Human-Centric and Integrative Lighting Asset Management in Public Libraries: Qualitative Insights and Challenges from a Swedish Field Study

Jing Lin,Per Olof Hedekvist,Nina Mylly,Math Bollen,Jingchun Shen,Jiawei Xiong,Christofer Silfvenius

2024-01-20

Abstract:Traditional lighting source reliability evaluations, often covering just half of a lamp's volume, can misrepresent real-world performance. To overcome these limitations,adopting advanced asset management strategies for a more holistic evaluation is crucial. This paper investigates human-centric and integrative lighting asset management in Swedish public libraries. Through field observations, interviews, and gap analysis, the study highlights a disparity between current lighting conditions and stakeholder expectations, with issues like eye strain suggesting significant improvement potential. We propose a shift towards more dynamic lighting asset management and reliability evaluations, emphasizing continuous enhancement and comprehensive training in human-centric and integrative lighting principles.

Other Statistics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### What problem does this paper attempt to solve?

This paper primarily explores the issues of human-centric and integrative lighting asset management in Swedish public libraries. Specifically:

1. **Limitations of traditional reliability assessments**:
- Traditional reliability assessments of lighting sources typically evaluate only half the volume of the bulb, leading to performance discrepancies in actual applications. This limited assessment method cannot fully reflect the performance in real-world scenarios.

2. **Gap between existing standards and actual needs**:
- Current standards and guidelines focus relatively narrowly when evaluating lighting systems, mainly concentrating on metrics like illuminance levels, while neglecting the diverse lighting needs and preferences of users.

3. **Poor actual performance of library lighting management**:
- The study found that despite libraries' intentions to create a good environment, there is a significant gap between actual lighting conditions and user expectations. Users, staff, and managers reported various issues such as eye fatigue and discomfort, indicating that there is considerable room for improvement in current lighting management.

4. **Insufficient consideration of dynamic needs**:
- The usage of library spaces is variable, with users potentially engaging in activities at different heights, areas, or near furniture, requiring unique lighting designs. However, existing standards often prescribe fixed measurement heights or distances, failing to fully adapt to actual usage patterns.

In summary, the paper aims to improve the lighting conditions in libraries by adopting advanced asset management methods, enhancing the understanding of human-centric and integrative lighting principles, and promoting continuous improvement. Additionally, the research emphasizes the need for a paradigm shift, not only in lighting asset management but also in reevaluating the reliability assessment standards of lighting sources.