Domain Adaptation for Sustainable Soil Management using Causal and Contrastive Constraint Minimization

Somya Sharma,Swati Sharma,Rafael Padilha,Emre Kiciman,Ranveer Chandra
2024-01-14
Abstract:Monitoring organic matter is pivotal for maintaining soil health and can help inform sustainable soil management practices. While sensor-based soil information offers higher-fidelity and reliable insights into organic matter changes, sampling and measuring sensor data is cost-prohibitive. We propose a multi-modal, scalable framework that can estimate organic matter from remote sensing data, a more readily available data source while leveraging sparse soil information for improving generalization. Using the sensor data, we preserve underlying causal relations among sensor attributes and organic matter. Simultaneously we leverage inherent structure in the data and train the model to discriminate among domains using contrastive learning. This causal and contrastive constraint minimization ensures improved generalization and adaptation to other domains. We also shed light on the interpretability of the framework by identifying attributes that are important for improving generalization. Identifying these key soil attributes that affect organic matter will aid in efforts to standardize data collection efforts.
Machine Learning
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper aims to address the challenges faced in estimating organic matter (organic material) content using remote sensing data, particularly the issues of model adaptation and generalization across different regions. Specifically, the paper focuses on how to use Causal Constraint Minimization (CACM) and Contrastive Learning techniques, combined with limited soil sensor data, to improve the model's generalization ability in unobserved areas or conditions, thereby achieving sustainable soil management. ### Main Issues 1. **Cost Issue**: The cost of directly sampling and measuring soil organic matter is high, limiting widespread application. 2. **Data Availability**: Although remote sensing data is relatively easy to obtain, its resolution is low and may be affected by noise, leading to poor model performance. 3. **Model Generalization**: Existing models lack sufficient generalization ability across different regions or environments, making it difficult to adapt to new, unobserved areas. ### Solutions The paper proposes a multimodal, scalable framework that uses remote sensing data and limited soil sensor data to improve the model's generalization ability and adaptability through the following methods: - **Causal Constraint Minimization**: Retaining the causal relationship between sensor attributes and organic matter to ensure the model's generalization ability across different regions. - **Contrastive Learning**: Utilizing the intrinsic structure of the data to train the model to distinguish between different regions, further enhancing the model's generalization ability. - **Embedding Space Optimization**: Enhancing the model's adaptability to different environments through joint training of satellite image embeddings and soil attribute embeddings. ### Main Contributions 1. **Improved Generalization Ability**: By combining Causal Constraint Minimization and Contrastive Learning, the model can better generalize in unobserved areas. 2. **Data Utilization Efficiency**: Even without sensor data during the inference phase, the model's performance can be improved by using sensor data during the training phase. 3. **Enhanced Interpretability**: Identifying key soil attributes that affect organic matter helps standardize data collection methods and optimize soil management practices. ### Experimental Results - **Generalization Performance**: Experimental results show that the method combining Causal Constraint Minimization and Contrastive Learning performs best in unobserved areas, significantly reducing Mean Squared Error (MSE). - **Domain Adaptation**: Cross-validation across different geographical locations verifies the model's adaptability in different environments, especially when fine-tuning at the farthest locations. - **Sensitivity Analysis**: Using variable removal methods, key soil attributes that most affect the model's generalization ability, such as clay content and nitrates, are identified. In summary, the paper proposes an effective framework by combining Causal Constraint Minimization and Contrastive Learning, addressing the issue of insufficient generalization ability of remote sensing data across different regions, and providing strong support for sustainable soil management.