Generalized, sublethal damage-based mathematical model for improved prediction of clonogenic survival curve flattening upon hyperthermia, radiotherapy, and beyond

Adriana M. De Mendoza,Soňa Michlíková,Steffen Lange,Paula S. Castro,Anni G. Muñoz,Lisa Eckhardt,Leoni A. Kunz-Schughart

2024-08-03

Abstract:Mathematical modeling can offer valuable insights into the behavior of biological systems upon treatment. Different mathematical models (empirical, semi-empirical, and mechanistic) have been designed to predict the efficacy of either hyperthermia (HT), radiotherapy (RT), or their combination. However, mathematical approaches capable of modeling cell survival from shared general principles for both mono-treatments alone and their co-application are rare. Moreover, some cell cultures show dose-dependent saturation in response to HT or RT, manifesting in survival curve flattenings. An advanced survival model must, therefore, appropriately reflect such behavior. We propose a cell survival model to predict the effect of both treatments based on the general principle of sublethal damage (SLD) accumulation for the induction of cell death and irreversible proliferation arrest. Our approach extends Jung's model on heat-induced cellular inactivation by incorporating dose-dependent recovery rates that delineate changes in SLD restoration. The resulting unified model (Umodel) accurately describes not only HT but also RT survival outcomes, is applicable to simultaneous thermoradiotherapy modeling, and particularly suited to reproduce and predict survival curve flattening phenomena. We demonstrate the Umodel's robust performance (R2 > 0.95) based on numerous clonogenic cell survival data sets from the literature and our experimental studies.

Biological Physics,Medical Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: Existing mathematical models have limitations in predicting cell survival rates for hyperthermia (HT), radiotherapy (RT), and their combined treatment (i.e., thermoradiotherapy, TRT). Especially in the high - dose or low - survival - rate regions, these models are often unable to accurately describe the saturation phenomenon of the survival curve, such as the flattening of the survival curve. Therefore, the researchers proposed a unified model (Umodel) based on the principle of sublethal damage (SLD) accumulation to more accurately predict cell survival rates under these treatment modalities and be able to reflect the flattening phenomenon of the survival curve.

Specifically, several key points mentioned in the paper include:

1. **Limitations of existing models**:
- Although existing mathematical models (empirical models, semi - empirical models, and mechanistic models) can predict the effects of single treatments (HT or RT), when considering the combined application of the two treatments simultaneously, there is a lack of models starting from shared basic principles.
- Some cell cultures show a dose - dependent saturation response under the action of HT or RT, manifested as the flattening of the survival curve. Existing models are difficult to accurately reflect this behavior.

2. **The proposed new model**:
- The researchers proposed a cell survival model (Umodel) based on the principle of sublethal damage (SLD) accumulation. This model extends Jung's model and describes the change of SLD repair by introducing a dose - dependent recovery rate.
- Umodel is not only applicable to single treatments of HT and RT, but also can be used for the modeling of simultaneous thermoradiotherapy (TRT), and is especially suitable for reproducing and predicting the flattening phenomenon of the survival curve.

3. **Model verification**:
- The researchers verified the performance of Umodel through a large number of clonogenic cell survival data sets. The results show that this model has high accuracy (R² ≳ 0.95).
- Umodel performs particularly well when dealing with data in the low - survival - rate or high - dose regions and can better reflect phenomena such as thermal adaptation and high - dose radioresistance.

4. **Advantages of the model**:
- Umodel can not only accurately predict the single - treatment effects of HT and RT, but also effectively describe the changes in cell survival rates under combined treatment, especially the flattening phenomenon of the survival curve.
- Compared with the existing LQ model and other models, Umodel provides better results in some cases, especially when dealing with complex biological phenomena.

In summary, the main objective of this paper is to develop a new mathematical model to more accurately predict cell survival rates under HT, RT, and their combined treatment and be able to reflect the flattening phenomenon of the survival curve, thereby providing a more reliable basis for clinical treatment.