Temperature as Joules per Bit

Charles Alexandre Bédard,Sophie Berthelette,Xavier Coiteux-Roy,Stefan Wolf
2024-01-23
Abstract:Boltzmann's constant reflects a historical misunderstanding of the concept of entropy, whose informational nature is obfuscated when expressed in J/K. We suggest that the development of temperature and energy, historically prior to that of entropy, does not amount to their logical priority: Temperature should be defined in terms of entropy, not vice versa. Following the precepts of information theory, entropy is measured in bits, and coincides with information capacity at thermodynamic equilibrium. Consequently, not only is the temperature of an equilibrated system expressed in J/bit, but it acquires an operational meaning: It is the cost in energy to increase its information capacity by 1 bit. Our proposal also supports the notion of available capacity, analogous to free energy. Finally, it simplifies Landauer's cost and clarifies that it is a cost of displacement, not of erasure.
Quantum Physics,Statistical Mechanics,Classical Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper attempts to address the issue of redefining the relationship between temperature and entropy to eliminate historical misunderstandings. Specifically: 1. **Historical Background**: The historical development sequence of the three concepts of temperature, energy, and entropy is temperature -> energy -> entropy. This sequence has led to an inconsistency between the unit of entropy (Joules per Kelvin, J/K) and the unit in information theory (bits, bit). 2. **Core Issue**: The paper argues that entropy should be viewed as a more fundamental concept rather than being defined through temperature. The author suggests changing the unit of entropy from J/K to bit to reflect its nature as information capacity. 3. **Main Objectives**: - **Redefine Temperature**: Propose that temperature should be expressed in Joules per bit (J/bit), which not only simplifies the units of physical quantities but also gives temperature an operational meaning: the energy required to increase the system's information capacity by 1 bit. - **Clarify Concepts**: Through this redefinition, the paper aims to clarify some fundamental concepts in thermodynamics and information theory, such as Landauer's erasure cost (the energy required to erase 1 bit of information) and available capacity (similar to free energy). 4. **Specific Contributions**: - **Information Capacity**: In a state of thermodynamic equilibrium, the system's entropy equals its information capacity, which can be measured in bits. - **Operational Meaning of Temperature**: Temperature can be understood as the energy required to increase the system's information capacity by 1 bit. - **Simplify Theory**: This redefinition simplifies the expression of Landauer's erasure cost and clarifies the distinction between measurement and erasure. In summary, the paper attempts to eliminate historical unit issues by redefining the relationship between temperature and entropy, making the concepts in thermodynamics and information theory more consistent and clear.