Stepping into the Right Shoes: The Effects of User-Matched Avatar Ethnicity and Gender on Sense of Embodiment in Virtual Reality

Tiffany D. Do,Camille Isabella Protko,Ryan P. McMahan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/TVCG.2024.3372067

2024-07-15

Abstract:In many consumer virtual reality (VR) applications, users embody predefined characters that offer minimal customization options, frequently emphasizing storytelling over user choice. We explore whether matching a user's physical characteristics, specifically ethnicity and gender, with their virtual self-avatar affects their sense of embodiment in VR. We conducted a 2 x 2 within-subjects experiment (n=32) with a diverse user population to explore the impact of matching or not matching a user's self-avatar to their ethnicity and gender on their sense of embodiment. Our results indicate that matching the ethnicity of the user and their self-avatar significantly enhances sense of embodiment regardless of gender, extending across various aspects, including appearance, response, and ownership. We also found that matching gender significantly enhanced ownership, suggesting that this aspect is influenced by matching both ethnicity and gender. Interestingly, we found that matching ethnicity specifically affects self-location while matching gender specifically affects one's body ownership.

Human-Computer Interaction

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve

This paper aims to explore the impact of matching the ethnicity and gender of users with their virtual selves on the sense of embodiment in virtual reality (VR). Specifically, the researchers examined the following questions through experimental design:

1. **RQ1**: How does matching or not matching the user's ethnicity with their virtual character's ethnicity affect their sense of embodiment in VR?
2. **RQ2**: How does matching or not matching the user's gender with their virtual character's gender affect their sense of embodiment in VR?
3. **RQ3**: How do gender and ethnicity matching interact?

### Background and Motivation

In many consumer-grade virtual reality applications, users typically play predefined roles with very limited customization options, often emphasizing storytelling over user choice. This limitation is particularly evident in some well-known VR games, such as *Half-Life: Alyx*, *Resident Evil Village*, and *Batman: Arkham VR*, where users can only play as preset white characters, with no option to choose different ethnicities and genders.

The researchers are concerned about whether this limitation affects the user's sense of embodiment. The sense of embodiment refers to the comprehensive experience of various sensations when users immerse themselves in a virtual environment and control a virtual body. Previous studies have shown that the sense of embodiment can affect multiple aspects such as distance perception and cognitive performance. Therefore, understanding how the similarity between user characteristics and virtual characters affects the sense of embodiment is of great significance for enhancing the VR user experience.

### Research Methods

The researchers conducted a 2×2 within-subjects experiment, recruiting a total of 32 participants (17 females, 15 males) from different ethnic backgrounds, including Asian, Black/African American, Latino/Hispanic, and White. Each participant experienced four different virtual characters under four conditions:

1. **Complete**: Both ethnicity and gender match.
2. **Ethnicity**: Ethnicity matches, but gender does not.
3. **Gender**: Gender matches, but ethnicity does not.
4. **None**: Neither ethnicity nor gender matches.

### Results

The research results indicate:

- **Ethnicity matching** significantly enhanced the user's sense of embodiment, regardless of gender matching. This was evident in aspects such as appearance, response, and ownership.
- **Gender matching** significantly enhanced the user's sense of belonging, indicating that the sense of belonging is influenced by both ethnicity and gender matching.
- **Ethnicity matching** particularly affected the user's self-location, while **gender matching** particularly affected the user's body ownership.

### Significance

This study expands the understanding of the sense of embodiment in virtual reality, particularly regarding the impact of ethnicity and gender matching. The results suggest that to enhance the user's sense of embodiment, VR applications should consider the user's personal characteristics and provide more diverse virtual character options. This has important practical significance for improving the VR experience of users from different backgrounds worldwide.