Abstract:The paper [12] discussed two approaches for multitarget tracking (MTT): the generalized labeled multi-Bernoulli (GLMB) filter and three Poisson multi-Bernoulli mixture (PMBM) filters. The paper [13] discussed two frameworks for multitarget trajectory representation--labeled random finite set (LRFS) and set of trajectories (SoT)--and the merging of SoT and PMBM into trajectory PMBM (TPMBM) theory. This paper summarizes and augments the main findings of [12], [13]--specifcally, why SoT, PMBM, and TPMBM are physically and mathematically erroneous.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to address is the evaluation and critique of the correctness and effectiveness of two multi-target tracking (MTT) methods and their extended frameworks. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following points:
1. **Evaluation of LRFS (Labeled Random Finite Sets) and SoT (Sets of Trajectories)**:
- The paper discusses the methods LRFS and SoT used to represent multi-target trajectories and points out the physical and mathematical errors in SoT.
- Specifically, the paper notes that the SoT method has fundamental mathematical and physical errors, making it unable to correctly model multi-target systems.
2. **Evaluation of different versions of the PMBM (Poisson Multi-Bernoulli Mixture) filter**:
- The paper discusses three different versions of the PMBM filter (PMBM-1, PMBM-2, PMBM-3) and points out theoretical errors in these versions.
- Specific errors include assuming all measurements come from newly detected targets, incorrect assumptions of dynamic priors, and the need to prune the PMBM distribution as time progresses.
3. **Evaluation of the TPMBM (Trajectory Poisson Multi-Bernoulli Mixture) filter**:
- The paper discusses the TPMBM filter, which is a framework combining SoT and PMBM-1, aimed at maintaining trajectories.
- However, the paper points out that the TPMBM filter itself also has serious theoretical errors, such as using an incorrect Trajectory Poisson Random Finite Set (TPRFS).
4. **Summary and extension of previous research**:
- The paper summarizes and extends previous research findings, particularly providing detailed analysis and argumentation on the physical and mathematical errors of SoT, PMBM, and TPMBM.
In summary, the main purpose of this paper is to reveal the theoretical and practical shortcomings of existing multi-target tracking methods through detailed analysis and critique, thereby providing guidance for future research.