PressProtect: Helping Journalists Navigate Social Media in the Face of Online Harassment

Catherine Han,Anne Li,Deepak Kumar,Zakir Durumeric

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1145/3687048

2024-08-27

Abstract:Social media has become a critical tool for journalists to disseminate their work, engage with their audience, and connect with sources. Unfortunately, journalists also regularly endure significant online harassment on social media platforms, ranging from personal attacks to doxxing to threats of physical harm. In this paper, we seek to understand how to make social media usable for journalists who face constant digital harassment. To begin, we conduct a set of need-finding interviews with Asian American and Pacific Islander journalists to understand where existing platform tools and newsroom resources fall short in adequately protecting journalists, especially those of marginalized identities. We map journalists' unmet needs to concrete design goals, which we use to build PressProtect, an interface that provides journalists greater agency when engaging with readers on Twitter/X. Through user testing with eight journalists, we evaluate PressProtect and find that participants felt it effectively protected them against harassment and could also generalize to serve other visible and vulnerable groups. We conclude with a discussion of our findings and recommendations for social platforms hoping to build defensive defaults for journalists facing online harassment.

Computers and Society,Human-Computer Interaction

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the paper attempts to solve

This paper aims to address the problem of journalists facing continuous online harassment on social media, especially more prominent among marginalized groups such as Asian - American and Pacific Islander (AAPI) journalists. Specifically:

1. **The extensiveness and seriousness of online harassment**:
- Journalists on social media platforms often suffer from different forms of online harassment such as personal attacks, doxxing, and threats of physical harm.
- These harassments not only affect journalists' mental health but may also lead to job burnout, psychological trauma, and even make them consider leaving the journalism industry.

2. **The insufficiency of existing tools and support**:
- The existing social media platform tools and newsroom resources are insufficient in protecting journalists, especially those journalists with marginalized identities.
- Existing tools such as the blocking function may be regarded as an obstacle to public information dissemination, so journalists are reluctant to use these tools.

3. **The conflict between professional standards and safety requirements**:
- Journalists need to abide by social platform policies, maintain an "active" and "authentic" online image, and at the same time fulfill their social responsibilities to convey information to the public.
- However, there is a tension between this participation requirement and their safety needs, making it difficult for journalists to manage their online presence.

### Solution: PressProtect

To solve these problems, the author designed and evaluated the PressProtect interface, aiming to help journalists use social media more effectively in the face of a large amount of harassment. The main features of PressProtect include:

- **Classifying comments**: Classify comments according to their relevance and toxicity. Relevant and toxic comments and irrelevant and toxic comments are hidden behind additional user - interface controls so that journalists can decide when to view or respond.
- **Automation tools**: Use large - language models (such as GPT - 3.5) to determine the relevance of comments and combine Google Jigsaw's toxicity classifier to judge the toxicity of comments.
- **Enhancing journalists' autonomy**: By providing more refined control options, journalists can better manage and respond to potentially harmful content.

### User testing and feedback

Through user testing of 8 journalists, the study found that PressProtect effectively protects journalists from harassment, especially those journalists reporting controversial topics (such as climate change or immigration issues). In addition, journalists believe that PressProtect can also be promoted for use among other public figures (such as politicians, celebrities).

In conclusion, through in - depth interviews and user testing, this paper reveals the specific needs of journalists for online harassment and proposes an effective solution to help them work more safely on social media.