Not all Probability Density Functions are Tomograms

L.A. Markovich,J. Urbanetz,V.I. Man'ko

2024-01-22

Abstract:This paper delves into the significance of the tomographic probability density function (pdf) representation of quantum states, shedding light on the special classes of pdfs that can be tomograms. Instead of using wave functions or density operators on Hilbert spaces, tomograms, which are the true pdfs, are used to completely describe the states of quantum systems. Unlike quasi-pdfs, like the Wigner function, tomograms can be analysed using all the tools of classical probability theory for pdf estimation, which can allow a better quality of state reconstruction. This is particularly useful when dealing with non-Gaussian states where the pdfs are multi-mode. The knowledge of the family of distributions plays an important role in the application of both parametric and non-parametric density estimation methods. We show that not all pdfs can play the role of tomograms of quantum states and introduce the conditions that must be fulfilled by pdfs to be "quantum".

Quantum Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper aims to explore which probability density functions (PDFs) can be used as phase - space tomograms of quantum states. Specifically, the paper focuses on how to distinguish probability density functions that can represent quantum states from those that cannot. The authors point out that not all probability density functions can be used as phase - space tomograms of quantum states. To determine whether a given probability density function can represent a quantum state, the paper introduces several conditions that must be satisfied, which are based on the properties of the density operator. Through these conditions, the authors evaluate the ability of known probability density functions to generate physical quantum states.

The main contributions of the paper include:
1. **Introducing the characteristic function of the probability density function of the phase - space tomogram**: The characteristic function is the Fourier transform of the probability density function, which always exists and is bounded. The paper shows that the characteristic function of the probability density function describing a quantum state must satisfy the conditions derived from the properties of the density operator.
2. **Deriving the relationship between the characteristic function and the density matrix**: The paper explicitly writes out the expressions of the trace and purity parameters of the density matrix under the characteristic function. In addition, it is also shown that the trace of the product of two density matrices can be represented in the integral form of their corresponding characteristic functions.
3. **Studying the exponential family distributions**: The paper examines some known exponential family distributions (such as the exponential distribution, gamma distribution, and chi - square distribution) and proves that these distributions do not satisfy the conditions for generating quantum states.
4. **Analyzing specific systems**: The paper studies in detail the superposition states of the harmonic oscillator, the pseudo - harmonic oscillator, and the cat state. For these systems, the paper derives their probability density functions and their characteristic functions and verifies that these functions satisfy the conditions for generating physical quantum states.

In summary, by introducing the characteristic function and a series of conditions, this paper provides a method to determine which probability density functions can be used to represent quantum states, thus providing a new theoretical basis for the reconstruction of quantum states.