Ultrashort-period WD binaries are not undergoing strong tidal heating

Peter Scherbak,Jim Fuller

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/ad1dd6

2024-01-26

Abstract:Double white dwarf (WD) binaries are increasingly being discovered at short orbital periods where strong tidal effects and significant tidal heating signatures may occur. We assume the tidal potential of the companion excites outgoing gravity waves within the WD primary, the dissipation of which leads to an increase in the WD's surface temperature. We compute the excitation and dissipation of the waves in cooling WD models in evolving MESA binary simulations. Tidal heating is self-consistently computed and added to the models at every time step. As a binary inspirals to orbital periods less than $\sim$20 minutes, the WD's behavior changes from cooling to heating, with temperature enhancements that can exceed 10,000 K compared with non-tidally heated models. We compare a grid of tidally heated WD models to observed short-period systems with hot WD primaries. While tidal heating affects their $T_{\rm eff}$, it is likely not the dominant luminosity. Instead these WDs are probably intrinsically young and hot, implying the binaries formed at short orbital periods. The binaries are consistent with undergoing common envelope evolution with a somewhat low efficiency $\alpha_{\rm CE}$. We delineate the parameter space where the traveling wave assumption is most valid, noting that it breaks down for WDs that cool sufficiently, where standing waves may instead be formed.

Solar and Stellar Astrophysics,High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### The problems the paper attempts to solve

The problems the paper attempts to solve are: in very short - period white dwarf binary systems, whether tidal heating significantly affects the surface temperature of white dwarfs, and whether this tidal heating can explain the observed high - temperature white dwarf phenomena.

### Background and motivation

1. **Discovery background**:
- In recent years, more and more short - period white dwarf binary systems have been discovered, and the orbital period of the most compact system is only 6.9 minutes (Burdge et al. 2019).
- For these compact systems, tidal effects are expected to be very strong (Iben et al. 1998), but the influence of tidal effects on white dwarfs and their observable properties remains uncertain.

2. **Theoretical expectations**:
- As white dwarf binaries gradually approach each other due to gravitational wave radiation, tidal effects will become stronger, and tidal heating may become the main source of luminosity (Iben et al. 1998; Burdge et al. 2020b).
- Measuring tidal heating is one of the important means to constrain tidal physics (Piro 2019).
- Under very short periods, tidal effects may affect the conditions before the merger of white dwarf binaries, such as the degree of synchronization between the rotation of white dwarfs and their orbits (Raskin et al. 2012; Dan et al. 2014; Yoon et al. 2007; Lorén - Aguilar et al. 2009).

3. **Research status**:
- Although tidal effects are expected to heat white dwarfs, quantitative predictions of it and the heating rate depending on the white dwarf mass and the system orbital period have not been strictly studied.
- Previous work has only estimated tidal heating for a few white dwarfs with different masses and orbital periods (Fuller & Lai 2013; Yu et al. 2021), and has not self - consistently simulated white dwarf structure changes, heating rates and heat deposition locations.

### Research objectives

1. **Model construction**:
- By self - consistently implementing tidal effects in the MESA stellar evolution code, study the evolution process of white dwarfs with different masses in binary systems.
- Simulate the excitation and dissipation of tidal waves, calculate tidal heating, and add it to the model.

2. **Result verification**:
- Compare the simulation results with the observed data of known short - period white dwarf binary systems to verify the influence of tidal heating on the surface temperature of white dwarfs.
- Explore whether tidal heating is the main energy source of these high - temperature white dwarfs, or whether these white dwarfs are inherently young and have a high temperature.

### Main findings

1. **The influence of tidal heating**:
- When the orbital period of the binary system is less than about 20 minutes, the behavior of white dwarfs changes from cooling to heating, and the increase in surface temperature can exceed 10,000 K.
- Tidal heating does affect the effective temperature (Teff) of white dwarfs, but may not be their main luminosity source. Instead, these white dwarfs may be inherently young and have a high temperature, meaning that the binary system is formed under a shorter orbital period.

2. **Parameter space analysis**:
- The effectiveness of tidal heating under different initial orbital periods has been studied, and it has been found that in some parameter spaces, the traveling - wave hypothesis is valid, while in other cases, standing waves may be formed.
- By comparing the results of different models, the parameter range where the traveling - wave hypothesis is most applicable has been determined.

### Conclusion

Through detailed numerical simulations and theoretical analyses, this paper explores the role of tidal heating in very short - period white dwarf binary systems. The research results show that although tidal heating does affect the surface temperature of white dwarfs, it is not the main energy source of these high - temperature white dwarfs. These white dwarfs are more likely to be inherently young and have a high temperature, which means that the binary system is formed under a shorter orbital period. This finding is of great significance for understanding the evolution history of white dwarf binaries and tidal physics.