Abstract:Model-combining (i.e., mixing) methods have been proposed in recent years to deal with uncertainty in model selection. Even though advantages of model combining over model selection have been demonstrated in simulations and data examples, it is still unclear to a large extent when model combining should be preferred. In this work, first we propose an instability measure to capture the uncertainty of model selection in estimation, called perturbation instability in estimation (PIE), based on perturbation of the sample. We demonstrate that estimators from model selection can have large PIE values and that model combining substantially reduces the instability for such cases. Second, we propose a model combining method, adaptive regression by mixing with model screening (ARMS), and derive a theoretical property. In ARMS, a screening step is taken to narrow down the list of candidate models before combining, which not only saves computing time, but also can improve estimation accuracy. Third, we compare ARMS with EBMA (an empirical Bayesian model averaging) and model selection methods in a number of simulations and real data examples. The comparison shows that model combining produces better estimators when the instability of model selection is high and that ARMS performs better than EBMA in most such cases in our simulations. With respect to the choice between model selection and model combining, we propose a rule of thumb in terms of PIE. The empirical results support that PIE is a sensible indicator of model selection instability in estimation and is useful for understanding whether model combining is a better choice over model selection for the data at hand.

To combine or not to combine: selecting among forecasts and their combinations

To combine or not to combine? issues of combining forecasts

To Combine Forecasts or to Combine Information?

Forecast combinations: An over 50-year review

Optimizing accuracy and diversity: a multi-task approach to forecast combinations

Optimal Portfolio Choice under Decision-Based Model Combinations

Tourism forecasting: To combine or not to combine?

Forecast with Forecasts: Diversity Matters

Statistical efficiency in the linear combination of forecasts

Forecast combination in agricultural economics: Past, present, and the future

Combining Linear Regression Models

Another look at forecast trimming for combinations: robustness, accuracy and diversity

On the Forecast Combination Puzzle

Comparison of selection and combination strategies for demand forecasting methods

Combining information from independent sources through confidence distributions

Forecast Combination under Heavy-Tailed Errors

Adaptive combinations of tail-risk forecasts

Infinite forecast combinations based on Dirichlet process

Is Single Forecast Method Better than Combined Forecast Method?

Forecasting in data-rich environments

Flexible global forecast combinations