Link Prediction with Relational Hypergraphs

Xingyue Huang,Miguel Romero Orth,Pablo Barceló,Michael M. Bronstein,İsmail İlkan Ceylan

2024-05-23

Abstract:Link prediction with knowledge graphs has been thoroughly studied in graph machine learning, leading to a rich landscape of graph neural network architectures with successful applications. Nonetheless, it remains challenging to transfer the success of these architectures to relational hypergraphs, where the task of link prediction is over $k$-ary relations, which is substantially harder than link prediction with knowledge graphs. In this paper, we propose a framework for link prediction with relational hypergraphs, unlocking applications of graph neural networks to fully relational structures. Theoretically, we conduct a thorough analysis of the expressive power of the resulting model architectures via corresponding relational Weisfeiler-Leman algorithms and also via logical expressiveness. Empirically, we validate the power of the proposed model architectures on various relational hypergraph benchmarks. The resulting model architectures substantially outperform every baseline for inductive link prediction, and lead to state-of-the-art results for transductive link prediction.

Machine Learning,Artificial Intelligence

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems Addressed by the Paper

The paper aims to address the **link prediction problem in relational hypergraphs**. Specifically, the researchers focus on performing link prediction in **fully relational data**, where each relationship involves multiple nodes (i.e., k-ary relationships). Unlike traditional knowledge graphs, these relationships can involve multiple entities, such as "Hawking went to Oxford University to study physics and obtained a bachelor's degree." This type of relationship can be represented using a relational hypergraph, where each ordered relational hyperedge corresponds to a relational fact.

### Background and Challenges

1. **Limitations of Existing Methods**:
- Existing link prediction methods mainly focus on binary relationships in knowledge graphs, while link prediction tasks in relational hypergraphs are more complex due to the need to handle k-ary relationships.
- Traditional methods like shallow embedding models (e.g., m-TransH, GETD) perform well on certain tasks but are generally inductive and cannot handle relationships between nodes not seen during training.
- Existing graph neural network methods (e.g., G-MPNN, RD-MPNN) attempt to extend to relational hypergraphs but have limited expressive power and cannot fully capture the complexity of k-ary relationships.

2. **Theoretical and Practical Challenges**:
- **Theoretical Analysis**: A deep analysis of the expressive power of existing models is needed to understand their limitations in handling k-ary relationships.
- **Experimental Validation**: New methods need to be validated on multiple benchmark datasets, especially in terms of performance on inductive link prediction tasks.

### Solution

1. **Introducing a New Framework**:
- The researchers propose the **Hypergraph Conditional Message Passing Neural Networks (HC-MPNNs)**, a new framework for inductive link prediction in relational hypergraphs.
- HC-MPNNs use a conditional message passing mechanism to better capture complex relationships between nodes and can initialize nodes differently based on the query during the initialization phase.

2. **Theoretical Analysis**:
- Using a variant of the Weisfeiler-Leman test (hrwl 1), the researchers demonstrate that HC-MPNNs have superior node differentiation capabilities compared to existing HR-MPNNs.
- Through an analysis of logical expressive power, the researchers show that HC-MPNNs can express richer node attributes, especially those dependent on other k nodes.

3. **Experimental Validation**:
- Experiments on multiple relational hypergraph benchmark datasets show that HC-MPNNs significantly outperform existing baseline methods in inductive link prediction tasks.
- The experiments also include ablation studies on initialization and position encoding choices, as well as performance analysis for different arities of relationships.

### Main Contributions

1. **Theoretical Contributions**:
- A rigorous analysis of the expressive power and limitations of existing HR-MPNNs.
- The proposal of the new HC-MPNNs framework, demonstrating its superiority in node differentiation and attribute expression.

2. **Experimental Contributions**:
- Detailed experimental validation on multiple benchmark datasets, showcasing the significant advantages of HC-MPNNs in inductive link prediction tasks.
- Providing detailed experimental settings and results, including standard deviation, execution time, memory usage, and a discussion on computational complexity.

### Conclusion

By introducing the HC-MPNNs framework, the paper successfully addresses the challenges of link prediction in relational hypergraphs, particularly the complexity of handling k-ary relationships. Both theoretical analysis and experimental results indicate that HC-MPNNs have significant advantages in terms of expressive power and practical application.