Revisiting the Landau criterion: a hydrodynamic and holographic approach to superfluid instabilities

Filippo Sottovia
2024-01-09
Abstract:In this thesis we investigate the instabilities of superfluids at finite superflow by means of a hydrodynamical approach. We find that at a finite value of the background superfluid velocity a hydrodynamic collective mode crosses to the upper half complex frequency plane, thereby signalling a dynamical instability. At the same time, however, this instability is also thermodynamic, as its onset is controlled by one of the second derivatives of the free energy changing sign. We carry out our analysis in two main setups: the "probe limit", where the fluctuations of the temperature and the normal fluid's velocity are frozen, and a complete approach, which includes them. In both cases we test our results with the help of gauge-gravity duality, finding good agreement between the hydrodynamic modes of the boundary theory and the quasinormal modes of the gravity theory. Our criterion for the onset of the instability, which is formulated in a model-independent way, applies to interacting systems irrespective of the strength of interactions, does not rely on boost invariance and does not assume any specific quantum statistics. As a final check, we also show that it yields the Landau critical velocity for Galilean superfluids with Bose-Einstein quasiparticles.
High Energy Physics - Theory,Quantum Gases,Superconductivity
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the instability of superfluid at a finite superfluid velocity. Specifically, the paper re - examines the Landau criterion and uses hydrodynamic and holographic methods to study the instability of superfluid. The following is an overview of the main content of the paper: ### Research Background Superfluid is a state of matter, whose main characteristics are non - viscous flow and heat conduction. This state originates from the spontaneously broken U(1) continuous global symmetry below the critical temperature \(T_c\). The gradient of the Goldstone field associated with symmetry breaking determines the velocity of the superfluid. At a finite temperature, the superfluid and normal fluid components coexist, and both contribute to the charge flow. ### Landau Criterion Landau predicted that when the superfluid velocity exceeds a certain critical value, the superfluid will become unstable. He determined the critical velocity by assuming that the system has Lorentz invariance at low temperatures and that the normal fluid consists of free Bose quasiparticles with Bose - Einstein statistics. ### Hydrodynamic Method Hydrodynamics provides an effective method for describing interacting systems, which is applicable to time and space scales longer than the typical scales at which local thermal equilibrium is reached. In this paper, the author uses the hydrodynamic method to study the superfluid instability at a finite superfluid velocity. The specific findings are as follows: - A hydrodynamic collective mode crosses into the upper half of the complex frequency plane, which indicates the existence of a kinetic instability. - This instability is also thermodynamically unstable because its appearance is controlled by the change of sign of the second derivative of the free energy. ### Holographic Method To verify the results of the hydrodynamic method, the author uses the gauge - gravity duality (holographic method). Through numerical calculations, the author finds that there is consistency between the hydrodynamic modes in the boundary theory and the quasi - normal modes in the gravitational theory. This further verifies their instability criterion. ### Main Conclusions - The proposed instability criterion is expressed in the form of collective variables, which is applicable to systems with different interaction strengths, does not depend on Lorentz invariance, and does not assume any specific quantum statistics. - When this criterion is applied to Galilean superfluid with Bose - Einstein quasiparticles, it can reproduce the Landau critical velocity. ### Mathematical Expression The instability condition can be expressed as: \[ \partial_\xi (\xi n_s)=0 \] where \(\xi\) is the modulus of the spatial gradient of the Goldstone field, and \(n_s\) is the charge density of the superfluid. ### Summary This paper proposes a new criterion for determining the critical velocity of superfluid through hydrodynamic and holographic methods. This criterion is applicable not only to weakly - coupled systems but also to strongly - coupled systems, and can explain kinetic and thermodynamic instabilities. These results provide a new perspective for understanding the instability of superfluid.