Short- vs. long-distance physics in $B\to K^{(*)} \ell^+\ell^-$: a data-driven analysis

Marzia Bordone,Gino isidori,Sandro Mächler,Arianna Tinari
2024-05-07
Abstract:We analyze data on $B\to K\mu^+\mu^-$ and $B\to K^*\mu^+\mu^-$ decays in the whole dilepton invariant mass spectrum with the aim of disentangling short- vs. long-distance contributions. The sizable long-distance amplitudes from $c \bar{c}$ narrow resonances are taken into account by employing a dispersive approach. For each available $q^2=m_{\mu\mu}^2$ bin and each helicity amplitude an independent determination of the Wilson coefficient $C_9$, describing $b\to s\ell^+\ell^-$ transitions at short distances, is obtained. The consistency of the $C_9$ values thus obtained provides an a posteriori check of the absence of additional, sizable, long-distance contributions. The systematic difference of these values from the Standard Model expectation supports the hypothesis of a non-standard $b\to s \mu^+\mu^-$ amplitude of short-distance origin.
High Energy Physics - Phenomenology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper aims to solve the problem of distinguishing between short - range and long - range physical contributions in the \(B\rightarrow K(\ast)\ell^+\ell^-\) decay process. Specifically, the research objective is to analyze the experimental data to resolve the short - range and long - range contributions in these decay processes and verify whether there are short - range effects beyond the Standard Model (SM). ### Research Background - **Proposing the Problem**: The \(B\rightarrow K(\ast)\ell^+\ell^-\) decay is an important way to detect physics beyond the Standard Model. Since this type of decay is strongly suppressed in the Standard Model, it is particularly sensitive to short - range physics. - **Theoretical and Experimental Challenges**: - **Theoretical Aspect**: To accurately describe these decays, non - perturbative effects need to be considered, especially the \(B\rightarrow K(\ast)\) form factors and the non - local matrix elements of four - quark operators. - **Experimental Aspect**: Experimentally, it has been possible to accurately measure the distributions of these decays, especially in the low \(q^2\) and high \(q^2\) regions. ### Main Methods - **Data Analysis**: Use the dispersion method to deal with long - range contributions, especially in the low \(q^2\) region, and use a data - driven method to extract the short - range Wilson coefficient \(C_9\). - **Model Construction**: Combine the known components in the Standard Model to construct a theoretical framework for the \(B\rightarrow K(\ast)\mu^+\mu^-\) decay, including short - range and long - range contributions. - **Fitting Process**: By fitting the experimental data, independently determine the \(C_9\) values for each \(q^2\) interval and each independent hadronic amplitude. ### Main Results - **No Significant Dependence**: The experimentally determined \(C_9\) values do not have a significant dependence in different \(q^2\) intervals and different hadronic amplitudes, indicating that the long - range contributions have been well described. - **Deviation from the Standard Model**: Nevertheless, the experimentally determined \(C_9\) values are significantly different from the Standard Model predictions, supporting the hypothesis of the existence of non - Standard Model short - range effects. ### Conclusions - **Main Conclusions**: - The data do not provide evidence of significant unconsidered long - range contributions. - The experimentally determined \(C_9\) values are inconsistent with the Standard Model expectations, which is in line with the hypothesis of non - Standard Model short - range effects. - **Future Prospects**: Further reducing the uncertainty, especially through more accurate experimental data, can more clearly verify these conclusions and may quantitatively estimate the degree of deviation from the Standard Model. ### Formula Display - **Modification of Wilson Coefficient \(C_9\)**: \[ C_9\rightarrow C_{9,\lambda}(q^2)+Y_{\lambda}^{c\bar{c}}(q^2)+Y_{\lambda}^{q\bar{q}}(q^2)+Y_{\lambda}^{b\bar{b}}(q^2) \] - **Dispersion Relation of Non - local Matrix Elements**: \[ \Delta H_{\lambda}^{c\bar{c}}(q^2)=\frac{q^2 - q_0^2}{\pi}\int_{s_0}^{\infty}ds\frac{\rho_{\lambda}^{c\bar{c}}(s)}{(s - q_0^2)(s - q^2)} \] - **Correction Term of Long - range Contribution**: \[ Y_{\lambda}^{c\bar{c}}(q^2)=Y_{\lambda}^{c\bar{c}}(q_0^2)+\frac{16\pi^2}{F_{\lambda}(q^2)}\Delta H_{\lambda}^{c\bar{c}}(q^2) \] These formulas show how to deal with long - range contributions through dispersion relations and experimental data and finally extract.