Semantic Computing for Organizational Effectiveness: From Organization Theory to Practice through Semantics-Based Modelling

Mena Rizk,Daniela Rosu,Mark Fox

2023-12-30

Abstract:A critical function of an organization is to foster the level of integration (coordination and cooperation) necessary to achieve its objectives. The need to coordinate and motivation to cooperate emerges from the myriad dependencies between an organization's members and their work. Therefore, to reason about solutions to coordination and cooperation problems requires a robust representation that includes the underlying dependencies. We find that such a representation remains missing from formal organizational models, and we leverage semantics to bridge this gap. Drawing on well-established organizational research and our extensive fieldwork with one of North America's largest municipalities, (1) we introduce an ontology, formalized in first-order logic, that operationalizes concepts like outcome, reward, and epistemic dependence, and their links to potential integration risks; and (2) present real-world applications of this ontology to analyze and support integration in complex government infrastructure projects. Our ontology is implemented and validated in both Z3 and OWL. Key features of our model include inferable dependencies, explainable coordination and cooperation risks, and actionable insights on how dependency structures within an organization can be altered to mitigate the risks. Conceptualizing real-world challenges like incentive misalignment, free-riding, and subgoal optimization in terms of dependency structures, our semantics-based approach represents a novel method for modelling and enhancing coordination and cooperation. Integrated within a decision-support system, our model may serve as an impactful aid for organizational design and effectiveness. More broadly, our approach underscores the transformative potential of semantics in deriving tangible, real-world value from existing organization theory.

Artificial Intelligence

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve

This paper aims to address the challenges of coordination and collaboration within organizations. Specifically, it explores how semantic technologies can enhance organizational coordination and collaboration in complex, large-scale infrastructure projects. The specific problems the paper attempts to solve are as follows:

1. **Representation of Dependencies**:
- Current organizational models lack effective methods for representing dependencies (such as knowledge dependencies, outcome dependencies, and reward dependencies). These dependencies are crucial for understanding and addressing coordination and collaboration issues.

2. **Need for Automated Reasoning**:
- There is a need for a formal representation method that can support automated reasoning to identify coordination needs and collaboration risks, and help organizations recognize and manage these risks.

3. **Practical Application Case**:
- Using the example of a government in a major North American city, the paper demonstrates how semantic technologies and decision support systems can be used to address specific coordination issues, particularly the coordination challenges in a flood control project.

4. **Formalization of Dependencies**:
- The paper introduces a formalization method based on first-order logic to describe different types of dependencies and their impact on coordination and collaboration.

5. **Development of Decision Support System**:
- Based on the aforementioned formalization method, a proof-of-concept decision support system was developed. This system can automatically identify coordination needs and collaboration risks and propose improvement measures.

Through these efforts, the paper attempts to fill the gaps in existing organizational theory in practice and demonstrate the potential of semantic technologies in solving real-world organizational problems.