Abstract:A group of $n$ agents with numerical preferences for each other are to be assigned to the $n$ seats of a dining table. We study two natural topologies:~circular (cycle) tables and panel (path) tables. For a given seating arrangement, an agent's utility is the sum of their preference values towards their (at most two) direct neighbors. An arrangement is envy-free if no agent strictly prefers someone else's seat, and it is stable if no two agents strictly prefer each other's seats. Recently, it was shown that for both paths and cycles it is NP-hard to decide whether an envy-free arrangement exists, even for symmetric binary preferences. In contrast, we show that, if agents come from a bounded number of classes, the problem is solvable in polynomial time for arbitrarily-valued possibly asymmetric preferences, including outputting an arrangement if possible. We also give simpler proofs of the previous hardness results if preferences are allowed to be asymmetric. For stability, it is known that deciding the existence of stable arrangements is NP-hard for both topologies, but only if sufficiently-many numerical values are allowed. As it turns out, even constructing unstable instances can be challenging in certain cases, e.g., binary values. We completely characterize the existence of stable arrangements based on the number of distinct values in the preference matrix and the number of agent classes. We also ask the same question for non-negative values and give an almost-complete characterization, the most interesting outstanding case being that of paths with two-valued non-negative preferences, for which we experimentally find that stable arrangements always exist and prove it under the additional constraint that agents can only swap seats when sitting at most two positions away. We moreover give a polynomial algorithm for determining a stable arrangement assuming a bounded number of classes.

Intergenerational Preferences and Continuity: Reconciling Order and Topology

Rank Preserving Preferences

Topological Connectedness and Behavioral Assumptions on Preferences: A Two-Way Relationship

A topological study for the existence of lower-semicontinuous Richter-Peleg multi-utilities

Intersecting families of sets and the topology of cones in economics

The continuity postulate in economic theory: A deconstruction and an integration

Complementarities in childcare allocation under priorities

Matchings under Preferences: Strength of Stability and Trade-offs

Continuity postulates and solvability axioms in economic theory and in mathematical psychology: a consolidation of the theory of individual choice

A continuous rating method for preferential voting. The incomplete case

The Yannelis-Prabhakar Theorem on Upper Semi-Continuous Selections in Paracompact Spaces: Extensions and Applications

Stable Dinner Party Seating Arrangements

Continuous Social Networks

Resolute refinements of social choice correspondences

Binary Relations in Mathematical Economics: On the Continuity, Additivity and Monotonicity Postulates in Eilenberg, Villegas and DeGroot

Intergenerational Insurance

Reconciling long-term cultural diversity and short-term collective social behavior

From Incomplete Preferences to Ranking via Optimization

Preservation of splitting families and cardinal characteristics of the continuum

Intertemporal Consumption With Anticipating, Remembering, And Experiencing Selves

Stable Marriage with Multi-Modal Preferences