Abstract:A detailed theoretical investigation is given which demonstrates that a recently proposed statistical scaling symmetry is physically void. Although this scaling is mathematically admitted as a unique symmetry transformation by the underlying statistical equations for incompressible Navier-Stokes turbulence on the level of the functional Hopf equation, by closer inspection, however, it leads to physical inconsistencies and erroneous conclusions in the theory of turbulence. The new statistical symmetry is thus misleading in so far as it forms within an unmodelled theory an analytical result which at the same time lacks physical consistency. Our investigation will expose this inconsistency on different levels of statistical description, where on each level we will gain new insights for its non-physical transformation behavior. With a view to generate invariant turbulent scaling laws, the consequences will be finally discussed when trying to analytically exploit such a symmetry. In fact, a mismatch between theory and numerical experiment is conclusively quantified. We ultimately propose a general strategy on how to not only track unphysical statistical symmetries, but also on how to avoid generating such misleading invariance results from the outset. All the more so as this specific study on a physically inconsistent scaling symmetry only serves as a representative example within the broader context of statistical invariance analysis. In this sense our investigation is applicable to all areas of statistical physics in which symmetries get determined in order to either characterize complex dynamical systems, or in order to extract physically useful and meaningful information from the underlying dynamical process itself.

Comment on the paper 'Saturation and Multifractality of Lagrangian and Eulerian Scaling Exponents in Three-Dimensional Turbulence'

Saturation and multifractality of Lagrangian and Eulerian scaling exponents in 3D isotropic turbulence

The anomalous scaling exponents of turbulence in general dimension from random geometry

Multifractal Dimension of Lagrangian Turbulence.

Turbulent flows are not uniformly multifractal

Lagrangian Structure Functions in Turbulence: A Quantitative Comparison Between Experiment and Direct Numerical Simulation

Perspectives on scaling and multiscaling in passive scalar turbulence

Scaling Laws in Turbulence

About Universality and Thermodynamics of Turbulence

Universal scaling regimes in rotating fluid turbulence

Universality of scaling and multiscaling in turbulent symmetric binary fluids

Binomial expansion for a linearized map with memory. A Final comment on: "Criticality and the fractal structure of -5/3 turbulent cascades"

On the mathematics of: “Criticality and the fractal structure of −5/3 turbulent cascades”

An Apparatus to Control and Monitor the Para-D2 Concentration in a Solid Deuterium, Superthermal Source of Ultra-cold Neutrons

Statistics of finite scale local Lyapunov exponents in fully developed homogeneous isotropic turbulence

On the physical inconsistency of a new statistical scaling symmetry in incompressible Navier-Stokes turbulence

Logarithmic scaling in the near-dissipation range of turbulence

Lagrangian Statistics for Navier-Stokes Turbulence under Fourier-mode reduction: Fractal and Homogeneous Decimations

Scaling laws and exact results in turbulence *

Self-similar geometries within the inertial subrange of scales in boundary layer turbulence