Evaluation of Rayleigh-Corrected Reflectance on Remote Detection of Algal Blooms in Optically Complex Coasts of East China Sea

Chengxin Zhang,Bangyi Tao,Yunzhou Li,Libo Ai,Yixian Zhu,Liansong Liang,Haiqing Huang,Changpeng Li
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/rs16132304
IF: 5
2024-06-24
Remote Sensing
Abstract:This study used GOCI-II data to systematically evaluate the feasibility of Rayleigh-corrected reflectance (Rrc) to detect algal blooms in the complex optical environment of the East China Sea (ECS). Based on long-term in situ remote sensing reflectance (Rrs), Rrc spectra demonstrated the similar capability of reflecting the water condition under various atmospheric conditions, and the baseline indices (BLIs) derived from Rrc and Rrs showed good consistency (R2 > 0.98). The effectiveness of five Rrc-based BLIs (SS490, CI, DI, FLH, and MCI) for algal bloom detection was assessed, among which SS490 and MCI showed better performances. A synthetic bloom detection algorithm based on the BLIs of Rrc was then developed to avoid the impact of turbid water. The validation of the BLI algorithm was carried out based on the in situ algal abundance data from 2021 to 2023. Specifically, SS490 showed the best bloom detection result (F-measure coefficient, FM = 0.97), followed by MCI (FM = 0.88). Since the 709 nm bands used in MCI were missing in many ocean color satellites, the SS490 algorithm was more useful in application. Compared to Rrs based bloom detection algorithms, synthetical Rrc BLI proposed in this paper provides more effective observation results and even better algal bloom detection performance. In conclusion, the study confirmed the feasibility of utilizing Rrc for algal bloom detection in the coastal areas of the ECS, and recognized the satisfactory performance of synthetical SS490 by comparing with the other BLIs.
environmental sciences,imaging science & photographic technology,remote sensing,geosciences, multidisciplinary
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the feasibility of using Rayleigh - corrected reflectance (Rrc) for algal bloom detection in the complex optical environment along the East China Sea coast in China. Specifically, the paper aims to: 1. **Evaluate the spectral characteristics of Rrc in different optical water types**: Investigate whether Rrc can effectively reflect changes in water quality under different optical conditions, especially in complex coastal waters. 2. **Develop a comprehensive baseline algorithm based on Rrc**: For identifying micro - algal blooms along the East China Sea coast in China, especially how to avoid the influence of turbid water bodies. 3. **Verify the effectiveness of different Rrc baseline indices in algal bloom detection**: By comparing with in - situ algal abundance data, evaluate the performance of different baseline indices (such as SS490, CI, DI, FLH and MCI) in algal bloom detection. ### Background and Motivation - **Harmful Algal Blooms (HABs)**: It is an ecological anomaly, manifested as the rapid reproduction and aggregation of micro - phytoplankton, leading to increasingly serious ecological problems in coastal areas around the world. - **Development of satellite remote sensing technology**: In recent years, the spatial and temporal resolution of ocean - color satellite remote sensing has been significantly improved, making it possible to monitor and characterize the location and extent of HABs from space. - **Challenges of atmospheric correction**: In coastal or estuarine areas with complex optical environments, reliably obtaining remote - sensing reflectance (Rrs) still faces challenges, mainly due to uncertainties in atmospheric correction schemes, such as inaccurate assumptions of water signals in the near - infrared band and inaccurate assumptions of relationships between different spectral bands. - **Advantages of Rrc**: Rrc has the following advantages by correcting the top - level atmospheric path radiation received by the sensor and removing the effects of ozone absorption and molecular (Rayleigh) scattering: - Rrc can be calculated more accurately, even considering polarization effects. - Rrc is less sensitive to atmospheric correction failures and can significantly improve data coverage without complex aerosol removal steps. - The coverage of Rrc can even be extended to severe solar glare areas, successfully deriving color patterns. ### Research Methods - **Data sources**: Use Level - 2 data of Geostationary Ocean Color Imager - II (GOCI - II), including Rayleigh - corrected reflectance (Rrc) and fully atmospherically - corrected remote - sensing reflectance (Rrs) data. - **In - situ data**: Include long - term spectral measurement data from the Dongou Marine Observation Platform and ship - borne hyperspectral radiometric measurement data during the LORCE cruise. - **Baseline subtraction algorithm**: Calculate the reflectance heights of different bands through the baseline subtraction algorithm to distinguish between algal - bloom waters and non - algal - bloom waters. ### Main Results - **Spectral characteristics**: Rrc shows obvious spectral differences in different types of water bodies. Especially in algal - bloom waters, the negative spectral shape near 490 nm (positive SS490) and the peaks in the 680 nm or 709 nm bands (positive FLH or MCI) are particularly significant. - **Effectiveness of baseline indices**: SS490 and MCI perform best in algal bloom detection. Among them, the F - measure coefficient of SS490 reaches 0.97, and that of MCI is 0.88. - **Data coverage**: The data coverage of Rrc is approximately 20% higher than that of Rrs. Especially in turbid water bodies and algal - bloom waters with high chlorophyll concentrations, Rrc is more stable and effective. ### Conclusions The paper confirms the feasibility of using Rrc for algal bloom detection in the complex optical environment along the East China Sea coast in China. And by comparing with other baseline indices, it recommends SS490 as the most effective Rrc baseline index for accurately identifying micro - algal blooms.