Effect on New Loan Repayment Fine Clause on Bank Jaya Artha's Customer Satisfaction and Recommendation

Mustaqim Adamrah,Yos Sunitiyoso

DOI: https://doi.org/10.56472/25835238/IRJEMS-V2I4P185

2024-01-09

Abstract:The growing population of older people in Indonesia--the world's fourth-most populous country--makes a larger cake for the pension business, including in the banking sector. PT Bank Jaya Artha is one of the Indonesian banks that provide products and services for people who are set to enter retirement age. In the wake of tight competition in the pension business market, Bank Jaya Artha has since 2019 imposed a fine of three times of installments in addition to 5% of outstanding debt on customers planning to repay their debt in a mission to prevent them from leaving for competitors. While the clause is not included in loan agreements signed before the implementation, it applies to past loan agreements as well. This, in turn, has led to customer complaints. The research is meant to find out how the implementation of the unconsented clause has affected customer satisfaction and willingness to recommend the bank and what the bank should do to become more customer-centric, according to customers. Using a design thinking framework, the research collects quantitative and qualitative data from the bank's pension customers through questionnaires and forum group discussions. Statistical analysis is utilized on quantitative data from questionnaires, and content analysis is utilized on qualitative data from questionnaires. A narrative analysis is also used to explain qualitative data from forum group discussions. The result shows that there are problems in the way the bank communicates information to customers, particularly information about the loan repayment fine. Lack of transparency, a reactive approach instead of a proactive one, the obscurity of the information, and the time the information is delivered have affected customers' satisfaction toward the bank.

General Economics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper examines the impact of a new loan prepayment penalty clause introduced by Bank Jaya Artha, an Indonesian bank, on customer satisfaction and willingness to recommend in its pension business. Due to intense market competition, Bank Jaya Artha started imposing penalties on customers who make early loan repayment since 2019, which led to customer dissatisfaction and complaints. Using a design thinking framework, the study collected quantitative and qualitative data through questionnaire surveys and forum group discussions to analyze how the penalty clause affects customer satisfaction and how the bank can become more customer-centric.

The study found that the bank lacks transparency in communicating the penalty information, relies on reactive rather than proactive communication, provides ambiguous information, and discloses information at inappropriate times, which all lower customer satisfaction. Furthermore, the study suggests that although overall satisfaction is relatively high, the likelihood of recommending the bank is low, partially due to the bank's shortcomings in information dissemination, service quality, and penalty policies.

The paper recommends that the bank needs to communicate with customers more proactively and transparently, especially when changing loan policies, to ensure that customers understand and agree to these changes, and may need to refund affected customers. Key to improving customer satisfaction and willingness to recommend is to enhance information dissemination, improve service quality, and consider customers' emotional needs and sense of fairness.