Magnetic Penrose process in the magnetized Kerr spacetime

Chandrachur Chakraborty,Parth Patil,G. Akash
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.109.064062
2024-03-04
Abstract:Magnetic Penrose process (MPP) could be highly efficient (efficiency can even exceed $100\%$) for extracting the energy from a Kerr black hole, if it is immersed in a mG order magnetic field. Considering the exact solution of the magnetized Kerr spacetime, here we derive the exact expression of efficiency ($\eta_{\rm MPP}$) for MPP, which is valid for both the Kerr black hole (BH) as well as Kerr superspinar (SS), and also from the weak magnetic field to an ultra-strong magnetic field $(B)$ which can even distort the original Kerr geometry. We show that although the value of $\eta_{\rm MPP}$ increases upto a certain value of ultra-strong magnetic field ($B_p$), it decreases to zero for $B > B_p$, in case of the Kerr BHs. On the other hand, $\eta_{\rm MPP}$ shows the opposite behavior in case of the Kerr SSs. One intriguing feature that emerges is, $\eta_{\rm MPP}$ acquires the maximum value for the Kerr parameter $a_* \approx 0.786$ (unlike $a_*=1$ for the ordinary PP), decreases for $0.786 < a_* \leq 1$. This indicates that the BH starts to expel the effect of magnetic field for $a_* > 0.786$, and is fully expelled from the extremal Kerr BH due to the gravitational Meissner effect. As a special case of MPP, we also study the ordinary Penrose process (PP) for magnetized Kerr spacetime. We show that MPP for Kerr BHs, Kerr SSs and ordinary PP for Kerr SSs can be superefficient for the astrophysical applications to powering engines in the high-energy sources like active galactic nuclei and quasars, in the weak magnetic fields. Our strong magnetic field result of MPP could be important to the primordial BHs in the early Universe immersed in the primordial magnetic fields, and to the transmuted BHs which are formed by collapsing and/or by merging of the magnetized progenitors. It is almost impossible to extract the energy from a BH (SS) through MPP (PP) in the ultra-strong magnetic fields.
High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,High Energy Physics - Theory
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the efficiency of extracting energy from Kerr black holes (Kerr BH) and Kerr superspinners (Kerr SS) through the Magnetic Penrose Process (MPP) in magnetized Kerr spacetime. Specifically, the authors derived the exact expression of MPP efficiency (\(\eta_{MPP}\)) under the conditions from weak magnetic fields to super - strong magnetic fields, and studied the behavioral characteristics of this process under different conditions. ### Main research questions: 1. **Exact expression of MPP efficiency**: - The paper derived the exact expression of MPP efficiency in magnetized Kerr spacetime, which is applicable to Kerr black holes and Kerr superspinners and covers the range from weak magnetic fields to super - strong magnetic fields. 2. **Change of efficiency with magnetic field strength**: - The change of MPP efficiency with magnetic field strength \(B\) was studied. It was found that for Kerr black holes, when the magnetic field strength exceeds a certain critical value \(B_p\), the efficiency first increases and then decreases to zero; while for Kerr superspinners, the efficiency shows the opposite behavior. 3. **Optimal Kerr parameter**: - It was found that the MPP efficiency reaches its maximum when the Kerr parameter \(a^* \approx 0.786\), not when \(a^* = 1\). This indicates that when \(a^* > 0.786\), the black hole begins to repel the magnetic field effect, and finally completely repels the magnetic field in the extreme Kerr black hole due to the gravitational Meissner effect. 4. **Efficiency of the Ordinary Penrose Process (PP)**: - As a special case of MPP, the efficiency of the ordinary Penrose process in magnetized Kerr spacetime was studied. It was found that for Kerr black holes, the PP efficiency decreases as the magnetic field strength increases; while for Kerr superspinners, the PP efficiency decreases from 103% to 0. ### Main conclusions: - **Super - high efficiency of MPP**: - Under weak magnetic field conditions, MPP can achieve an efficiency of more than 100%, which is of great significance for the energy engines of high - energy astrophysical phenomena such as active galactic nuclei and quasars. - **Influence of super - strong magnetic fields**: - Under super - strong magnetic field conditions, the MPP efficiency first increases to a peak and then decreases to zero. This indicates that under extreme conditions, the magnetic field has a significant impact on the energy extraction process of black holes. - **Influence of Kerr parameters**: - The MPP efficiency reaches its maximum when \(a^* \approx 0.786\), and when \(a^* = 1\), the efficiency is significantly reduced to only 20.7%. - **Limitations of the ordinary Penrose process**: - The ordinary Penrose process can hardly extract energy from black holes or superspinners under super - strong magnetic field conditions. ### Formula summary: - **Exact expression of MPP efficiency**: \[ \eta_{MPP} = \left[ \left( \frac{\Omega_1 - \Omega_-}{\Omega_+ - \Omega_-} \right) \left( \frac{g_{tt} + \Omega_+ g_{t\phi}}{g_{tt} + \Omega_1 g_{t\phi}} \right) - 1 \right] - \frac{q A_t}{m} \] - **Relationship between Kerr parameter \(a^*\) and magnetic field strength \(B\)**: \[ \eta_{MPP} \text{ reaches its maximum when } a^* \approx 0.786 \] - **Efficiency under super - strong magnetic field conditions**: \[ \eta_{MPP} \text{ decreases to zero when } B > B_p \] These research results