Experimental genuine quantum nonlocality in the triangle network

Ning-Ning Wang,Chao Zhang,Huan Cao,Kai Xu,Bi-Heng Liu,Yun-Feng Huang,Chuan-Feng Li,Guang-Can Guo,Nicolas Gisin,Tamás Kriváchy,Marc-Olivier Renou
2024-01-27
Abstract:In the last decade, it was understood that quantum networks involving several independent sources of entanglement which are distributed and measured by several parties allowed for completely novel forms of nonclassical quantum correlations, when entangled measurements are performed. Here, we experimentally obtain quantum correlations in a triangle network structure, and provide solid evidence of its nonlocality. Specifically, we first obtain the elegant distribution proposed in (Entropy 21, 325) by performing a six-photon experiment. Then, we justify its nonlocality based on machine learning tools to estimate the distance of the experimentally obtained correlation to the local set, and through the violation of a family of conjectured inequalities tailored for the triangle network.
Quantum Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to realize and verify quantum non - locality in a triangular network structure. Specifically, the authors generated quantum correlations in the triangular network through experiments and provided solid evidence for its non - locality. This work mainly focuses on how to achieve new forms of non - locality through entanglement measurements in the triangular network, and this non - locality cannot be simply reduced to the non - locality in the standard Bell inequality. ### Background and Problems of the Paper 1. **Quantum Non - locality**: Quantum non - locality means that particles in a quantum system can show strong correlations even when they are far apart, and this correlation cannot be explained by the local hidden variable model in classical physics. Bell's theorem has proven this, that is, the predictions of quantum theory are irreconcilable with the predictions of any local hidden variable model. 2. **Quantum Network**: In recent years, it has been discovered that quantum networks (multiple independent entanglement sources are distributed to multiple measurement parties) can exhibit new forms of non - locality. Especially in the triangular network, this non - locality is particularly evident. 3. **Existing Challenges**: Although some conjectures about the non - locality of quantum networks have been proposed theoretically, it is still very difficult to experimentally verify these conjectures. In particular, how to generate and detect these new forms of non - locality in experiments is an important research direction. ### Experimental Design and Methods 1. **Experimental Setup**: The paper describes an optical triangular network based on the spontaneous parametric down - conversion (SPDC) process. Three EPR sources are located at the three vertices of the triangle respectively, and each source generates a pair of entangled photons. 2. **Entanglement Measurement**: Each node receives photons from two different EPR sources and performs an Elegant Joint Measurement (EJM). EJM is a special measurement method that can generate a specific quantum distribution. 3. **Data Processing**: Use machine - learning methods to estimate the distance between the experimentally generated distribution and the local hidden variable model, and further verify non - locality by violating certain inequalities. ### Main Results 1. **Generated Distribution**: The experiment successfully generated the so - called "elegant distribution", which is a quantum distribution unique to the triangular network. 2. **Non - locality Verification**: - **Distance Estimation**: Estimate the minimum distance between the experimentally generated distribution and the local hidden variable model by the neural network method. The results show that this distance is significantly greater than zero, indicating that the experimentally generated distribution has non - locality. - **Inequality Verification**: The experimental results violate a class of inequalities derived by machine - learning methods, further confirming non - locality. ### Discussion and Conclusions 1. **New Forms of Non - locality**: The paper shows that new forms of non - locality can be achieved through entanglement measurements in the triangular network, and this non - locality cannot be simply reduced to the non - locality in the standard Bell inequality. 2. **Experimental Limitations**: Although the experimental results strongly support the existence of non - locality, there are still some common loopholes, such as the locality loophole and the fair - sampling loophole. In addition, the network local model also introduces a new independence loophole. 3. **Future Prospects**: Future research can further close these loopholes through more advanced technologies (such as deterministic photon - photon gates) to more strictly verify quantum non - locality. In conclusion, this paper realizes a new form of quantum non - locality in the triangular network through experiments and provides solid evidence to support this finding. This not only deepens our understanding of quantum non - locality but also provides new tools and methods for the development of quantum information science.