The Machine Vision Iceberg Explained: Advancing Dynamic Testing by Considering Holistic Environmental Relations

Hubert Padusinski,Christian Steinhauser,Thilo Braun,Lennart Ries,Eric Sax
2024-04-30
Abstract:Machine Vision (MV) is essential for solving driving automation. This paper examines potential shortcomings in current MV testing strategies for highly automated driving (HAD) systems. We argue for a more comprehensive understanding of the performance factors that must be considered during the MV evaluation process, noting that neglecting these factors can lead to significant risks. This is not only relevant to MV component testing, but also to integration testing. To illustrate this point, we draw an analogy to a ship navigating towards an iceberg to show potential hidden challenges in current MV testing strategies. The main contribution is a novel framework for black-box testing which observes environmental relations. This means it is designed to enhance MV assessments by considering the attributes and surroundings of relevant individual objects. The framework provides the identification of seven general concerns about the object recognition of MV, which are not addressed adequately in established test processes. To detect these deficits based on their performance factors, we propose the use of a taxonomy called "granularity orders" along with a graphical representation. This allows an identification of MV uncertainties across a range of driving scenarios. This approach aims to advance the precision, efficiency, and completeness of testing procedures for MV.
Robotics,Artificial Intelligence,Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition,Software Engineering,Image and Video Processing
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper discusses the potential deficiencies of current Machine Vision (MV) testing strategies in Highly Automated Driving (HAD) systems. The author advocates for a more comprehensive understanding of the performance factors that must be considered in the MV evaluation process, as ignoring these factors may lead to significant risks. The paper uses the analogy of an iceberg to illustrate the potential hidden challenges in current MV testing strategies and proposes a novel black-box testing framework that focuses on environmental context to enhance the MV evaluation of relevant individual object properties and surrounding environment. The paper identifies seven common issues in MV object recognition and proposes the use of a "granularity order" classification method and graphic representation to detect these issues, aiming to identify MV uncertainty in various driving scenarios. The goal of the paper is to improve the accuracy, efficiency, and completeness of MV testing procedures.