The stability and instability of the language control network: a longitudinal resting-state functional magnetic resonance imaging study

Zilong Li,Cong Liu,Xin Pan,Guosheng Ding,Ruiming Wang

2024-03-07

Abstract:The language control network is vital among language-related networks responsible for solving the problem of multiple language switching. Researchers have expressed concerns about the instability of the language control network when exposed to external influences (e.g., Long-term second language learning). However, some studies have suggested that the language control network is stable. Therefore, whether the language control network is stable or not remains unclear. In the present study, we directly evaluated the stability and instability of the language control network using resting-state functional magnetic resonance imaging (rs-fMRI). We employed cohorts of Chinese first-year college students majoring in English who underwent second language (L2) acquisition courses at a university and those who did not. Two resting-state fMRI scans were acquired approximately 1 year apart. We found that the language control network was both moderately stable and unstable. We further investigated the morphological coexistence patterns of stability and instability within the language control network. First, we extracted connections representing stability and plasticity from the entire network. We then evaluated whether the coexistence patterns were modular (stability and instability involve different brain regions) or non-modular (stability and plasticity involve the same brain regions but have unique connectivity patterns). We found that both stability and instability coexisted in a non-modular pattern. Compared with the non-English major group, the English major group has a more non-modular coexistence pattern.. These findings provide preliminary evidence of the coexistence of stability and instability in the language control network.

Neurons and Cognition

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the stability and instability of the Language Control Network (LCN) when faced with external influences. The researchers focus on how the LCN maintains its functional stability during multilingual switching and whether it can retain a certain level of adaptability in changing environments.

The abstract of the paper points out that while some studies suggest that the LCN is stable, other studies propose that this network may not always be stable, especially under the influence of long-term second language learning. Therefore, it is currently unclear whether the Language Control Network is stable or unstable.

To directly assess the stability and instability of the Language Control Network, the research team employed Resting-State Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (rs-fMRI) technology and conducted a one-year follow-up study on two groups of Chinese university students. One group majored in English and thus received extensive second language learning; the other group did not major in English and had less second language learning.

The study found that the Language Control Network exhibited both moderate stability and instability. Additionally, the research explored the morphological patterns of the coexistence of stability and instability. The researchers discovered that these two characteristics coexist in a non-modular manner, meaning they involve the same brain regions but exhibit different connectivity patterns. Compared to non-English major students, English major students showed a more non-modular coexistence pattern.

In summary, this paper aims to reveal the stability and instability within the Language Control Network through experimental data and to further understand how these two characteristics interact and coexist within the neural network. This helps us better understand how the brain controls language in a multilingual environment.