thus reducing the demands on the external current drive, while high edge safety factor q95 can dramatically reduce the tokamak disruption risk. This regime is particularly suited for a high magnetic field steady-state tokamak reactor, such as the China Fusion Engineering Test Reactor (CFETR), as a high magnetic field can offset the reduction in fusion power associated with high q95. The parameter space of the EAST grassy ELM regime appears to overlap with that of the projected baseline scenario of CFETR (q95 = 5.5-7, N ~ 2, fGW ~ 0.7, fBS ~ 50%) with 1 GW fusion power production. This regime is thus proposed as the primary ELM-mitigation solution for CFETR and potentially offers a highly promising operational scenario for future steady-state fusion beyond ITER. High separatrix density makes this regime especially suitable for operation with divertor detachment. A new detachment feedback control scheme, so-called Probe-Radiation-Detachment (PRD) control scheme, has been demonstrated, which use divertor Langmuir probe Tet to judge detachment entry, then use divertor radiation signal to achieve sustained detachment. Energy confinement is typically enhanced by 10% in the grassy ELM regime with neon seeding. As heat accumulation in divertor targets and tungsten sputtering by large-ELM induced heat pulses are the key obstacles to achieve long-pulse high-performance H-mode operation, the grassy ELM regime combined with detachment feedback control provides an integrated solution for power and particle exhaust and long-pulse H-mode operation, applicable to CFETR and beyond. A non-inductive spontaneous no-ELM regime has been achieved in EAST with extensive lithium wall coating or real-time lithium powder/granules injection at relatively low heating power [2]. In this regime, the recycling neutral from the wall surface and pedestal fueling are significantly reduced. Low pedestal fueling is expected in future fusion reactors with high edge pressure. Unlike the high-recycling no-ELM regime with strong electrostatic edge coherent mode (ECM) [3], this regime is accessible at low density (nel <310 m at Ip = 450 kA and nel <3.510 m, at Ip = 500 kA) and has no clear correlation with pedestal fluctuations. ELITE/NIMROD simulations indicate that the low pedestal-foot density and the ion diamagnetic stability effect may play a key role in access to this regime. This regime changes into a low-power small-ELM regime by increasing the pedestal-foot density. The small ELMs greatly facilitate impurity control, which is critical for achieving long-pulse H-mode operations. The record 101s H-mode plasma was obtained in this regime.

ELM-free Enhanced Dα H-mode with Near Zero NBI Torque Injection in DIII-D Tokamak

Observation of ELM-free H-mode in the HL-2A tokamak

ELM Mitigation by Supersonic Molecular Beam Injection into the H-mode Pedestal in the HL-2A Tokamak

Experimental study of elm control by varying toroidal rotation with ctr-nbi on east d

The multi-faced nature of the quasicoherent mode in EDA H-mode

Characterization of the ELM-free Negative Triangularity Edge on DIII-D

A Stationary Long-Pulse Elm-Absent H-Mode Regime in East

Characteristics of Edge-Localized Modes in the Experimental Advanced Superconducting Tokamak (East)

Discovery of stationary operation of quiescent H-mode plasmas with net-zero neutral beam injection torque and high energy confinement on DIII-D

Decoupling of peeling and ballooning thresholds of pedestal stability and reduction in ELM frequency via enhanced turbulence with edge electron cyclotron heating in DIII-D

Role of density gradient driven trapped electron mode turbulence in the H-mode inner core with electron heating

Edge Localized Mode Suppression and Plasma Response Using Mixed Toroidal Harmonic Resonant Magnetic Perturbations in DIII-D

Developing steady state elm-absent h-mode scenarios with advanced divertor configuration in east tokamak

The Dependence of the Impurity Transport on the Dominant Turbulent Regime in ELM-y H-mode Discharges

Advances in the Steady-State Hybrid Regime in DIII-D—a Fully Non-Inductive, ELM-suppressed Scenario for ITER

MHD simulations of formation, sustainment and loss of Quiescent H-mode in the all-tungsten ASDEX Upgrade

Edge-coherent Oscillation Providing Nearly Continuous Transport During Edge-Localized Mode Mitigation by N = 1 Resonant Magnetic Perturbation in HL-2A

Edge Profiles of Electron Temperature and Density During ELMy H-mode in Ohmically Heated TCV Plasmas

Observation of a Fully Non-Inductive H-mode Regime Dominated by the Sporadic-Small Edge-Localized Modes in EAST with a Tungsten Divertor

Advances in understanding high-performance small/no ELM H-mode regimes

Inter-ELM pedestal turbulence dynamics dependence on q 95 and temperature gradient