Business Model Contributions to Bank Profit Performance: A Machine Learning Approach

F. Bolivar,Miguel A. Duran,A. Lozano-Vivas

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ribaf.2022.101870

2024-01-23

Abstract:This paper analyzes the relation between bank profit performance and business models. Using a machine learning-based approach, we propose a methodological strategy in which balance sheet components' contributions to profitability are the identification instruments of business models. We apply this strategy to the European Union banking system from 1997 to 2021. Our main findings indicate that the standard retail-oriented business model is the profile that performs best in terms of profitability, whereas adopting a non-specialized business profile is a strategic decision that leads to poor profitability. Additionally, our findings suggest that the effect of high capital ratios on profitability depends on the business profile. The contributions of business models to profitability decreased during the Great Recession. Although the situation showed signs of improvement afterward, the European Union banking system's ability to yield returns is still problematic in the post-crisis period, even for the best-performing group.

General Economics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper investigates the relationship between bank profitability and its business model, and proposes a new analytical strategy using machine learning methods. The study focuses on the banking system in the European Union between 1997 and 2021, and finds that traditional retail-oriented business models perform the best in terms of profitability, while non-focused business models may lead to low profitability. Additionally, the impact of capital ratios on profitability depends on the bank's business model. During financial crises, the contribution of business models to profitability decreases, and even after the crisis, profitability remains a challenge for the EU banking industry. The paper identifies different business models by classifying banks' contributions to profits based on asset and liability portfolios using random forest algorithms and tree interpreters, rather than treating profitability as a byproduct of analysis. The research findings also indicate that approximately 17% of banks migrate to other models before and after the crisis by adjusting their business models. This paper extends the application of machine learning in bank analysis and provides a new perspective on understanding how bank strategic choices affect profits.