Validation of symmetry-induced high moment velocity and temperature scaling laws in a turbulent channel flow

Francisco Alcántara-Ávila,Luis Miguel García-Raffi,Sergio Hoyas,Martin Oberlack

2024-01-29

Abstract:The symmetry-based turbulence theory has been used to derive new scaling laws for the streamwise velocity and temperature moments of arbitrary order. For this, it has been applied to an incompressible turbulent channel flow driven by a pressure gradient with a passive scalar equation coupled in. To derive the scaling laws, symmetries of the classical Navier-Stokes and the thermal energy equations have been used together with statistical symmetries, i.e. the statistical scaling and translation symmetries of the multi-point moment equations. Specifically, the multi-point moments are built on the instantaneous velocity and temperature fields other than in the classical approach, where moments are based on the fluctuations of these fields. With this instantaneous approach, a linear system of multi-point correlation equations has been obtained, which greatly simplifies the symmetry analysis. The scaling laws have been derived in the limit of zero viscosity and heat conduction, i.e. $Re_\tau \rightarrow \infty$ and $Pr > 1$, and apply in the centre of the channel, i.e. they represent a generalization of the deficit law so herewith extending the work of done on the velocity field. The scaling laws are all power laws, with the exponent of the high moments all depending exclusively on those of the first and second moments. To validate the new scaling laws, the data from a large number of DNS for different Reynolds and Prandtl numbers have been used. The results show a very high accuracy of the scaling laws to represent the DNS data. The statistical scaling symmetry of the multi-point moment equations, which characterizes intermittency, has been the key to the new results since it generates a constant in the exponent of the final scaling law. Most important, since this constant is independent of the order of the moments, it clearly indicates anomalous scaling.

Mathematical Physics,Fluid Dynamics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to verify the scaling laws of high - order velocity and temperature moments based on symmetry in turbulent channel flow. Specifically, the author utilizes the symmetries of the Navier - Stokes equations and the thermal energy equation, as well as the statistical symmetries of the multi - point moment equations, to derive a new set of scaling laws. These scaling laws are applicable to the case of high Reynolds numbers in the central region and Prandtl numbers greater than 1. These scaling laws are derived in the zero - viscosity and heat - conduction limits (i.e., \( \text{Re}_\tau \to \infty \) and \( \text{Pr} > 1 \)) and are expressed in the form of power laws, where the exponents of the high - order moments depend only on the exponents of the first - order and second - order moments.

To verify these new scaling laws, the author uses a large amount of direct numerical simulation (DNS) data, which cover different Reynolds numbers and Prandtl numbers. The results show that these scaling laws can represent the DNS data very accurately, especially in the central region.

### Key issues
1. **Derivation of new scaling laws**:
- Utilize the symmetries of the Navier - Stokes equations and the thermal energy equation.
- Utilize the statistical symmetries of the multi - point moment equations.
- Derive scaling laws applicable to high Reynolds numbers and Prandtl numbers greater than 1.

2. **Verification of new scaling laws**:
- Use a large amount of DNS data for verification.
- Compare the DNS data with the derived scaling laws to verify their accuracy.

### Main contributions
- **New scaling laws**: A new set of scaling laws has been derived, which are applicable to the case of high Reynolds numbers in the central region and Prandtl numbers greater than 1.
- **Verification results**: The accuracy of these scaling laws has been verified through a large amount of DNS data.
- **Theoretical basis**: These scaling laws are derived by using symmetry theory, especially Lie symmetry, providing a solid theoretical basis.

### Formula summary
- **Navier - Stokes equations**:
\[
M_i(x)=\frac{\partial U_i}{\partial t}+U_k\frac{\partial U_i}{\partial x_k}+\frac{\partial P}{\partial x_i}-\nu\frac{\partial^2 U_i}{\partial x_k\partial x_k} = 0
\]
- **Thermal energy equation**:
\[
E(x)=\frac{\partial\Theta}{\partial t}+U_k\frac{\partial\Theta}{\partial x_k}-\alpha\frac{\partial^2\Theta}{\partial x_k\partial x_k}=0
\]
- **Multi - point moment equations**:
\[
\frac{\partial H_{i\{n\}\Theta\{m\}}}{\partial t}+\sum_{a = 1}^n\frac{\partial H_{i\{n + 1\}\Theta\{m\}}[i(n + m+ 1)\to k](x(n + m+ 1)\to x(a))}{\partial x_k(a)}+\frac{\partial I_{i\{n - 1\}\Theta\{m\}}[a]P}{\partial x_i(a)}-\nu\frac{\partial^2 H_{i\{n\}\Theta\{m\}}}{\partial x_k(a)\partial x_k(a)}+\sum_{b = n+ 1}^{n + m}\frac{\partial H_{i\{n + 1\}\Theta\{m\}}[i(n + m+ 1)\to k](x(n + m+ 1)\to x(b))}{\partial x_k(b)}-\alpha\frac{\partial^2