Abstract:Derivatives of differential equation solutions are commonly for parameter estimation, fitting neural differential equations, and as model diagnostics. However, with a litany of choices and a Cartesian product of potential methods, it can be difficult for practitioners to understand which method is likely to be the most effective on their particular application. In this manuscript we investigate the performance characteristics of Discrete Local Sensitivity Analysis implemented via Automatic Differentiation (DSAAD) against continuous adjoint sensitivity analysis. Non-stiff and stiff biological and pharmacometric models, including a PDE discretization, are used to quantify the performance of sensitivity analysis methods. Our benchmarks show that on small stiff and non-stiff systems of ODEs (approximately < 100 parameters+ODEs), forward-mode DSAAD is more efficient than both reverse-mode and continuous forward/adjoint sensitivity analysis. The scalability of continuous adjoint methods is shown to be more efficient than discrete adjoints and forward methods after crossing this size range. These comparative studies demonstrate a trade-off between memory usage and performance in the continuous adjoint methods that should be considered when choosing the technique, while numerically unstable backsolve techniques from the machine learning literature are demonstrated as unsuitable for most scientific models. The performance of adjoint methods is shown to be heavily tied to the reverse-mode AD method used for the vector-Jacobian product calculations, with tape-based AD methods shown to be 2 orders of magnitude slower on nonlinear partial differential equations than static AD techniques. In addition, these results demonstrate the out-of-the-box applicability of DSAAD to differential-algebraic equations, delay differential equations, and hybrid differential equation systems where the event timing and effects are dependent on model parameters, showcasing an ease of implementation advantage for DSAAD approaches. Together, these benchmarks provide a guide to help practitioners to quickly identify the best mixture of continuous sensitivities and automatic differentiation for their applications.

A Comparative Study of Sensitivity Computations in ESDIRK-Based Optimal Control Problems

Analytical Sensitivity Computation Using Collocation Method with Non-Uniform Mesh Discretisation for Numerical Solutions of Optimal Control Problems

A Novel Analytical Second‐order Sensitivity Calculation Approach Using the Finite Element Method for Chemical Engineering Problems

Exploration of methods for computing sensitivities in ODE models at dynamic and steady states

ESDIRK-based nonlinear model predictive control for stochastic differential-algebraic equations

Benchmarking methods for computing local sensitivities in ordinary differential equation models at dynamic and steady states

A C++ implementation of the discrete adjoint sensitivity analysis method for explicit adaptive Runge-Kutta methods enabled by automatic adjoint differentiation and SIMD vectorization

Quasi-Newton Extremum Seeking Control Based on Incremental Recursive Identification.

A Comparison of Automatic Differentiation and Continuous Sensitivity Analysis for Derivatives of Differential Equation Solutions

An Adaptive Partial Sensitivity Updating Scheme for Fast Nonlinear Model Predictive Control

Revisiting Implicit Differentiation for Learning Problems in Optimal Control

An adaptive step size controller for iterative implicit methods

The non-intrusive reduced basis two-grid method applied to sensitivity analysis

Numerical Methods for Optimal Boundary Control of Advection-Diffusion-Reaction Systems

Computing Sensitivities in Evolutionary Systems: A Real-Time Reduced Order Modeling Strategy

Probabilistic ODE Solvers for Integration Error-Aware Numerical Optimal Control

Reduced Desensitization Formulation for Optimal Control Problems

Direct integral pseudospectral and integral spectral methods for solving a class of infinite horizon optimal output feedback control problems using rational and exponential Gegenbauer polynomials

Numerical methods for closed-loop systems with non-autonomous data

Stability of step size control based on a posteriori error estimates

Numerical simulation of differential-algebraic equations with embedded global optimization criteria