On the Particle Acceleration Mechanisms in a Double Radio Relic Galaxy Cluster, Abell 1240

Arnab Sarkar,Felipe Andrade-Santos,Reinout J. van Weeren,Ralph P. Kraft,Duy N. Hoang,Timothy W. Shimwell,Paul Nulsen,William Forman,Scott Randall,Yuanyuan Su,Priyanka Chakraborty,Christine Jones,Eric Miller,Mark Bautz,Catherine E. Grant

2024-01-12

Abstract:We present a 368 ks deep Chandra observation of Abell~1240, a binary merging galaxy cluster at a redshift of 0.195 with two Brightest Cluster Galaxies (BCGs) may have passed each other 0.3 Gyr ago. Building upon previous investigations involving GMRT, VLA, and LOFAR data, our study focuses on two prominent extended radio relics at the north-west (NW) and south-east (SE) of the cluster core. By leveraging the high-resolution Chandra imaging, we have identified two distinct surface brightness edges at $\sim$ 1 Mpc and 1.2 Mpc NW and SE of the cluster center, respectively, coinciding with the outer edges of both relics. Our temperature measurements hint the edges to be shock front edges. The Mach numbers, derived from the gas density jumps, yield $\cal{M}_{\rm SE}$ = 1.49$^{+0.22}_{-0.24}$ for the South Eastern shock and $\cal{M}_{\rm NW}$ = 1.41$^{+0.17}_{-0.19}$ for the North Western shock. Our estimated Mach numbers are remarkably smaller compared to those derived from radio observations ($\cal{M}_{\rm SE}$ = 2.3 and $\cal{M}_{\rm NW}$ = 2.4), highlighting the prevalence of a re-acceleration scenario over direct acceleration of electrons from the thermal pool. Furthermore, we compare the observed temperature profiles across both shocks with that of predictions from collisional vs. collisionless models. Both shocks favor the Coulomb collisional model, but we could not rule out a purely collisionless model due to pre-shock temperature uncertainties.

High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena,Astrophysics of Galaxies

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is in the double radio relic regions in the Abell 1240 galaxy cluster, the specific process and efficiency of the particle acceleration mechanism. Specifically, the researchers hope to use high - resolution X - ray observation data, especially by analyzing two obvious surface brightness edges (located in the northwest and southeast directions), to explore whether these edges are shock fronts and further determine the Mach number of the shock. In addition, they also attempt to verify the thermodynamic behaviors involved in the particle acceleration process by comparing the temperature profiles predicted by different models with the actually observed temperature profiles, especially to distinguish the effectiveness of the collisional model and the collisionless model in explaining these phenomena.

### Research Background

- **Galaxy Cluster Mergers**: Galaxy cluster mergers are one of the largest - scale gravitational collapse structures in the universe and are crucial for understanding the evolution of the cosmic structure. A large amount of energy released during the merger process is partially converted into thermal energy, and at the same time, a small part of the energy (<1%) may be used to accelerate cosmic rays (CRs).
- **Radio Relics**: Radio relics are significant signs of galaxy cluster merger shocks, and synchrotron radiation emitted by accelerated cosmic rays can be detected through radio observations. The particle acceleration mechanism in low - Mach - number merger shocks is not fully understood yet, and there are two main theories: direct acceleration and re - acceleration.

### Research Objectives

1. **Determine the Shock Front**: Identify the position of the shock front by analyzing the X - ray surface brightness profile.
2. **Measure the Mach Number**: Derive the Mach number using the gas density jump and compare it with the radio observation results.
3. **Verify the Thermodynamic Model**: Verify which model is more in line with the actual situation by comparing the observed temperature profile with the predictions of the collisional model and the collisionless model.

### Main Findings

- **Shock Front Position**: The researchers identified two surface brightness edges in the northwest and southeast directions respectively, and these edges are considered to be shock fronts.
- **Mach Number**: The Mach numbers derived from the gas density jump are \( M_{\text{SE}} = 1.49^{+0.22}_{-0.24} \) and \( M_{\text{NW}} = 1.41^{+0.17}_{-0.19} \) respectively. These values are much lower than the Mach numbers derived from radio observations (\( M_{\text{SE}} = 2.3 \) and \( M_{\text{NW}} = 2.4 \)), which support the re - acceleration mechanism rather than the direct acceleration mechanism.
- **Thermodynamic Model**: The observed temperature profile is more in line with the prediction of the collisional model, but the possibility of the collisionless model cannot be completely excluded because the uncertainty of the pre - shock temperature is relatively large.

### Conclusion

The research results show that low - Mach - number shocks in the Abell 1240 galaxy cluster are more likely to accelerate electrons through the re - acceleration mechanism rather than direct acceleration from the thermal pool. This finding provides important clues for understanding the particle acceleration mechanism during the galaxy cluster merger process.