Damping Separation of Finite Open Systems in Gravity-Related Experiments in the Free Molecular Flow Regime

Hou-Qiang Teng,Jia-Qi Dong,Yisen Wang,Liang Huang,Peng Xu
2024-01-10
Abstract:The residual gas damping of the test mass (TM) in the free molecular flow regime is studied in the finite open systems for high-precision gravity-related experiments. Through strict derivation, we separate the damping coefficients for two finite open systems, i.e., the bi-plate system and the sensor core system, into base damping and diffusion damping. This elucidates the relationship between the free damping in the infinite gas volume and the proximity damping in the constrained volume, unifies them into one microscopic picture, and allows us to point out three pathways of energy dissipation in the bi-plate gap. We also provide the conditions that need to be met to achieve this separation. In applications, for space gravitational wave detection, our results for the residual gas damping coefficient for the 4TM torsion balance experiment is the closest one to the experimental and simulation data compared to previous models. For the LISA mission, our estimation for residual gas acceleration noise at the sensitive axis is consistent with the simulation result, within about $5\%$ difference. In addition, in the test of the gravitational inverse-square law, our results suggest that the constraint on the distance between TM and the conducting membrane can be reduced by about $28\%$.
General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,Instrumentation and Detectors
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the residual gas damping problem of the test mass (TM) in the free - molecule - flow region in a finite open system in high - precision gravity - related experiments. Specifically, through rigorous derivations, the researchers separated the damping coefficients in two finite open systems (i.e., the double - plate system and the sensor core system) into basic damping and diffusion damping. This work not only clarifies the relationship between the free damping in an infinite gas volume and the near - field damping in a restricted volume, but also unifies the microscopic pictures of these damping phenomena and points out three energy dissipation paths in the double - plate gap. In addition, the study also provides the conditions required to achieve this separation. ### Key Point Summary: 1. **Problem Background**: In high - precision gravitational experiments, the random collisions of residual gas molecules around the test mass (TM) will limit the acceleration noise of TM, thus affecting the precision or sensitivity of the experiment. Therefore, accurately assessing environmental noise has become one of the key tasks in high - precision gravity - related experiments. 2. **Research Objectives**: Through rigorous derivations of finite open systems, separate the basic and diffusion parts of the damping coefficient, explain the relationship between free damping and near - field damping, and provide specific separation conditions. 3. **Main Contributions**: - **Separation of Damping Coefficient**: Decompose the damping coefficient into basic damping and diffusion damping, corresponding to the free damping in an infinite gas volume and the near - field damping in a restricted volume respectively. - **Unification of Microscopic Pictures**: Through the analysis of microscopic physical processes, unify the explanations of free damping and near - field damping. - **Energy Dissipation Paths**: Point out three energy dissipation paths in the double - plate gap, namely the damping force of incident molecules, the transfer of kinetic energy from molecules desorbed from the TM surface to the fixed plate, and the density change caused by the diffusion process. 4. **Application Examples**: - **Space - based Gravitational Wave Detection**: For the LISA mission, the residual gas acceleration noise estimated by the research results is consistent with the simulation results, with an error within 5%. - **Test of the Inverse - square Law of Gravity**: The research results show that when testing the inverse - square law of gravity, the distance constraint between TM and the conductive film can be reduced by about 28%. ### Formula Analysis: - **Power Spectral Density of Damping Force Noise**: \[ S_f(\omega)=4k_BT\text{Re}\left(-\frac{\partial F(\omega)}{\partial v(\omega)}\right)=4k_BT\text{Re}[Z(\omega)] \] where \(S_f(\omega)\) is the power spectral density of the fluctuating force on TM, \(k_B\) is the Boltzmann constant, \(T\) is the temperature, \(F\) is the damping force, \(v\) is the velocity of TM, and \(Z(\omega)\) is the mechanical impedance of the system. - **Change in Molecular Number Density in the Double - Plate Finite Open System**: \[ \frac{d\Delta n}{dt}=-\frac{\Delta n}{\tau_0}-\frac{n_0}{h_0}\frac{dh}{dt} \] where \(\tau_0\) is the diffusion time for molecule escape, \(h(t) = h_0 + B\cos(\omega t)\) is the gap spacing, and the general form of the solution is: \[ \Delta n=n_0B\omega\tau_0\frac{1}{h_0}\sqrt{1+\omega^2\tau_0^2}\cos(\omega t+\phi)+Ce^{-t/\tau_0} \] where \(\phi = (\arctan(1 / \omega\tau_0)-\pi)\in(-\pi,-\pi/2)\) is the phase angle, and \(C\) is the integration constant. - **Total Damping Coefficient**: \[ \beta_B=\left(4A_x+\pi\right)