Orbital evolution of close binary systems: comparing viscous and wind-driven circumbinary disc models

George Turpin,Richard Nelson
2024-01-20
Abstract:Previous work has shown that interactions between a central binary system and a circumbinary disc (CBD) can lead to the binary orbit either shrinking or expanding, depending on the properties of the disc. In this work, we perform two-dimensional hydrodynamical simulations of CBDs surrounding equal mass binary systems that are on fixed circular orbits, using the Athena++ code in Cartesian coordinates. Previous studies have focused on discs where viscosity drives angular momentum transport. The aim of this work is to examine how the evolution of a binary system changes when angular momentum is extracted from the disc by a magnetised wind. In this proof-of-concept study, we mimic the effects of a magnetic field by applying an external torque that results in a prescribed radial mass flux through the disc. For three different values of the radial mass flux, we compare how the binary system evolves when the disc is either viscous or wind-driven. In all cases considered, our simulations predict that the binary orbit should shrink faster by a factor of a few when surrounded by a wind-driven circumbinary disc compared to a corresponding viscous circumbinary disc. In-spiral timescales of $\sim 10^6$-$10^7$yr are obtained for circular binaries surrounded by CBDs with masses typical of protoplanetary discs, indicating that significant orbital shrinkage can occur through binary-disc interactions during Class I/II pre-main sequence phases.
Earth and Planetary Astrophysics,Solar and Stellar Astrophysics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problems that this paper attempts to solve are: **In the protoplanetary disk, how does the interaction between the central binary star system and the circumbinary disc (CBD) affect the evolution of the binary star orbit? In particular, when the angular momentum is extracted from the disk through the magnetized wind rather than the turbulent viscosity, how will the evolution of the binary star system change?** ### Background and Motivation 1. **Prevalence of Binary Star Systems**: Approximately half of the solar - like main - sequence stars are located in multi - star systems, among which about 34% are binary star systems. The properties of these systems provide clues about their formation and evolution. 2. **Formation Mechanisms of Binary Star Systems**: Studies have shown that close systems may be formed through disk fragmentation, while wider systems may originate from the fragmentation of optically thin turbulent molecular cloud cores. 3. **Pre - main - sequence Binary Star Systems**: Pre - main - sequence binary star systems are also very common, and many young embedded systems show evidence of circumbinary matter. 4. **Evolution of Binary Star Orbits**: Pre - main - sequence binary star systems are usually surrounded by circumbinary disks, and the interaction between these disks and the binary stars may lead to orbital contraction or expansion. ### Research Objectives 1. **Compare the Effects of Different Angular Momentum Transport Mechanisms**: The researchers use two - dimensional hydrodynamic simulations to compare the differences in the evolution of binary star orbits when the angular momentum is extracted from the disk through the magnetized wind and the turbulent viscosity. 2. **Verify Theoretical Models**: Through simulations, verify the binary star orbit evolution rates predicted by theoretical models, especially in cases where the angular momentum transport mechanisms are different. 3. **Understand Disk - Binary Interaction**: Explore the impact of disk - binary interaction on the evolution of binary star orbits, especially in the pre - main - sequence stage. ### Methods 1. **Numerical Simulation**: Use the Athena++ code to conduct two - dimensional hydrodynamic simulations to simulate the evolution of equal - mass binary star systems on fixed circular orbits. 2. **Simulation Setup**: The simulation sets up three different types of experiments: - **Viscosity Calibration**: Calibrate the numerical viscosity by simulating a non - viscous ring diffusion experiment. - **Comparison with Previous Work**: Compare with the work of Tiede et al. (2020) to verify the consistency of the simulation results. - **Comparison between Viscous and Wind - Driven Disks**: Compare the effects of viscous disks and wind - driven disks on the evolution of binary star orbits. ### Main Findings 1. **Orbital Evolution Rate**: In all cases considered, the simulation predicts that when the binary star system is surrounded by a wind - driven circumbinary disk, the orbital contraction speed is several times faster than when it is surrounded by a viscous disk. 2. **Time Scale**: For circular - orbit binary stars surrounded by a typical protoplanetary disk mass, the time scale of spiral in - spiral is approximately 10^6 to 10^7 years, indicating that significant orbital contraction can occur through disk - binary interaction in the pre - main - sequence stage. ### Conclusions 1. **Importance of Angular Momentum Transport Mechanisms**: The angular momentum transport mechanism driven by the magnetized wind has an important impact on the evolution of binary star orbits and may lead to faster orbital contraction. 2. **Evolution in the Pre - main - sequence Stage**: In the pre - main - sequence stage, through disk - binary interaction, the orbits of close binary star systems can be significantly contracted, which provides theoretical support for explaining the frequency of observed close binary star systems. In summary, this paper explores the evolution of binary star orbits under different angular momentum transport mechanisms through detailed numerical simulations, providing new insights into the formation and evolution of binary star systems.