One model to rule them all: magnetic braking from CVs to low-mass stars

Arnab Sarkar,Hongwei Ge,Lev Yungelson,Christopher A. Tout
2024-01-09
Abstract:We present the results of the study of cataclysmic variables (CVs) and AM Canum Venaticorum (AM CVn) stars with our double dynamo (DD) formalism of angular momentum loss (AML) by magnetic braking (MB). We show that (1) our MB model reproduces the period gap ($2\lesssim P_\mathrm{orb}/\,\mathrm{hr}\lesssim3$) and the period minimum spike ($P_\mathrm{orb}\approx 80\, \mathrm{min}$) in CV distribution, (2) evolved CVs, where the donor star commences Roche lobe overflow (RLOF) close to or just beyond the end of the main-sequence, populate the region in and beyond the period gap, and are more likely to be detected at $P_\mathrm{orb}\geq 5.5 \,\mathrm{hr}$. This contaminates the mass-radius fit of long-period CV donors. We show that (3) several evolved CVs become AM CVn stars with $10\lesssim P_\mathrm{orb}/\,\mathrm{min}\lesssim 65$. Their evolution, driven by $\mathrm{AML_{MB}}$ and AML by gravitational radiation (GR, $\mathrm{AML_{GR}}$), leaves them extremely H-exhausted to the point of being indistinguishable from AM CVn stars formed via the He-star and the White Dwarf (WD) channels in terms of the absence of H in their spectra. We further show that (4) owing to the presence of a significant radiative region, intermediate-mass giants/sub-giants, which are progenitors of AM CVn stars formed through the He-star channel, may undergo common envelope evolution that does not behave classically, (5) several AM CVn systems with extremely bloated donors, such as Gaia14aae, ZTFJ1637+49 and SRGeJ045359.9+622444 do not match any modelled trajectories if these systems are modelled only with $\mathrm{AML_{GR}}$, (6) the uncertainties in MB greatly affect modelling results. This, in turn, affects our efforts to distinguish between different AM CVn formation channels and their relative importance. Finally, we find that (7) a similar MB prescription also explains the spin-down of single, low-mass stars.
Solar and Stellar Astrophysics,High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problems that this paper attempts to solve mainly focus on the following aspects: 1. **Explain the role of the magnetic braking mechanism in binary star systems**: - The paper studied the role of magnetic braking (MB) in cataclysmic variables (CVs) and AM Canum Venaticorum (AM CVn) stars through the Double Dynamo (DD) model. Specifically, the paper showed how two α - Ω vortices (one located in the convective envelope and the other at the boundary between the radiative core and the convective envelope) can drive magnetic braking, thus explaining the period gap (2 ≲ \( P_{\text{orb}} \) /hr ≲ 3) and the period minimum spike (\( P_{\text{orb}} \) ≈ 80 min) in CVs. 2. **The distribution and characteristics of evolving CVs**: - The research found that when the donor star approaches or has just passed the end of the main - sequence stage and begins Roche lobe overflow (RLOF), these evolving CVs will fill the period gap and the regions beyond it, and are more likely to be detected at \( P_{\text{orb}} \) ≥ 5.5 hours. This may lead to the contamination of the mass - radius relationship of long - period CV donor stars. 3. **The formation channels of AM CVn stars**: - Some evolving CVs will become AM CVn stars, with orbital periods between 10 ≲ \( P_{\text{orb}} \) /min ≲ 65. These stars become extremely hydrogen - depleted due to angular momentum loss (caused by magnetic braking and gravitational wave radiation), so that hydrogen can hardly be detected in the spectrum, and are indistinguishable from AM CVn systems formed through the helium star and white dwarf channels. 4. **The common envelope evolution of intermediate - mass giant/sub - giant stars**: - Intermediate - mass giant or sub - giant stars (the precursors of AM CVn stars) may experience non - classical common envelope evolution, which is different from the classical model. The paper pointed out that this evolution may not occur on the dynamical time scale, but is a two - step process: a dynamical time - scale event plus a thermal time - scale event. 5. **The impact of magnetic braking uncertainty**: - The uncertainty in magnetic braking estimates has a great impact on the modeling results, which in turn affects the efforts to distinguish different AM CVn formation channels and their relative importance. The paper emphasized that the assumption of magnetic braking strength is crucial to these conclusions, and the magnetic braking strength varies greatly in different models. 6. **The spin - down of individual low - mass stars**: - The paper also explored how to use a similar magnetic braking model to explain the spin - down phenomenon of individual low - mass stars. In general, through detailed theoretical modeling and the comparison of observational data, this paper aims to comprehensively understand the role of magnetic braking in different types of binary star systems, especially the evolution processes of CVs and AM CVn stars.