Abstract:The competition for limited urban spaces due to the growing demand for both living space and green areas causes conflicts in urban development. This paper aims to support urban planners with a systematic multi-criteria decision making process and a supporting tool-chain. The process uses multi-objective optimization (MOO) to quantify trade-offs, allowing planners to gain a broad perspective on optimal solutions. The generic process builds an urban simulation model, applies MOO, explores the results in terms of multi-criteria trade-offs, and guides the decision making of urban planners. To enable this process, we present a tool-chain for applying a Gaussian Process Regression based MOO algorithm to a computationally expensive urban simulation model. The tool-chain allows to identify Pareto-optimal solutions and their properties with reasonable computational effort. A case study model is set up in the Grasshopper environment and couples simulation components for outdoor thermal comfort and Life Cycle Assessment. It allows to identify multi-objective trade-offs for a high-dimensional space of urban configuration degrees of freedom such as outdoor vegetation, photovoltaics, and building characteristics. We compare the workflow results to other MOO algorithms and show how it can support decision making in urban planning at early design phases. In our case study, the tool chain was able to investigate the multi dimensional space of urban configurations. It systematically identified Pareto-optimal solutions therein and reduced the number of model evaluations significantly. The case study results showcase the trade-off between lifecycle-based global warming potential (GWP) and outdoor thermal comfort. We identified the number of trees and the coverage of the east and west façades with photovoltaics as the most sensitive parameters. The proposed process proves to be a powerful multi-criteria decision support tool for urban planners. It allows to identify and quantify the Pareto Front of competing urban target trade-offs at early design phases. Additionally, it visualizes them according to the boundary conditions of urban development. The input configurations of the obtained Pareto-solutions serve as a base of urban planning recommendations. In our case study, trees and photovoltaics prove to be good leverage points in the area of GWP optimal solutions. However, urban planners need to carefully coordinate inputs when aiming for a specific trade-off balance. The tool-chain and the simulation model offer further potential for investigating neighborhood typologies. Thereby, applicants can derive scalable guidance to support the sustainable transformation of the urban environment.

Transitioning complex socioeconomic modeling to informed and visualized decision-making: A tightly coupled planning support system

Tightly Coupling Input Output Economics with Spatio-Temporal Land Use in a Dynamic Planning Support System Framework

Appropriate Modelling in DSSs for River Basin Management

A Dynamic and Spatially Explicit Modeling Approach to Identify the Ecosystem Service Implications of Complex Urban Systems Interactions

Multi-scenario simulation of land use and land cover based on shared socioeconomic pathways: The case of coastal special economic zones in China

Sociohydrology modeling for complex urban environments in support of integrated land and water resource management practices

Modeling the United Oscillation and Wave of economic policy and urban planning employing spatial population dynamics

The development of a novel decision support system for regional land use planning for brownfield land

Integration of multi-scale dynamic spatial models of socio-economic and physical processes for river basin management

A Coupled SD and CLUE-S Model for Exploring the Impact of Land Use Change on Ecosystem Service Value: A Case Study in Baoshan District, Shanghai, China

Dynamic Urban Planning: an Agent-Based Model Coupling Mobility Mode and Housing Choice. Use case Kendall Square

The Integration of Dual Evaluation and Minimum Spanning Tree Clustering to Support Decision-Making in Territorial Spatial Planning

Integrating Land Use and Socioeconomic Factors into Scenario-Based Travel Demand and Carbon Emission Impact Study

Urban systems exploration: A generic process for multi-objective urban planning to support decision making in early design phases

Spatial modeling and design of smart communities

From scenario to roadmap: Design and evaluation of a web-based participatory watershed planning system for optimizing multistage implementation plans of management practices under stepwise investment

A Framework of Planning Support System and Its Apllications

Dynamics of Land Use/Land Cover (LULC) Considering Ecosystem Services for a Dense-Population Watershed Based on a Hybrid Dual-Subject Agent and Cellular Automaton Modeling Approach

Spatial dynamic modeling and urban land use transformation: a simulation approach to assessing the costs of urban sprawl

Synergies and trade-offs in achieving sustainable targets of urban renewal: A decision-making support framework

Modeling Production-Living-Ecological Space for Chengdu, China: an Analytical Framework Based on Machine Learning with Automatic Parameterization of Environmental Elements