An Investigation of Hardware Security Bug Characteristics in Open-Source Projects

Joey Ah-kiow,Benjamin Tan
2024-02-01
Abstract:Hardware security is an important concern of system security as vulnerabilities can arise from design errors introduced throughout the development lifecycle. Recent works have proposed techniques to detect hardware security bugs, such as static analysis, fuzzing, and symbolic execution. However, the fundamental properties of hardware security bugs remain relatively unexplored. To gain a better understanding of hardware security bugs, we perform a deep dive into the popular OpenTitan project, including its bug reports and bug fixes. We manually classify the bugs as relevant to functionality or security and analyze characteristics, such as the impact and location of security bugs, and the size of their bug fixes. We also investigate relationships between security impact and bug management during development. Finally, we propose an abstract syntax tree-based analysis to identify the syntactic characteristics of bug fixes. Our results show that 53% of the bugs in OpenTitan have potential security implications and that 55% of all bug fixes modify only one file. Our findings underscore the importance of security-aware development practices and tools and motivate the development of techniques that leverage the highly localized nature of hardware bugs.
Cryptography and Security
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper attempts to address the issue of the characteristics of hardware security vulnerabilities. Specifically, the authors aim to understand the fundamental characteristics of hardware security vulnerabilities by deeply analyzing security vulnerability reports and their fixes in open-source hardware projects. The specific issues the paper attempts to address are as follows: 1. **Proportion of security vulnerabilities**: How many vulnerabilities in open-source hardware projects are related to security? 2. **Impact of vulnerabilities**: How do these security vulnerabilities affect hardware systems? Specifically, what is their impact on confidentiality, integrity, and availability? 3. **Vulnerability management**: How are these security vulnerabilities managed and handled during the development process? 4. **Characteristics of vulnerability fixes**: What files and lines of code are typically involved in fixing security vulnerabilities? Do these fixes have specific language structure characteristics? Through the above research, the paper aims to reveal the characteristics of hardware security vulnerabilities and provide guidance for developing more effective vulnerability detection and repair techniques in the future. The research results show that, during the studied period, 52.9% of the vulnerabilities in the OpenTitan project were security-related, and the fixes for these vulnerabilities typically involved fewer files and lines of code. Additionally, the most security vulnerabilities were found in cryptography-related IP modules. These findings emphasize the importance of adopting security-aware practices and tools during hardware development.