What Exactly is Antimatter (Gravitationally Speaking)?

Scott Menary

2024-01-19

Abstract:There has been renewed interest in the idea of antigravity -- that matter and antimatter repel gravitationally - in lieu of the recent beautiful ALPHA-g result for the free-fall acceleration of antihydrogen of $a_{\bar{H}}=(0.75\pm 0.13~({\rm stat.+syst.})\pm 0.16~({\rm simulation}))g$. Precision tests of the Weak Equivalence Principle (WEP) have shown that binding energy (atomic, nuclear, and nucleonic) acts like matter under gravity. Whereas the contribution of atomic binding energy to the mass of antihydrogen is negligible, the majority of the mass of the antiproton comes from the gluonic binding energy. Hence, in terms of antigravity, the antiproton is mostly composed of matter and so even if the antimatter content of the antiproton is repelled by the Earth, there would still be a net attraction of the antihydrogen to the Earth because of its dominant matter content. Using recent Lattice QCD results showing that around two-thirds of the mass of the proton (and, hence, from the $CPT$ Invariance of QCD, of the antiproton) is due to gluons, I find that in the antigravity scenario the free-fall acceleration of antihydrogen would be $a_{\bar{H}}=(0.33^{+0.10}_{-0.06})g$. The fact that antinucleons are more matter than antimatter (in the gravitational sense) leads to quite different cosmological consequences than the naive antigravity scenario (where antistars are wholly antimatter). For example, it follows naturally that there is a matter-antimatter asymmetry in the universe right from the instant of the Big Bang -- but not a baryon-antibaryon asymmetry. Again, this stems simply from the fact that antibaryons are more matter than antimatter.

General Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the behavior of antimatter under the influence of gravity, particularly the free-fall acceleration of antihydrogen atoms. By analyzing existing theoretical and experimental results, the authors aim to address the following key issues:

1. **The relationship between antimatter and gravity**: The paper discusses the concept of "antigravity," i.e., the gravitational repulsion between matter and antimatter, and examines whether this concept is reasonable.

2. **Composition of antiprotons**: The authors analyze the mass structure of antiprotons, pointing out that most of the mass in antiprotons is actually contributed by gluon binding energy. This portion of the mass behaves as "matter" under gravity, rather than "antimatter."

3. **Free-fall acceleration of antihydrogen atoms**: Based on the above analysis, the authors predict the free-fall acceleration of antihydrogen atoms in Earth's gravitational field and compare it with recent results from the ALPHA experiment.

Specifically, the paper addresses the following core issues:

- **Problem definition**: The paper attempts to determine the behavior of antimatter (particularly antihydrogen atoms) under the influence of gravity and how its internal composition affects this behavior.

- **Theoretical background**: The authors review relevant theories, including the equivalence principle in general relativity, the weak equivalence principle (WEP), and its impact on binding energy.

- **Experimental basis**: The paper cites results from the ALPHA experiment as key evidence, which demonstrated that the free-fall acceleration of antihydrogen atoms is close to that of normal matter.

- **Analytical methods**: The authors use the latest results from quantum chromodynamics (QCD) to estimate the proportion of the "antimatter" part in antiprotons.

- **Conclusion**: Through these analyses, the paper predicts that in an "antigravity" scenario, the free-fall acceleration of antihydrogen atoms is approximately \(0.33^{+0.10}_{-0.06}g\). This result shows some discrepancy with the ALPHA experiment but does not completely rule out the "antigravity" hypothesis. If future experiments can further reduce uncertainties, this hypothesis can be more clearly verified or refuted.

In summary, the core objective of the paper is to explore the behavior of antimatter under the influence of gravity through theoretical analysis and experimental data, particularly the free-fall acceleration of antihydrogen atoms, and to attempt to resolve the fundamental issues regarding the interaction between antimatter and gravity.