Abstract:The is no other model or hypothesis verification tool in Bayesian statistics that is as widely used as the Bayes factor. We focus on generative models that are likelihood-free and, therefore, render the computation of Bayes factors (marginal likelihood ratios) far from obvious. We propose a deep learning estimator of the Bayes factor based on simulated data from two competing models using the likelihood ratio trick. This estimator is devoid of summary statistics and obviates some of the difficulties with ABC model choice. We establish sufficient conditions for consistency of our Deep Bayes Factor estimator as well as its consistency as a model selection tool. We investigate the performance of our estimator on various examples using a wide range of quality metrics related to estimation and model decision accuracy. After training, our deep learning approach enables rapid evaluations of the Bayes factor estimator at any fictional data arriving from either hypothesized model, not just the observed data $Y_0$. This allows us to inspect entire Bayes factor distributions under the two models and to quantify the relative location of the Bayes factor evaluated at $Y_0$ in light of these distributions. Such tail area evaluations are not possible for Bayes factor estimators tailored to $Y_0$. We find the performance of our Deep Bayes Factors competitive with existing MCMC techniques that require the knowledge of the likelihood function. We also consider variants for posterior or intrinsic Bayes factors estimation. We demonstrate the usefulness of our approach on a relatively high-dimensional real data example about determining cognitive biases.

A universal robust bound for the intrinsic Bayes factor

Empirical Bayes factors for common hypothesis tests

Modified intrinsic Bayes factor for multivariate regression models

Nonparametric Bayes Factors Based on Empirical Likelihood Ratios.

On Bayes factors for hypothesis tests

The expected demise of the Bayes factor

What is a Bayes factor?

Deep Bayes Factors

A Good check on the Bayes factor

Assessing Bayes Factor Surfaces Using Interactive Visualization and Computer Surrogate Modeling

Fiducialize statistical significance: transforming p-values into conservative posterior probabilities and Bayes factors

On the Null Distribution of Bayes Factors in Linear Regression

An Objective and Robust Bayes Factor for the Hypothesis Test One Sample and Two Population Means

The flaw of averages: Bayes factors as posterior means of the likelihood ratio

Convergence of Pseudo-Bayes Factors in Forward and Inverse Regression Problems

Empirical Bayes in Bayesian learning: understanding a common practice

Compound e-values and empirical Bayes

Bayes factor functions for reporting outcomes of hypothesis tests

A Bayes factor with reasonable model selection consistency for ANOVA model

A puzzle of proportions: Two popular Bayesian tests can yield dramatically different conclusions

The Bayes Factor and Its Implementation in JASP: A Practical Primer