Finding critical transitions of the post-disaster recovery using the sensitivity analysis of agent-based models

Sangung Park,Jiawei Xue,Satish V. Ukkusuri

2024-01-13

Abstract:Frequent and intensive disasters make the repeated and uncertain post-disaster recovery process. Despite the importance of the successful recovery process, previous simulation studies on the post-disaster recovery process did not explore the sufficient number of household return decision model types, population sizes, and the corresponding critical transition conditions of the system. This paper simulates the recovery process in the agent-based model with multilayer networks to reveal the impact of household return decision model types and population sizes in a toy network. After that, this paper applies the agent-based model to the five selected counties affected by Hurricane Harvey in 2017 to check the urban-rural recovery differences by types of household return decision models. The agent-based model yields three conclusions. First, the threshold model can successfully substitute the binary logit model. Second, high thresholds and less than 1,000 populations perturb the recovery process, yielding critical transitions during the recovery process. Third, this study checks the urban-rural recovery value differences by different decision model types. This study highlights the importance of the threshold models and population sizes to check the critical transitions and urban-rural differences in the recovery process.

Computers and Society,Physics and Society

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### What problems does this paper attempt to solve?

This paper aims to reveal the Critical Transitions (CTs) in the post - disaster recovery process by using Agent - Based Models (ABM) and Multilayer Networks (MN), combined with sensitivity analysis. Specifically, the main objectives of the study are:

1. **Evaluate the impact of different types of resident return decision - making models and population sizes on the macro - patterns of the post - disaster recovery process**:
- Researchers introduced different Threshold Models, including the universal homogeneous, universal heterogeneous, individual heterogeneous, and time - varying threshold models, to simulate residents' return decisions.
- At the same time, the study also explored the impact of different population sizes on these models.

2. **Identify the conditions for critical transitions in the post - disaster recovery process**:
- Critical transitions refer to the phenomenon that the system suddenly changes from one state to another under small perturbations. The study hopes to find out the specific conditions that lead to such transitions through simulation and analysis.

### Research background and motivation

Frequent and intense natural disasters have made the post - disaster recovery process complex and full of uncertainties. Although successful post - disaster recovery is crucial, previous studies have not fully explored different types of resident return decision - making models, population sizes, and the corresponding system - critical transition conditions. Therefore, this study hopes to fill this research gap by introducing new models and methods and provide scientific basis for policy - makers to better cope with the challenges in the post - disaster recovery process.

### Main research contents

- **Introduce threshold models**: Threshold models can avoid the assumption of interchangeability between attributes and more accurately describe residents' return decisions.
- **Construct multilayer networks**: Multilayer networks are used to describe the interactions between different levels (such as family, society, physical infrastructure).
- **Simulate the post - disaster recovery process**: Simulate the post - disaster recovery process of five counties affected by Hurricane Harvey through Agent - Based Models, and analyze the urban - rural differences.
- **Sensitivity analysis**: Study the impact of different types of return decision - making models and population sizes on the post - disaster recovery process, and identify the conditions that may lead to critical transitions.

### Experimental design

Researchers designed a two - factor experiment to directly quantify the impact of different types of resident return decision - making models and population sizes on the post - disaster recovery process. Specific experimental settings include:

- **Toy network simulation**: Conduct preliminary simulations in a simplified small network to verify the validity and stability of the model.
- **Actual case analysis**: Apply the ABM - MN model to simulate the post - disaster recovery process of five Texas counties affected by Hurricane Harvey in 2017, and analyze the urban - rural differences.

Through these studies, the paper hopes to reveal the conditions for critical transitions in the post - disaster recovery process and provide theoretical support and practical guidance for future post - disaster recovery work.