Abstract:Ordinal learning (OL) is a type of machine learning models with broad utility in health care applications such as diagnosis of different grades of a disease (e.g., mild, modest, severe) and prediction of the speed of disease progression (e.g., very fast, fast, moderate, slow). This paper aims to tackle a situation when precisely labeled samples are limited in the training set due to cost or availability constraints, whereas there could be an abundance of samples with imprecise labels. We focus on imprecise labels that are intervals, i.e., one can know that the a sample belongs to an interval of labels but cannot know which unique label it has. This situation is quite common in health care datasets due to limitations of the diagnostic instrument, sparse clinical visits, or/and patient dropout. Limited research has been done to develop OL models with imprecise/interval labels. We propose a new Hybrid Ordinal Learner (HOL) to integrate samples with both precise and interval labels to train a robust OL model. We also develop a tractable and efficient optimization algorithm to solve the HOL formulation. We compare HOL with several recently developed OL methods on four benchmarking datasets, which demonstrate the superior performance of HOL. Finally, we apply HOL to a real-world dataset for predicting the speed of progressing to Alzheimer’s Disease (AD) for individuals with Mild Cognitive Impairment (MCI) based on a combination of multi-modality neuroimaging and demographic/clinical datasets. HOL achieves high accuracy in the prediction and outperforms existing methods. The capability of accurately predicting the speed of progression to AD for each individual with MCI has the potential for helping facilitate more individually-optimized interventional strategies. Note to Practitioners—Machine learning (ML) algorithms have been widely adopted to support disease diagnosis and prognosis. In some situations, the outcome variable of interest is on an ordinal scale, i.e., it includes several classes with a natural order. For example, the variable of interest can be the grade of a disease as mild, moderate, or severe; or it can be the progression speed of a disease as very fast, fast, moderate, or slow. Ordinal learning (OL) is the type of ML algorithms for ordinal variable prediction. Most existing OL algorithms can only include samples with precise labels in training. However, it is common to have samples with imprecise/interval labels, i.e., we know that a sample belongs to a range of classes/labels but do not know which specific class/label it belongs to. This situation can happen due to a variety of different reasons such as use of less accurate diagnostic instrument under cost or availability constraints, sparse clinical assessment, and patient dropout. We propose a Hybrid Ordinal Learner (HOL) to integrate samples with both precise and interval labels to train a robust OL model. HOL is evaluated using four public benchmarking datasets and shows superior performance compared to existing methods. Also, we apply HOL to a real-world dataset for predicting the speed of progressing to Alzheimer’s Disease (AD) for individuals with Mild Cognitive Impairment (MCI). MCI is the prodromal stage of AD. Individuals with MCI show noticeable signs of memory loss and cognitive declines, but these symptoms are not severe enough to interfere their independent living. HOL achieves high accuracy in predicting the speed of progressing to AD for each MCI subject (e.g., the speed of ‘very fast’‘, fast’‘, moderate’, or ‘slow), which could potentially help facilitate the development of more individually-optimized interventional strategies.

HOPE: Hybrid-granularity Ordinal Prototype Learning for Progression Prediction of Mild Cognitive Impairment

Identification of Outcome-Oriented Progression Subtypes from Mild Cognitive Impairment to Alzheimer’s Disease Using Electronic Health Records

Predicting the Pace of MCI Progression to AD Based on Multi‐modality Neuroimaging Data by a Novel Hybrid Ordinal Learning Algorithm

Early Prediction of Progression to Alzheimer's Disease using Multi-Modality Neuroimages by a Novel Ordinal Learning Model ADPacer

Early Prediction of Progression to Alzheimer’s Disease Using Multi-Modality Neuroimages by a Novel Ordinal Learning Model ADPacer

Hybrid Multimodality Fusion with Cross-Domain Knowledge Transfer to Forecast Progression Trajectories in Cognitive Decline

Investigating Predictors of Progression from Mild Cognitive Impairment to Alzheimer’s Disease Based on Different Time Intervals

Multi-modal Sequence Learning for Alzheimer's Disease Progression Prediction with Incomplete Variable-Length Longitudinal Data.

Machine Learning Approach for Improved Longitudinal Prediction of Progression from Mild Cognitive Impairment to Alzheimer’s Disease

Multi-modal sequence learning for Alzheimer’s disease progression prediction with incomplete variable-length longitudinal data

Prediction of Progressive Mild Cognitive Impairment by Multi-Modal Neuroimaging Biomarkers

Prediction Of Mild Cognitive Impairment to Alzheimer’s Disease Conversion Via Machine Learning

Rethinking modeling Alzheimer's disease progression from a multi-task learning perspective with deep recurrent neural network

Novel Iterative Attention Focusing Strategy for Joint Pathology Localization and Prediction of MCI Progression.

Deep Ordinal Ranking for Multi-Category Diagnosis of Alzheimer's Disease using Hippocampal MRI data

Predicting Future Clinical Changes of MCI Patients Using Longitudinal and Multimodal Biomarkers

High-Order Multi-Task Feature Learning to Identify Longitudinal Phenotypic Markers for Alzheimer's Disease Progression Prediction.

Integrating Static and Dynamic Data for Improved Prediction of Cognitive Declines Using Augmented Genotype-Phenotype Representations.

AD-BERT: Using Pre-trained contextualized embeddings to Predict the Progression from Mild Cognitive Impairment to Alzheimer's Disease

Tracking Progression from Mild Cognitive Impairment to Alzheimer's Disease Using Multivariate Biomarkers and Pattern Classification

A Novel Hybrid Ordinal Learning Model With Health Care Application