Abstract:Although there are several explanations for why one succeeds or fails, effort and ability are the major causes that students report. The purpose of the present study was to measure the perceptions of 149 college freshmen enrolled in a university honors program about their skills in 15 talent areas. In addition, this study explored the relationship of interests and ability and effort attributions with self-efficacy and investigated gender differences in these perceptions. There was a positive relationship between students’ interest in a talent area and their assessment of their skill in that area. The strongest relationships tended to be in nonacademic areas. For some talents, males placed stronger attributions on the role that natural ability played, whereas females indicated that personal effort contributed to high levels of performance. Participants’ implicit theory of intelligence did not appear to influence their perceptions of the importance of ability in academic performance. Putting the Research to Use Educators and parents must recognize the important role interest plays in student achievement. Interest is one of the single best predictors of high performance in a variety of talent areas. For gifted students to sustain the effort necessary to reach high levels of academic rigor, they must either be interested in the topic or find the task meaningful. Educators may need to modify their instruction and curriculum to capitalize on student interests. Gifted students appear to be aware of their high ability and view it as contributing to their success. Although some researchers have cautioned against recognizing student ability at the peril of diminishing the importance of effort, educators and parents should not be fearful of discussing the role ability plays in gifted students’ performances, while also emphasizing the importance of hard work and perseverance.

An Emerging Professional Identity: Influences on the Achievement of High-Ability First-Generation College Females

Supporting First-Generation Students’ Adjustment to College With High-Impact Practices

First-Generation College Students’ Academic Challenges Understood Through the Lens of Expectancy Value Theory in an Introductory Psychology Course

Profiles of First-Generation College Students: Social, Financial, Academic, and Cultural Barriers to College Lives

Influences on Career Development for Gifted Adolescent Girls in Selective Academic Programs in Australia

Exploring the Relationship of College Freshmen Honors Students’ Effort and Ability Attribution, Interest, and Implicit Theory of Intelligence With Perceived Ability

First‐generation college students' funds of knowledge support the development of an engineering role identity

Motivation, College Integration, and Intentions to Persist Among First-Generation College Students: A Latent Class Approach

Nurturing a College-Going Identity in Black Emerging Adults

Factors Influencing the Development of Perfectionism in Gifted College Students

First-generation students in rural communities: A study of effective programming components that support closing the excellence gap

Understanding the Relationship Between Perfectionism and Achievement Motivation in Gifted College Students

Experiences, Supports, and Strategies of First-Generation College Students

Perceptions of talented university students related to opportunities and autonomy for creative productivity

Talent Ignored, Talent Diverted: The Cultural Context Underlying Giftedness in Females

We Can't Change What We Don't Recognize: Understanding the Special Needs of Gifted Females

Exploring the development of students’ identities as educational leaders and educational researchers in a professional practice doctoral program

Understanding the Nuances of First-Generation College Students: How the Culture of College Factors Into Academic Success

How Personal and Familial Narratives Affect the Decision Making of Mature-Aged First-in-Family Students Pursuing University

Gifted High-School Students' Perspectives on the Development of Perfectionism

Perfectionism in Gifted High-School Students: Responses to Academic Challenge