Liouvillian exceptional points of an open driven two-level system

Nikhil Seshadri,Anqi Li,Michael Galperin
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1063/5.0177714
2024-01-09
Abstract:We study the applicability of the Liouvillian exceptional points (LEPs) approach to nanoscale open quantum systems. A generic model of the driven two-level system in a thermal environment is analyzed within the nonequilibrium Green's function (NEGF) and Bloch quantum master equation (QME) formulations. We derive the latter starting from the exact NEGF Dyson equations and highlight the qualitative limitations of the LEP treatment by examining the approximations employed in its derivation. We find that non-Markov character of evolution in open quantum systems does not allow for the introduction of the concept of exceptional points for a description of their dynamics. Theoretical analysis is illustrated with numerical simulations.
Quantum Physics,Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Chemical Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### What problem does this paper attempt to solve? This paper attempts to explore the effectiveness and limitations of using the Liouvillian Exceptional Points (LEPs) method in nanoscale open quantum systems. Specifically, the authors analyze the behavior of a driven two-level system in a thermal environment and study it using both the Non-Equilibrium Green's Function (NEGF) and the Bloch Quantum Master Equation (QME) methods. ### Main Issues and Objectives: 1. **Method Applicability**: - Evaluate the applicability of the Liouvillian Exceptional Points (LEPs) method in describing the dynamics of open quantum systems. - Compare the results of the NEGF and QME methods to explore the advantages and disadvantages under different approximations. 2. **Theoretical Limitations**: - Analyze the limitations of the Liouvillian method in dealing with non-Markovian evolution. - Compare the standard Hamiltonian Exceptional Points (HEPs) and Liouvillian Exceptional Points (LEPs) methods, highlighting their differences and complementarities. 3. **Numerical Simulations**: - Validate the performance of different methods under specific parameters through numerical simulations, especially the behavior of the system near exceptional points. - Explore how non-Markovian effects influence the dynamical properties of the system. ### Specific Issues: - **Non-Markovian Evolution**: - The characteristics of non-Markovian evolution make it difficult to introduce the concept of exceptional points. The authors validate this through numerical simulations and explain the underlying mathematical reasons. - **Approximation Methods**: - The authors discuss in detail the approximation steps required from the exact NEGF method to the approximate QME method, including the Rotating Wave Approximation (RWA) and the Markovian approximation. - **Experimental Comparison**: - Although theoretical analysis points out some potential issues, the authors emphasize that these analyses do not negate existing experimental observations but provide a theoretical basis for further understanding these experiments. ### Conclusion: - **Effectiveness of LEPs**: - The Liouvillian Exceptional Points (LEPs) method can effectively describe the dynamics of the system under the Markovian approximation but fails in the non-Markovian case. - **Theory and Experiment**: - Theoretical analysis can help understand experimental results, but it is also necessary to be aware of the errors and limitations that approximation methods may bring. In summary, this paper explores the application scope and limitations of the Liouvillian Exceptional Points method in open quantum systems through the study of a driven two-level system, providing an important theoretical foundation for future research.