Study of X-ray emission from the S147 nebula with SRG/eROSITA: X-ray imaging, spectral characterization, and a multiwavelength picture

Miltiadis Michailidis,Gerd Pühlhofer,Werner Becker,Michael Freyberg,Andrea Merloni,Andrea Santangelo,Manami Sasaki,Andrei Bykov,Nikolai Chugai,Eugene Churazov,Ildar Khabibullin,Rashid Sunyaev,Victor Utrobin,Igor Zinchenko
2024-06-25
Abstract:Simeis 147 (S147, G180.0-01.7, "Spaghetti nebula") is a supernova remnant (SNR) extensively studied across the entire electromagnetic spectrum, from radio to giga-electronvolt $\gamma$-rays, except in X-rays. Here, we report the first detection of significant X-ray emission from the entire SNR using data of the extended ROentgen Survey Imaging Telescope Array (eROSITA) onboard the Russian-German Spektrum Roentgen Gamma (SRG). The object is located at the Galactic anticenter, and its 3 deg size classifies it among the largest SNRs ever detected in X-rays. By employing $\sim$15 years of Fermi-LAT data, our study confirms the association of the remnant with a spatially coincident diffuse giga-electronvolt excess, namely 4FGL J0540.3+2756e or FGES J0537.6+2751. The X-ray emission is purely thermal, exhibiting strong O, Ne, and Mg lines; whereas it lacks heavier-Z elements. The emission is mainly confined to the 0.5-1.0 keV band; no significant emission is detected above 2.0 keV. Both a collisional plasma model in equilibrium and a model of nonequilibrium collisional plasma can fit the total spectrum. While the equilibrium model -- though statistically disfavored -- cannot be excluded by X-ray fitting, only the absorption column of the nonequilibrium model is consistent with expectations derived from optical extinction data. Adopting an expansion in a homogeneous medium of typical interstellar medium (ISM) density, the general SNR properties are broadly consistent with an expansion model that yields an estimated age of $\sim0.66-2\times10^{5}$ yr, that is a rather old age. The preference for an X-ray-emitting plasma in nonequilibrium, however, adds to the observational evidence that favors a substantially younger age. In a companion paper, we explore an SNR-in-cavity scenario, resulting in a much younger age that alleviates some of the inconsistencies of the old-age scenario.
High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the paper attempts to solve This paper aims to solve the following problems: 1. **Detecting the radiation of supernova remnant S147 in the X - ray band**: - S147 (also known as the "Spaghetti Nebula") is a known supernova remnant. It has been studied in multiple electromagnetic wavebands (from radio to gamma - ray) before, but relatively few studies have been done in the X - ray band. The paper reports the first detection of significant X - ray radiation from the entire S147 supernova remnant using the SRG/eROSITA telescope. 2. **Analyzing X - ray imaging and spectral characteristics**: - Through the analysis of eROSITA data, the imaging characteristics and spectral properties of S147 in the X - ray band were studied. Special attention was paid to the energy - spectrum distribution of X - ray emission and whether there were specific elemental lines (such as oxygen, neon, magnesium, etc.). 3. **Multi - band comprehensive study**: - Combining X - ray observation data with data from other wavebands (such as gamma - ray, optical, etc.), the multi - band characteristics of S147 were explored. In particular, the association between S147 and a spatially coincident gamma - ray excess region (4FGL J0540.3+2756e or FGES J0537.6+2751) was confirmed. 4. **Investigating the physical properties and evolution history of S147**: - Through X - ray spectral fitting, the physical state of S147 was studied, including parameters such as temperature, density, and absorption column. At the same time, based on these parameters, the age and distance of S147 were estimated, and its possible evolution models were explored. Two models are mentioned in the paper: the equilibrium collisional plasma model and the non - equilibrium collisional plasma model, and their respective advantages and disadvantages were discussed. 5. **Verifying and interpreting the observation results**: - By comparing the fitting results of different models, the X - ray emission characteristics of S147 were verified, and the significance of these characteristics for understanding the physical properties and evolution history of S147 was explained. In particular, the paper points out that the non - equilibrium collisional plasma model is more consistent with the optical extinction data, supporting a younger age estimate. ### Specific problems and methods - **X - ray detection**: Using the all - sky survey data (eRASS:4) of the eROSITA telescope, the X - ray radiation of S147 was detected for the first time. - **Spectral analysis**: Through X - ray spectral analysis, it was determined that the X - ray emission of S147 is mainly concentrated in the 0.5 - 1.0 keV energy range and lacks heavy elemental lines. - **Multi - band data**: Combining Fermi - LAT gamma - ray data, the association between S147 and the gamma - ray excess region was confirmed. - **Physical parameter estimation**: Through spectral fitting, parameters such as the temperature, density, and absorption column of S147 were estimated, and its age and distance were inferred. - **Model comparison**: The equilibrium collisional plasma model and the non - equilibrium collisional plasma model were compared, and their explanatory abilities for the physical properties of S147 were explored. ### Main conclusions - **Successful X - ray detection**: The significant radiation of S147 in the X - ray band was confirmed for the first time. - **Clear spectral characteristics**: The X - ray emission is mainly concentrated in the 0.5 - 1.0 keV energy range and lacks heavy elemental lines. - **Multi - band association**: The association between S147 and the gamma - ray excess region was confirmed. - **Reasonable physical parameters**: The non - equilibrium collisional plasma model is more consistent with the optical extinction data, supporting a younger age estimate. Through these studies, the paper provides important clues for understanding the physical properties and evolution history of S147.